I think I was where you're currently at last year (a casual/fair-weather fan transformed into a more serious/studious one), but for all intents and purposes, I'm where you're at. I'm going to focus on programs under the COP because they interest me more. I'll edit in more when I'm less lazy.

2008-2009
Patrick Chan's short program (@ 4CC)
Evan Lysacek's long program (@ worlds)

Yu Na-Kim's short program (@ worlds)

Savchenko/Szolkowy's short program (@ worlds)

Delobel/Schoenfelder's free dance (If you're in Canada, you can see their performance at the grand prix final online through the CBC, otherwise, here's the French Masters). Let me know if you want the the CBC version – I can't direct link it because of how it's embedded.
Virtue/Moir's free dance (@ worlds)
Samuelson/Bates original dance (@ worlds)
Davis/White/s free dance (@ worlds)
Shibutanis' free dance (@ junior worlds)

2007-2008

Jeff Buttle's long program (@ worlds)
Daisuke Takahashi's short program (@ worlds)

Carolina Kostner's short program (@ worlds)
Yu Na Kim's long program (@ worlds)
Mao Asada's long program (@ worlds)

Zhang/Zhang's short program (@ worlds)
Dube/Davison's long program (@ worlds)

Virtue/Moir's free dance (@ worlds)
Virtue/Moir's original dance (@ Skate Canada)
Delobel/Schoenfelder free dance (@ worldsl)

2006-2007

Daisuke Takahashi's long program
Stephan Lambiel's long program

Yu-Na Kim's short program (@ worlds)
Carolina Kostner's short program (@ worlds
Mao Asada's long program (@ worlds)

Shen/Zhao's short program

Denkova/Staviski's free dance
Dubreuil/Lauzon's free dance
Virtue/Moir's free dance ( @ worlds)


2005-2006

Brian Joubert's long program (@ worlds)
Stephane Lambiel's long program (@ worlds)

Shizuka Arakawa's long program (@ Olympics)

Totmiannia/Marinnin's long program (@ Olympics)

Navka/Kostomorov's free dance (@ Olympics)
Dubrueil/Lauzon's free dance (@ worlds)
Virtue/Moir's free dance (@ junior worlds)
Delobel/Schoenfelder's free dance (@ Olympics)
Drobiazko/Vanagas' free dance (@ worlds)