- Joined
- Jul 28, 2003
Loved the challenge and the designs. But I thought the judges were on crack or something (though I do agree with the winner).
First of all, Katherine's design was a hundred times better than Angela's, and significantly better than Vincent's. I do understand that she is not a "top designer" material, but I still thought others should have been out instead. Also, I could not believe that Bradley was in top three over Laura, Kayne and Michael! All of those three had excellent designs to Bradley's very ho-hum one. And I don't know what to make of Keith - he puts out an excellent design, but he refuses to comply with a half of the challenge about designing for the dog. However, if they let Angela get away with not producing a sketch last week, it's only fair that they let Keith get away with it this time.
And - OMG! - that dogs are just TOO CUTE! Especially Laura's doggie, despite the designer's obvious distate for her!
Finally, a note on models competition. I thought it made it more of a competition they way they did it last week, which was also how they had it in season 1, which was that each designer chose a model, starting from the winner. This week they went back to season 2 model, with the winner having an option to switch to the loser's model. IMHO, this process is more random for the models; a bad model with a good-but-not-best designer will go through week after week with better models being eliminated (as Zulema's model went through week after week in seasons 2).
First of all, Katherine's design was a hundred times better than Angela's, and significantly better than Vincent's. I do understand that she is not a "top designer" material, but I still thought others should have been out instead. Also, I could not believe that Bradley was in top three over Laura, Kayne and Michael! All of those three had excellent designs to Bradley's very ho-hum one. And I don't know what to make of Keith - he puts out an excellent design, but he refuses to comply with a half of the challenge about designing for the dog. However, if they let Angela get away with not producing a sketch last week, it's only fair that they let Keith get away with it this time.
And - OMG! - that dogs are just TOO CUTE! Especially Laura's doggie, despite the designer's obvious distate for her!
Finally, a note on models competition. I thought it made it more of a competition they way they did it last week, which was also how they had it in season 1, which was that each designer chose a model, starting from the winner. This week they went back to season 2 model, with the winner having an option to switch to the loser's model. IMHO, this process is more random for the models; a bad model with a good-but-not-best designer will go through week after week with better models being eliminated (as Zulema's model went through week after week in seasons 2).
Last edited:
