Let's see how well a disparate group of fans agree or disagree on how to use the PCS numbers and how they apply to some specific performances.
Here are three good programs from a competition judged under the old 6.0 system. So there's no right or wrong in terms of the program component scores, no official panel to compare our scores to.
Christopher Bowman
Todd Eldredge
Mark Mitchell
(One of the reasons I chose these programs was that they were available on youtube. If anyone can find Paul Wylie's program, or, hey, Michael Chack's, please add a link.)
Don't worry about the technical elements, except insofar as they influence your PCS. Don't worry at all about who won or should have won or would win under IJS.
Let's just focus on the program component scores. How would you score each of these performances in Skating Skills, Transitions, Performance/Execution, Choreography, and Interpretation? Please explain your reasoning for your scores.
Detailed program component explanations
Here are three good programs from a competition judged under the old 6.0 system. So there's no right or wrong in terms of the program component scores, no official panel to compare our scores to.
Christopher Bowman
Todd Eldredge
Mark Mitchell
(One of the reasons I chose these programs was that they were available on youtube. If anyone can find Paul Wylie's program, or, hey, Michael Chack's, please add a link.)
Don't worry about the technical elements, except insofar as they influence your PCS. Don't worry at all about who won or should have won or would win under IJS.
Let's just focus on the program component scores. How would you score each of these performances in Skating Skills, Transitions, Performance/Execution, Choreography, and Interpretation? Please explain your reasoning for your scores.
Detailed program component explanations