A place among the greats....I'm sorry but I'm surprised that there's even a question about this. She's not one of the 'Greats'. She did well on one night and yes her name will be listed under Olympic champion but that's it. This is not to say it's over. If she comes back and win Nat more than once and Worlds then I would say there's a big chance.
A better question is would the skating world list Tara amongst the greats? Tara has titles under her belt but she's taken a lot of criticism.