Technical Panel Disclosed | Page 3 | Golden Skate

Technical Panel Disclosed

HCOSurfer

Final Flight
Joined
Feb 25, 2007
.. I stated my point based on my interpretation on many UR calls and stand by it. In essence I have every right to voice how I feel within my logic and there's no way you can say I know nothing about figure skating because of that. Besides, why are you alreay jumping to the conclusion that I'm a Yuna fan?

I apologize, I'm just used to hearing things like that from her uberfans.
 

yangjie

On the Ice
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
I am really suprised at seeing that some yu-na's fans think she always jumps cleanly.

common, she is a human, she sometimes makes a mistake and jums a lip and a cheating 3-3.
Thats why jugdes sometimes give her attentions.
 

gourry

Final Flight
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
I am really suprised at seeing that some yu-na's fans think she always jumps cleanly.

common, she is a human, she sometimes makes a mistake and jums a lip and a cheating 3-3.
Thats why jugdes sometimes give her attentions.

It's about questionable calls. Have you ever heard any Yuna fan say anything about her 2A-3T< at GPF LP? Or her 3-3< at SA LP? Or her 3F< at SA LP? No. Because they were all right calls.
But 3-3< at GPF SP? NO. Big no. That is a really questionable and I dare say wrong call.
And FYI, if the rotation is boarderline, the tech callers are supposed to call in favor of the skaters. Yuna's 3-3 at GPF was not even borderline.
 
Last edited:

gracefulswan

On the Ice
Joined
Aug 16, 2003

Sophia KP

Rinkside
Joined
Jan 15, 2010
I am really suprised at seeing that some yu-na's fans think she always jumps cleanly.

common, she is a human, she sometimes makes a mistake and jums a lip and a cheating 3-3.
Thats why jugdes sometimes give her attentions.


OMG Yangjie, are you kidding?
Yuna's 3-3 is cheated and """" lip"""" ?
then what about mao's 4cc lp 3A and rachael's 3-3?
 
Joined
Jul 11, 2003
There is nothing a TV or icenetwork viewer can do about what they see on those screens, the last word on URs is the Technical Call or the Judges' score.

Maybe someday, isolating a questionable call will be shown on the Jumbothon and also on screens in slow motion. Icenetwork does show some but not enough.
 

yangjie

On the Ice
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
OMG Yangjie, are you kidding?
Yuna's 3-3 is cheated and """" lip"""" ?
then what about mao's 4cc lp 3A and rachael's 3-3?

yeah, I was really suprised that Mao's 3a2t in 4cc wasnt downgraded.

but,why do you ask me about mao and rachel?

i am just saying that yuna SOMETIMES jumps a cheating 3-3 like everyone elso, because she is a human.
so SOME yuna's fans should know about it.

and i think her flip is not lip this year,but her flip was lip last year.
so jugdes gave yuna E call or ! call last year.right?
 

Daniel5555

On the Ice
Joined
Jan 27, 2009
The only thing that I want as fan of Yuna is fair judgement. If Yuna makes underrotation, downgrade her. If not, not downgrade her. I think most of us, fans, want it that way.
In my opinion, and I watched her GPF SP a lot of times, that 3-3 was not underrotated, but, well, I hope that this was just an error from tech specialist. Yuna is human and tech specialist is human too.
 

dorothea

Rinkside
Joined
Jan 12, 2010
I think that now the technical panel has a chance to repent her folly. Maybe she just wanted to show off her position and authority by daring to give wrong marks to the most acclaimed jumps of Yuna,the world top skater.---first 3F/3T, then 3L/3T. Enough is enough. Now I hope that tech specialist repent her foolish acts, and never do it again. This time, she has to judge fairly and prove to the world that she can be a tech panel with conscience .

As for Yuna, don't be afraid. I believe everything will be all right for her. We all know Yuna's 3/3 is a textbook as shown in NewYorkTimes, and all Yuna has to do is just do her usual perfect jumps.:) God bless Yuna!
 
Last edited:

yangjie

On the Ice
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
I think that now the technical panel has a chance to repent her folly. Maybe she just wanted to show off her position and authority by daring to give wrong marks to the most acclaimed jumps of Yuna,the world top skater.---first 3F/3T, then 3L/3T. Enough is enough. Now I hope that tech specialist repent her foolish acts, and never do it again. This time, she has to judge fairly and prove to the world that she can be a tech panel with conscience .

As for Yuna, don't be afraid. I believe everything will be all right for her. We all know Yuna's 3/3 is a textbook as shown in NewYorkTimes, and all Yuna has to do is just do her usual perfect jumps.:) God bless Yuna!

she jumped lip when yuna's 3f3t was downgraded by that judge at 2008 CoC, just remember it.
 

Daniel5555

On the Ice
Joined
Jan 27, 2009
R.D.
That's nothing - look at the Chan/Plushenko thread :) The only problem with this judge is that she has a story of being picky at Yuna with questionable calls, even statistically that looks suspicious. That's why fans are worried.
 
Top