Page 5 of 9 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 LastLast
Results 61 to 75 of 130

Thread: Mao wants to do a quad at Sochi in 2014

  1. #61
    Mashimaro on Ice
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    1,419
    They devote a whole webpage for this? :sheesh: Rivals youtube videos.

  2. #62
    Rinkside
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    GA
    Posts
    13
    Quote Originally Posted by miki88 View Post
    They devote a whole webpage for this? :sheesh: Rivals youtube videos.
    Somethings wrong with it? I thought the website is trustful, not like some crazy youtube videos. If you find any serious mistakes for their post, let me know.

  3. #63
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    626
    Quote Originally Posted by CassieH View Post
    Somethings wrong with it? I thought the website is trustful, not like some crazy youtube videos. If you find any serious mistakes for their post, let me know.
    I browsed around the website, great content and articles throughout the years!

    Thanks for sharing :D

  4. #64
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    New York City
    Posts
    289
    Quote Originally Posted by CassieH View Post
    I agree. Some users keep saying that Asada's 3As should have more goe, but the below website explains why she got low goe for her 3As.

    http://www.iceskatingintnl.com/archi...ple%20Axel.htm

    Asada need to work with her 3A more rather than quad jump if she really want to win OGM.
    I really hope that she find someone who knows CoP very well like Orser and Wilson.
    It's clear from the photo that her toe pick is ingrained in the ice as she lands her 2T. So she's 2-footing her landings again?

  5. #65
    Custom Title hurrah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    1,148
    Quote Originally Posted by Figure88 View Post
    It's clear from the photo that her toe pick is ingrained in the ice as she lands her 2T. So she's 2-footing her landings again?
    It's hard to see where the ice begins in the photo, but I looked really, really carefully, and it doesn't look like her toe pick is ingrained. It's above the ice.

    By the way, their article, 'Hamilton Turns Darkness into Light' makes for an engrossing read.

  6. #66
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    New York City
    Posts
    289
    Quote Originally Posted by hurrah View Post
    It's hard to see where the ice begins in the photo, but I looked really, really carefully, and it doesn't look like her toe pick is ingrained. It's above the ice.

    By the way, their article, 'Hamilton Turns Darkness into Light' makes for an engrossing read.
    The ingrained is probably the wrong word, but it does look like the toe pick is on the surface of the ice. Her double toe definitely looks 2 footed to me.

  7. #67
    Medalist
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    76
    I would rather see Mao correct her technique on the jumps she already struggles with before attempting newer and more difficult ones. I would also like to see her focus on improving her overall programs. Also, Vancouver has shown us just performing the most difficult jumps alone is not enough to win the Olympic gold medal anymore.
    Last edited by SweetPea21307; 03-01-2010 at 01:38 AM.

  8. #68
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    858
    Quote Originally Posted by kyla2 View Post
    There are an awful lot of snarky comments about Mao on this thread. She certainly doesn't deserve it. She delivered 2 fully rotated triple axels in her Lp and one in her short. The next time you can find a woman skater who can do that, be sure to let me know. I would never underestimate her. She has a ton of potential. All of this advice is very entertaining from armchair coaches.
    Yes, I agree with you. And it's the same posters who post these snarky comments about Mao not just on this thread, but other threads too.

  9. #69
    Gadfly and Bon Vivant Mafke's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Posts
    1,389
    Quote Originally Posted by SweetPea21307 View Post
    Vancouver has shown us just performing the most difficult jumps alone is not enough to win the Olympic gold medal anymore.
    I'm not sure if she got that memo....

  10. #70
    Dreaming and dancing Bennett's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Watching the sunset
    Posts
    2,793
    Quote Originally Posted by janetfan View Post
    The future of what?
    Let me remind you that Sasha is an Olympic Silver medalist and Flatt is a 7th place Olympic finisher, the worst showing by a US Lady Champion going back before WW2.

    I hope Flatt does better at Worlds because Mirai can't get back the third spot for USA all by herself.

    Mirai is the future. Her talent is obvious and has fans and experts gushing. Orser praised Mirai as did Button.
    Sorry, you seem to have taught us that history a few times in the forums.

    Back to the topic, I just hope that Mao does not get injured.

    I feel excited about the possibility that Plush and Mao practice together. Practicing with others is really a lot of fun. There is something magical about it. Just watching better spins and better jumps on ice help you move that way. It's a lot different from just watching videos or listening to the coach.

  11. #71
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Posts
    4,221
    George Rossano, why am I not surprised, as I know he posts here and is a huge fan of Yuna Kim.

    His bias marks him not to be trusted in my book, same goes for Joe Inman, and also this very board, as I know whom he is good friends with. FSU in this instance is a more objective & fair board when it comes to both Mao Asada & Evgeni Plushenko.

    George Rossano's photos mark him the same as Philip Hersh, whom used youtube videos (specifically pro Yuna Kim supporter videos) at the beginning of the season to justify his point.

    Back on topic, it has always been obvious (leastways to me) that the Japanese culture is more about honor versus reward, and this translates into their skating. Daisuke Takahashi could have easily taken the safe conservative route by not going for the quad in his FS in order to post a better result, mayhap even a gold medal. But as he himself said, that's not the way he wanted to win, he wanted to win by attempting the hardest element, so he went for it. It was about the S K A T E, not the end result. About honor & humility, which is the hallmark of the Japanese culture. Thus, I was not surprised this whole season to see Mao Asada go for the whole shebang, despite the public outcry. She knew what the judges wanted (& even the skatefans, lol), but she didn't care, she stuck with her guns and skated to Bells of Moscow (which she had specifically chosen over a light lyrical musical number in order to challenge herself). And the same goes for all three triple axels. Once again, it was about the skate itself, not the end result. It's just too bad she didn't skate clean at the Olympics, thus the tears, here's hoping she skates clean at Worlds.

    Regards the quad, I'm thinking Mao has always had this planned, just like she kept talking about Sochi was her goal this past year. Lol, which got me mad, I said dang it why are you thinking about Sochi, you should be thinking about Vancouver!*mad* Now, in retrospect, I'm beginning to understand Mao, a little. I think she knew she wouldn't be ready for Vancouver, it was just a warmup for Sochi, her ultimate goal. To master three triple axels and a quad by the time Sochi comes round. And willing to forego the gold medal this year in order to concentrate on landing three triple axels (i.e. one in the SP & two in the FS). Whereas if she had reverted to her old programs & jumps from 2007/2008, it would have been a huge step backward for her, even if it might have gotten her the gold medal. Instead, she decided to go forward with the three triple axels, become consistent with them this year, and hopefully in the following years. But at the same time work on mastering a quad to her repertoire, which I honestly think will be thee biggest challenge of her entire career up until now.

    Mao's been doing 3axels since she was 11/12 yrs. old, so it's not unreasonable that one day she would accomplish what she just did (i.e. landing three 3axels at the Olympics). However, I question *any* skater adding such a hard element such as the quad later on in their careers. Seriously, how many skaters have actually managed to do it? I mean Tara Lipinski was doing 3/3s when she was a tween, same goes for Sarah Hughes, Michelle Kwan, Irina Slutskaya, et al. OTOH, Oksana Baiul never did one, even when she was a tween, and the same goes for plenty of other female skaters I never saw did even one during their competitve careers. However, I know plenty tried the 3axel endlessly in practice, but never did one or landed one in competition. My point being in order to land a difficult element such as the quad in one's later career, one must have first started landing them successfully in their younger tween or teenage years. Right? I'm honestly hoping Mao Asada will be the exception to the rule, but history shows us the reality of such an undertaking. Case in point, Michelle Kwan, whom tried to add a more difficult 3/3 to her repertoire later on in her 20's, which might have led to her hip injury. And also Kristi Yamaguchi said she desperately tried adding the 3axel to her repertoire in her late teens/early 20's without success, thus she instead concentrated on landing the 3L/3T combo. to defeat Midori Ito, which she did master. Therefore, I don't know, it seems to me if you haven't mastered a triple axel or a 3/3 or a quad by the time your 19 yrs. old, statistics show you will never do so.

    That said, I honestly wish Mao Asada all the luck in the world, and by sheer force of stubborness & will power, I wouldn't be surprised if she does prove all the statisticians wrong. *smile*

  12. #72
    Dreaming and dancing Bennett's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Watching the sunset
    Posts
    2,793
    Yeah, there's something really crazy about it and I love that craziness. It's a rare quality to be able to say and do what you really dream of, when so many ppl say no, that's crazy. But a lot of olympians seem to be like that, one way or another.

  13. #73
    leave no stone unturned seniorita's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Posts
    5,580
    in a completely off topic quad, Mao and Plush video, cute

  14. #74
    Rinkside
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    6
    Quote Originally Posted by Nadine View Post
    Back on topic, it has always been obvious (leastways to me) that the Japanese culture is more about honor versus reward, and this translates into their skating. Daisuke Takahashi could have easily taken the safe conservative route by not going for the quad in his FS in order to post a better result, mayhap even a gold medal. But as he himself said, that's not the way he wanted to win, he wanted to win by attempting the hardest element, so he went for it. It was about the S K A T E, not the end result. About honor & humility, which is the hallmark of the Japanese culture. Thus, I was not surprised this whole season to see Mao Asada go for the whole shebang, despite the public outcry. She knew what the judges wanted (& even the skatefans, lol), but she didn't care, she stuck with her guns and skated to Bells of Moscow (which she had specifically chosen over a light lyrical musical number in order to challenge herself). And the same goes for all three triple axels. Once again, it was about the skate itself, not the end result. It's just too bad she didn't skate clean at the Olympics, thus the tears, here's hoping she skates clean at Worlds.

    Regards the quad, I'm thinking Mao has always had this planned, just like she kept talking about Sochi was her goal this past year. Lol, which got me mad, I said dang it why are you thinking about Sochi, you should be thinking about Vancouver!*mad* Now, in retrospect, I'm beginning to understand Mao, a little. I think she knew she wouldn't be ready for Vancouver, it was just a warmup for Sochi, her ultimate goal. To master three triple axels and a quad by the time Sochi comes round. And willing to forego the gold medal this year in order to concentrate on landing three triple axels (i.e. one in the SP & two in the FS). Whereas if she had reverted to her old programs & jumps from 2007/2008, it would have been a huge step backward for her, even if it might have gotten her the gold medal. Instead, she decided to go forward with the three triple axels, become consistent with them this year, and hopefully in the following years. But at the same time work on mastering a quad to her repertoire, which I honestly think will be thee biggest challenge of her entire career up until now.

    Mao's been doing 3axels since she was 11/12 yrs. old, so it's not unreasonable that one day she would accomplish what she just did (i.e. landing three 3axels at the Olympics). However, I question *any* skater adding such a hard element such as the quad later on in their careers. Seriously, how many skaters have actually managed to do it? I mean Tara Lipinski was doing 3/3s when she was a tween, same goes for Sarah Hughes, Michelle Kwan, Irina Slutskaya, et al. OTOH, Oksana Baiul never did one, even when she was a tween, and the same goes for plenty of other female skaters I never saw did even one during their competitve careers. However, I know plenty tried the 3axel endlessly in practice, but never did one or landed one in competition. My point being in order to land a difficult element such as the quad in one's later career, one must have first started landing them successfully in their younger tween or teenage years. Right? I'm honestly hoping Mao Asada will be the exception to the rule, but history shows us the reality of such an undertaking. Case in point, Michelle Kwan, whom tried to add a more difficult 3/3 to her repertoire later on in her 20's, which might have led to her hip injury. And also Kristi Yamaguchi said she desperately tried adding the 3axel to her repertoire in her late teens/early 20's without success, thus she instead concentrated on landing the 3L/3T combo. to defeat Midori Ito, which she did master. Therefore, I don't know, it seems to me if you haven't mastered a triple axel or a 3/3 or a quad by the time your 19 yrs. old, statistics show you will never do so.

    That said, I honestly wish Mao Asada all the luck in the world, and by sheer force of stubborness & will power, I wouldn't be surprised if she does prove all the statisticians wrong. *smile*
    She landed 3 3As this time but it would be pretty hard to deny that, she landed them by a narrow margin. Plus she had to reduce her body fat to 7%. It's too harsh for her to keep her condition that way for 4 years, b/c her body will change over time. She can't stop that. A quad and 3 3As by the time Sochi... I don't know. I get your point, but she's not playing the game smartly, that's for sure.
    Last edited by FrozenHotCoffee; 03-01-2010 at 08:22 AM.

  15. #75
    Banned janetfan's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Philadelphia, PA
    Posts
    6,889
    Quote Originally Posted by FrozenHotCoffee View Post
    She landed 3 3As this time but it would be pretty hard to deny that, she landed them by a narrow margin. Plus she had to reduce her body fat to 7%. It's too harsh for her to keep her condition that way for 4 years, b/c her body will change over time. She can't stop that. A quad and 3 3As by the time Sochi... I don't know. I get your point, but she's not playing the game smartly, that's for sure.
    I think Mao is already taking a health risk with all of the practice required for the 3A's. Should she keep practicing them while adding a quad - with all the practice required for that jump - would seem to be putting alot of wear and tear on her body.

    She seems to be made of steel - but I have to wonder how much stress her body can take?
    I think the lack of a coach has taken a toll on Mao. Sure her 3A's are quite an accomplishment - but we also see her losing other jumps and with urs on 2Loops and 2 toes.

    The sacrifice Mao made for the 3A's seems to show up with diminished skills on her other jumps. Adding a quad may excite fans who live for jumps but I think Mao is such an exquisite skater and I would rather see her show a more well rounded approach to her skating.

    Of course Mao has every right to do it her way and while I congratulate her for being the first Lady to land three 3A's I can also say how much more I prefer Yuna's programs this season.

    I worry that Mao may not be physically able to keep up this jump oriented style through to 2014. It would be a great loss to skating if that were to happen. As to her dream of becoming Olympic champion all she has to do is see how Yuna and Orser did it. A successful, long term plan based on refining as many elements as possible.

    In today's skating it has been made clear that big jumps alone are not enough to win the OGM.
    We do talk alot about the Yuna-Mao rivalry but what we saw in Vancouver was a total win for Orser/Wilson over Mao's obsession with the 3A and lack of good strategic coaching.

Page 5 of 9 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •