Sasha's comeback attempt.
This may seem obvious and not be even worth saying, but I feel saddened by Sasha's failed comeback attempt.
I think this is definitely an opportunity missed: while her training certainly helped her regain her form to a certain extent, her preparation level was below what was needed to mount a serious challenge. Basically, I think she has miscalculated the amount of time it would take to really become competitive at the national level. That's very sad because it is obvious she put in serious effort that has gotten her far. All that effort was wasted by poor planning. She needed to start the serious training about eight months earlier than she did. Ironically, this is what has always frustrated me about Sasha: she seemed like a hard worker, and yet her preparation efforts were not optimized to ensure success.
Beliver in Sasha's Perfect Program
She supposedly started training with Rapheal in fall of 2008. She should have stopped doing SOI after that and devoted herself to training full-time. If she had, and also not gotten injured and avoided the boot problems (or dealt with them sooner) she would have skated well. It was not so much that she did not start training soon enough, but that she did not plan on being so injured. If she had not been injured she would have skated in the GP and known that her footwork was level 1, etc.
I agree, but I was still happy to see her skate, her SP was wonderful
Yes, that's what I meant.. she should have started "serious/full-time" training earlier. I guess no one advised her to be aware of the strain the body would have to face when switching into intense athletic mode after so many years away. And of course, her LP could have been much more difficult, earning her a lot more points despite any jump problems.
Originally Posted by Tinymavy15
FAILED COME BACK ATTEMPT??? I am very sorry but it sounds reall mean and harsh. I do not think it was failed at all. She showed us beaudiful short program and I am very sure because of her, the viewing rate went up. She definitely helped to get more people interested and excited about figure skating in the Olympic year. Whether you like her or not, she is a global icon of figure skating. And America should be really proud of producing such a special skater and respect her for coming back.
I think it is up to Sasha to evaluate whether she "failed" or not.
After her LP she seemed surprisingly calm and did not look like she thought of herself as a failure. I suspect she did the best she could with the injury situation.
I was happy with her SP and it was great seeing her skate again.
Last night as I began watching the LP's it hit me that Sasha was probably not going to be able to come close to a clean skate. Just a feeling - maybe based on her previosu history and certainly due to her lack of training time.
Who knows what Sasha is thinking today. She said it was about "the journey" and that she wanted the feeling back that comes with competing.
From that point Sasha may be thinking that just getting out on the ice again makes her a winner - and not a failure.
Keeper of the Kweens OGM.
I don't think her comeback was failed at all. She skated a great short and went after everything in the LP. She didn't give up and she attempted everything. To me that spoke volumes. And 4th place after 4 years off from competitive skating, not to shabby.
I agree, I don't think it was necessarily a "failed" attempt, but as janetfan said, that is for Sasha to decide. I think she knew heading into Nationals what she was capable of. But on the other hand, so many were saying as long as she stood up, it was her Nationals to lose, and I believe she skated her LP with that in mind. Had she started out strong and faltered, I could believe it was all about lack of training and stamina, but she faltered out the gate, she seemed so slow and tentative compared to the SP, and never really got going. Well, she gave it a shot, and she knows what went wrong with the comeback. She got a lot of attention and loving during the whole Nationals and she clearly enjoyed it. So, I hope that is a bit of a consolation prize.
I am not being mean, I am simply evaluating her goal and whether she has achieved it or not:
Originally Posted by PROKOFIEV
Goal: To make the Olympic team.
Has she succeed or failed to make the Olympic team? Failed.
Now, whether she skated well and or/enjoyed the experience is a different question, but she was out to make the Olympic team!
Well, if the comeback attempt was to make the Oly team (which Cohen has said many times) and she didn't, that could technically be considered a failure. But really, only she knows whether it is one or not. But it definitely was not a raging success, we can say that much.
She seemed to "wise up" in the month before Nationals, probably when she realized she probably most likely was going to fall short. It struck me how loose and carefree she seemed to be in the freeskate. Usually she has a deer-in-the-headlights look. I was actually wondering if that was a display of confidence in herself and she was looking to wow us. Retrospectively, looks like she knew she was done and just wanted to enjoy the performance, even if she wasn't able to hit the jumps.
I agree that she tried to make the most of the moment. My thinking is more of this line than "she blew it, she failed"- just because she had the courage to go for it. That's as much as you can do and for once she came across as warm and friendly to reporters, the audience and her competitors.
Originally Posted by MK's Winter
Last edited by R.D.; 01-24-2010 at 09:49 PM.
"The only real failure in life is the failure to try". Sasha tried and she did not fail. I remember at the last Olympics that the media and the non-fans kept saying that Sasha failed to win gold, not that she had won silver.
She said she hoped to make the Olympic team but it would not be the end of the world if she didn't make it.
Originally Posted by krenseby
She said it was about the journey and about getting the feeling back,
That is what she said and there is no need to make up your own version.
Sasha will most likely give an interview soon and will probably talk more about it.
I think she proved people like you wrong and more than a few have given her some credit for attempting this comeback. I can no more declare it a success or failure than you can.
Last edited by janetfan; 01-25-2010 at 07:21 AM.
What also struck me was how calm and at peace with herself she seemed when it was clear her competitors outscored her. No emotion, no surprise. Perhaps, she knew exactly where she would place, after all.
Originally Posted by R.D.