What are your PCs for the men? | Golden Skate

What are your PCs for the men?

enlight78

Medalist
Joined
Nov 2, 2005
Here's my PCs for the top three.
Plushenko
skating skills 8.5
Transitions 6.8
P/E 8.0
Choreography 6.8
Interpitation 7.0

Lambiel
S/S 7.8
T 7.6
P/E 7.7
C 7.8
I 8.0

Buttle
skating skills
S/S 8.3
T 7.8
P/E 7.5
C 8.1
I 8.4
 
Last edited:

childfreegirl

Final Flight
Joined
Jan 6, 2004
I won't break it down like that, but I have some general observations.

Joubert was overmarked. He had everything in the 7s and IMO, they should've been in the 6s.

Van Der Perren was undermarked. He had 6's and should've had 7s.

Shawn Sawyer was undermarked. Again, he had 6's and should've had 7s.

Sandhu, IMO, was slightly overmarked in some areas. Skating skills were great, transitions were good, but the fire just wasn't there.

Dinev was possibly undermarked.

I realize a lot of this still has to do with reputation and international exposure. Sad, sad, sad.
 

Engwaciriel

On the Ice
Joined
Dec 27, 2005
childfreegirl said:
I won't break it down like that, but I have some general observations.

Joubert was overmarked. He had everything in the 7s and IMO, they should've been in the 6s.
.

Still it was a step in the right direction with Joubert, before he's had higher scores than Lambiel, which I really can't understand. But now they were lower..
 
Top