Evan is more imposing on the ice because he's huge, and his skating is super smooth. Johnny's SP was good but I really felt like he did not put his heart and soul into the LP at all, I thought it was boring. Ryan and Adam's FS were deservedly ahead of Johnny's because Johnny's was boring.
Evan was tense in the SP i'll admit, but apart from the mistakes in the LP, I thought it was beautiful. He has a great quality to his skating. I'm sad Ryan is retiring, I had no idea he was 26! I though he was like 20, he seems so youthful!