Tribute to Alexei Yagudin---Passion for Skating

Kelly22 · Feb 20, 2006

Vash01 said:
I totally disagree that Plushenko did not stand a chance against Yagudin. "

Agreed, style is a matter of taste. If Yagudin skated clean, he was unbeatable, in large part, because his programs were superior. Winter will go down in skating history as one of the best programs, ever.

It's great that Plushenko is your favorite skater, he is definitely outstanding. The 6.0 slam diminished the validity of your point.

PS (reason for edit). On this we can agree, Yagudin and Plushenko competing together raised the bar in mens figure skating. It was a nail biting rivalry that we may not see again for quite a while.

Vash01 · Feb 20, 2006

JaeJ said:
Vash01, do you have citations to support the contention that Pluskenko won more head to head comps than Yagudin? I'm really interested because -- except for the Russian Nationals, where Plushenko was always favored -- my impression was just the opposite -- I could be thinking only of international comps, though ... I'll check for sources as well and share if I find any. Thanks!

ETA: Okay, here is what I found at the US Figure Skating Association: out of ten international figure skating events in which both Yagudin and Plushenko participated between the 1998 Worlds and 2002 OLYs, including GPFs and Goodwill Games, Yagudin outscored Plushenko seven out of ten times. The three times that Plushenko outscored Yagudin all occurred in 2001 -- Worlds, GPF, and Goodwill.

I was unable to find results of European Finals because ISU's website shows the results in the language of the country that hosted the Finals. I do know that Yagudin never won a Russian National title, so I assume that those results would favor Plushenko.

If you are able to find the European Finals website w/English translation, I'd love to see it (I know, I'm a total geek!). Thanks!

I did count the Russian nationals. However, I was thinking more of their competitions leading into the 2002 Olympics (that is, 2000-2002) because in 1998 Plushenko went to his first worlds and did not skate in the Olympics. I don't remember the results of all the GP's but in 1999-2000 he won all but the worlds (he fell apart in the LP). He won all the competitions after that (Yagudin may not have been in all of them) until 2002 GPF which he lost to Yagudin. It was a close competition, which could have gone either way.

The real point I was trying to make was that Yagudin was not unbeatable as the original poster wrote. Yagudin was the more developed skater of the two at that point, but he had been beaten by Plushenko many times particularly in the two years before the Olympics. Plushenko was in fact the reigning world champion at the 2002 Olympics.

Vash

soogar · Feb 20, 2006

Shanti said:
Thanks for the thread!

I still miss him (and Sasha Abt ) so much whenever I watch Men's events

Russian Fed should have made a deal with Abt to keep him in competition. He would have had decent results (even without a quad).

Evdokia · Feb 20, 2006

Zanzibar said:
Hee-hee...I think the conversation was something like:

Me: Can you believe how adorable Sasha Abt is? Have you ever see a Russian as adorable as that man? Maybe we should take some pictures of you and Sahsa TOGETHER! Sasha, Sasha, Sasha!

Alexei: (Heavy Russian accent): "My ears are going to bleed, please stop saying that word!"

And that name! :rofl:

soogar said:
Russian Fed should have made a deal with Abt to keep him in competition. He would have had decent results (even without a quad).

I too think so, I wish he had not decided to retire!

Boy, he could have so easily made it on the podium in Turino. However, unfortunately Russian Fed - at least prior to 2002 - more likely did everything to make him quit his eligible career instead of encouraging him to hang on.

For the Sasha fans here: please sign in the yahoo-group my friend Irene has set up for Sasha - there are lots of pics of him skating in shows, but also from other skaters (Alexej included).

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Alexander-Abt/

JaeJ said:
On a side note, I've always wondered why Yagudin never won a Russian title, even when he was winning everything else in sight ... seems odd, but people probably wondered the same thing about Sasha Cohen until last month!

Alexej never won a Russian National title simply because of skating badly at that event. :biggrin:

Some of his worst competitive performances usually happened to be Russian Nationals. Actually he was even lucky to make the team at times. And even on those rare occasions, when Alexej skated good at Nationals, Plush skated better hands down. I think unlike Plushy, Alexej simply didn’t care for Nationals, he knew, he would be on the team, no matter how he skated and so he decided to save his energy for major events like Worlds or the Olympics.

Vash01 said:
Agreed, style is a matter of taste. If Yagudin skated clean, he was unbeatable, in large part, because his programs were superior. Winter will go down in skating history as one of the best programs, ever.

YES!!!

CzarinaAnya · Feb 20, 2006

I never said Evgeni, was unbeatable.

Alexei's passion for the sport outranks any male figure skater I've come across, though. His programs could bring people to tears. I truly don't dislike Evgeni, at all. It's just that I can't find that extra something in his skating, that Alexei shows. His skating motto always seemed to be, "the show must go on".

JaeJ · Feb 20, 2006

Vash01 said:
I did count the Russian nationals. However, I was thinking more of their competitions leading into the 2002 Olympics (that is, 2000-2002) because in 1998 Plushenko went to his first worlds and did not skate in the Olympics. I don't remember the results of all the GP's but in 1999-2000 he won all but the worlds (he fell apart in the LP). He won all the competitions after that (Yagudin may not have been in all of them) until 2002 GPF which he lost to Yagudin. It was a close competition, which could have gone either way.

The real point I was trying to make was that Yagudin was not unbeatable as the original poster wrote. Yagudin was the more developed skater of the two at that point, but he had been beaten by Plushenko many times particularly in the two years before the Olympics. Plushenko was in fact the reigning world champion at the 2002 Olympics.

Vash

Yagudin did go into total melt-down in 2001, losing all of the major competitions to Plushenko (2001 is the only year in which this occurred however). It is my understanding that this disastrous season led Yagudin to a renewed discipline toward his game, which made him *cough* unbeatable by 2002. Just MHO (smile).

Please see the following list of comps in which Y and P went head to head. Note that I list only the results of the Grand Prix Finals, not the individual GP comps, which may be contributing to the confusion on this matter. These results are taken directly from http://www.usfigureskating.org/Events.asp.

1998 Worlds/Yag = 1st/Plush = 3rd
1998 Goodwill Games/Yag = 2nd/Plush = 3rd
1999 Grand Prix Final/Yag = 1st/Plush = 3rd
1999 Worlds/Yag = 1st/Plush = 2rd
2000 Worlds/Yag = 1st/Plush = 4th
2001 GPF/Yag = 2nd/Plush = 1st
2001 Worlds /Yag = 2nd/Plush = 1st
2001 Goodwill Games/Yag = 3rd/Plush = 1st
2001/02 GPF/Yag = 1st/Plush = 2nd
2002 Olympics /Yag = 1st/Plush = 2nd

Also -- did Plushenko win all the Russian Nationals from 1998 to 2002? if so, that is an incredible feat! I also agree with the other posters who said that Y and P drove themselves and their sport to new highs. I honestly believe that 1998-2002 will be looked back upon as the golden age of Men's figure skating, due largely to the competition between Y and P.

Evdokia · Feb 20, 2006

JaeJ said:
Also -- did Plushenko win all the Russian Nationals from 1998 to 2002? if so, that is an incredible feat!

Plushenko won Russian Nationals in 1999, 2000, 2001 and 2002 (Yagudin placed 2nd that years), in 1998 Ilia Kulik won.

JaeJ · Feb 20, 2006

Evdokia said:
Plushenko won Russian Nationals in 1999, 2000, 2001 and 2002 (Yagudin placed 2nd that years), in 1998 Ilia Kulik won.

Thank you for this info, and also for your earlier explanation as to why Yagudin failed to ever win a Russian National gold. Interesting that he never went "all out" for that title -- I think he may have regretted it later in his career. I remember an interview after either his OGM or his 2002 Worlds performance where the commentator said something like, "Now that you've won it all -- Europeans, Worlds, and now Olympics, what are your plans," and he interrupted her to say, "no, I've never won the Russian title." It made me think that it bothered him at least a little that the one title had eluded him for so long ...

Germanice · Feb 20, 2006

What I find amazing is that Yagudin still had some his most passionate and memorable performances in his so-called *meltdown* season 2000/2001, just remember "Gladiator" at Skate Canada 2000, "Gladiator" at Euros 2001 and "Revolution Etude" at Worlds 2001. :rock:

It's kinda ironic/sad though he never won anything "big" with his probably greatest LP, "Gladiator". I wonder how many people will remind Plushenko's programs of this particular season?

Anke

Kelly22 · Feb 21, 2006

Anke,

Was Overcome ever an LP or always an exhibition number? Overcome is my true all time favorite. One memorable performances was Hallmark 2002 (I think 2002).

Germanice · Feb 21, 2006

Kelly, "Overcome" was an exhibition program only during the (eligible) season 2001/2002, but later he skated it in several Pro/Pro-Am events also; Hallmark was one of them. Another great, intense & comparable performance of it was at Sears Open 2003.

Anke

JaeJ · Feb 22, 2006

Germanice said:
What I find amazing is that Yagudin still had some his most passionate and memorable performances in his so-called *meltdown* season 2000/2001, just remember "Gladiator" at Skate Canada 2000, "Gladiator" at Euros 2001 and "Revolution Etude" at Worlds 2001. It's kinda ironic/sad though he never won anything "big" with his probably greatest LP, "Gladiator". I wonder how many people will remind Plushenko's programs of this particular season?

Anke

I totally agree about "Gladiator!" I thought I was the only one who believed that it was Yagudin's best FS program ever. And I remember the performance at Skate Canada -- Todd Eldridge skated first and it was actually (no disrespect intended toward Todd Eldridge fans) the only time that I was ever impressed with an Eldridge skate. I remember thinking, "wow, he's actually pretty good when he's on." Then of course, Yagudin came out and brought (almost literally!) the house down with his debut of "Gladiator." I was nearly on my feet, cheering at home! That was such an incredible performance ... I really miss the passion and excitement that Yagudin nearly always brought to his events.

CzarinaAnya · Mar 4, 2006

Kathleen, I can't get into your pictures anymore.

Big Deal · Mar 4, 2006

Plushenko vs. Jagudin was like pure tecnique vs. passion on the ice.

Jagudin was a real fluent, smooth ice-skater and Plushy is a ballet dancer on a wrong surface (like element-stop-posing, element-stop-posing).
Even with that they both bring a level of the men's figure skating as high as nobody else really can reach it nowdays.

Jagudin was like Artur Dmitriev in pair-skating with their fantastic passion.
I also think Jagudin was much more lovable then Plush, but it is just my opinion...

Zanzibar · Mar 4, 2006

CzarinaAnya said:
Kathleen, I can't get into your pictures anymore.

Hi. Hey - my new 'off ice' website is finally up today, so I took all of the Epson sites down. My new photo website link is:

http://www.ka-bangs.com

Thanks - hope you enjoy it.

mzheng · Mar 4, 2006

So after all this is what missing in this Olympics, according to Sonia Bianchetti.

Passion = Yagudin.

CzarinaAnya · Mar 5, 2006

Thanks Kathleen! I swear, the things you get him to do....lol

Joesitz (RIP) · Mar 5, 2006

Passion, Passion, Passion. Point your finger at some imaginery person in the audience and you have Passion. :bow:

Joe

NansXOXOX · Mar 5, 2006

Joesitz said:
Passion, Passion, Passion. Point your finger at some imaginery person in the audience and you have Passion.

Joe

Joe, If that's your definition of passion, then Elvis has "passion," and while I enjoy Elvis's skating, I wouldn't call it "passionate." Alexei never pointed his finger at anyone in the audience during his Revolution Etude short program and in my opinion, that program is FULL of passion.

Nan

Joesitz (RIP) · Mar 5, 2006

Hey Nans - I don't have a definition of Passion.To me, it's in the mind of the beholder. i think it means something to the effect as extraordinary love. I believe all people have that ability but some show it different ways.

Alexei goes after you. Stephane invites you in. Pick your choice.

Joe

Tribute to Alexei Yagudin---Passion for Skating

Kelly22

Vash01

soogar

Evdokia

CzarinaAnya

JaeJ

Evdokia

JaeJ

Germanice

Kelly22

Germanice

JaeJ

CzarinaAnya

Big Deal

Zanzibar

mzheng

CzarinaAnya

Joesitz (RIP)

NansXOXOX

Joesitz (RIP)

Similar threads

Connect with us