Bee Gees Night. Each of the final 4 had to sing 2 BeeGees songs of their choice. Sorry if I don't have the precise names of the songs.
Josh: Sang Jive Talkin and To Love Somebody. He did a pretty good job at Jive Talkin and a nice job with the 2nd song. Of course, both were countrified. Best he's been so far which is still better than Carmen's best.
Clay: Sang To Love Somebody and Grease. Great job on the 1st song - typical theatrical faces which still bug me. Grease didn't do it for me - the hip shake was downright embarrassing. Give me Frankie Valli's version.
Kim: Sang To Be Your Everything and Emotion. Hardly sang the lyrics - mostly vocal gymnastics except the chorus. She's been much better.
Ruben: Sang Nights On Broadway and How Can You Mend A Broken Heart. Loved both performances. You could tell he was trying to look more serious and not smile throughout. I think it's tough for him because he enjoys singing so much.
Guest judge Robin Gibb: Again - guest judges are too nice. Lionel Richie is still the king of guest judges.
Although I'd be kinder than Simon, I agreed with him totally tonight with regards to his opinion of the performances. He's the most honest judge and the contestants are wise to consider his suggestions (i.e. need to hear something different, get rid of the facial contortions, etc.)
So, tonight, Ruben gets all my votes because I enjoyed both his performance.
My bottom 2 for tonight: Kim and Clay (for Grease). Kim should go based on only tonight.
My bottom 2 of 4 overall: Josh and Kim. Josh should go if based upon all shows.