- Joined
- Jul 11, 2003
Unfortunately, Alyssa is not on my top 5 at Nats. However, I would love that prediction to be wrong and have Alyssa included.
What about Nagasu in your top 5?
Nagasu is probably going to compete as a junior again.
Both are pretty mediocre, and I have nothing more to add.
Can I predict (although much too early): Kimmie, Rachael, Bebe, Caroline, Emily in that particular order?
Joe
Emily Hughes is NOT the youngest Hughes kid. She has a younger sister, Taylor, who doesn't skate competitively.
If you read through the LIBERTY thread, you would find out that Rachael Flatt won the Senior Ladies FS by a huge margin over Ashley Wagner, the Junior Worlds bronze medalist. At 14, Rachael finished 5th in her first US Nationals as a Senior. Emily was 16 at her first US Nationals, and she placed 6th. Emily improved to 3rd in her second try at Nationals, and there is no reason to believe that Rachael won't improve her standing as well the second time around.
I placed her in 4th. She's not a World's possibility. Too young. But as I said it is much to early for predictions. This will change over the course of the Cheesefests (if they are a competition) plus the more serious GP events.What about Caroline? With all the hype about her... where would you place her?
Kypma
At 12,Michelle Kwan placed 6th on her first try.She placed 1st on her 3rd try.At 13,Tara Lipinski placed 3rd on her first try.She placed first on her 2nd try
I placed her in 4th. She's not a World's possibility. Too young. But as I said it is much to early for predictions. This will change over the course of the Cheesefests (if they are a competition) plus the more serious GP events.
Joe
I think people are giving Zhang and Flat too much credit.
This will be another nats that will be Meissner's to lose. Hughes, and to a lesser extent, Alyssa, BeBe and Katy are the front-runners. You can call the young ones "wild-cards". That includes Zhang, Flat and Wagner(?). With a minimum of 10 skaters scheduled to be televised, we might get to see a few of the other unknowns as well.
Hughes, Alyssa, BeBe and Katy are hardly models of consistency. Emily and Bebe can skate good SPs, but their FSs are error-prone. Alyssa and Katy---who knows which alter ego will show up.
Zhang is very consistent, and Flatt is fairly consistent. I think one of them is going to make the podium, and there's an outside chance both of them could make it.
Why is everyone ignoring Nagasu?