03-28-2010, 03:42 PM
Thanks Kalle for your comment from watching live. Its always interesting to me how the skater's come across live, as its not always the same as tv. Glad you enjoyed watching Cynthia. I used to live in Canada so have seen her many times, though not live. Glad Europeans got the chance to see her when she is skating well. Iam not sure if she will be a really consistant skater throughout the season next year but if she peaks at the right time again for Worlds then its good.
03-28-2010, 04:01 PM
I always enjoy reading other skating fans reports too
Originally Posted by Olympia
It is not often that I get to see live skating but each time I realize how differently you experience some skaters and their programs.
Last edited by kalle; 03-28-2010 at 04:15 PM.
03-28-2010, 04:34 PM
Yes, thanks for the birds-eye report. I think there are some things that don't make it through the TV which impact how those of us at home may see and judge the skaters, such as speed/flow across the ice.
03-28-2010, 04:52 PM
Cynthia skate was just fantastic, I hope this boots her confidence as she has a lot of potential.
Originally Posted by figuristka
She was very elegant, powerfull, yet very gentle on the ice and for the first time in years, I did not "think" that she would fall, she seemed to be in a very good place mentally speaking.
I like the fact that it is not impossible to become a champion at a "later" stage in your career. I really admire skaters such as Shizuka and Joannie, the way they worked their way up from year to year.
I believe you shall never give up, that is why sometimes it is kind of cruel to read that some people prefers skaters like Alissa and Carolina to retire..
As a fan it can be frustrating to see such talented skaters not live up to their potentials but I realised after Carolinas skate yesterday that she was there for the love of skating, I really felt that it meant so much to her to be able to share her emotions through her program despite the final standings..
03-28-2010, 05:00 PM
Cynthia was awesome! I'm wondering though, is it just a coincidence that all the Canadian lady skaters are SO MUSCULAR? I mean really, Joannie, Cynthia, Amelie, Myrianne, Dianne. Maybe they condition with the hockey players ? Whatever, I like seeing a tall, muscular woman like Cynthia on the ice.
03-28-2010, 05:02 PM
Originally Posted by ajjcanada
I expected Yuna to be way above the others in term of flow and speed over the ice but not at all..Of course, she is a reference but I was amazed to see Laura, Mirai, Cynthia and Akiko "flying" around the ice with nice transitions too..
03-28-2010, 05:33 PM
As silverlake22 mentioned, the question was about skaters who managed to come up with a way of doing 7 triples without a triple-triple. Under the current Zayak rules 7 triples is impossible without a triple Axel, a triple-triple, or a 2A-triple combo.
Originally Posted by museksk8r
In 1998 Michelle did not recover from her broken foot in time to train her triple-triple combo. So she had to do eight jumping passes to get the full content in.
She also used 8 jumping passes (7 triples) to edge out Lu Chen (6 triples) for the 1996 World Championship
I don't think so. Lulu did accomplish some 7 triple programs (at 1991 Worlds for instance), but always with a 3T/3T combo. She did 5 triples at 1994 Olympics and 5 in winning the 1995 World Championship.
Originally Posted by janetfan
I am pretty sure that all of Slutskaya's 7-triple performances came after the "seven jumping pass rule" was in place.
In comparing Kwan to Slutskaya, I think we should take note of the fact that Michelle was a young prodigy, while Irina was something of a late bloomer. By the time Irina really got it going, round about 2001-02, Michelle was already on the back slope of her career (still producing memorable programs, though.)
Last edited by Mathman; 03-28-2010 at 05:37 PM.
03-28-2010, 06:03 PM
MM. I've never read any of your retorts to go against the judges. You normally just roll out the protocols and say that's what happened.
Originally Posted by Mathman
I do agree with you and happy you can disagree with the judges.
03-28-2010, 06:04 PM
I didn't think sequences counted.
03-28-2010, 06:13 PM
I am so misunderstood. Posters come on board and ask, what happened? why did so-and-so get such a low Transitions score? What does the rule say about thus-and-so?
Originally Posted by Joesitz
So I try to do my civic duty and look up the answers to these questions.
That doesn't mean I agree or disagree with anybody. Just trying to aid the discussion by reporting the facts.
Yes, I meant you can't come up to 7 triples unless you have a triple-triple combo or sequence, or a double Axel/triple combo or sequence, or a triple Axel. Sasha Cohen and Joannie Rochette are two skaters that used a 3S sequence to squeeze in their seventh triple.
Originally Posted by ImaginaryPogue
Michelle actually did eight separate individual passes at both 1996 Worlds and 1998 Olympics (before they changed the rules to allow only seven.)
Last edited by Mathman; 03-28-2010 at 06:32 PM.
03-28-2010, 06:26 PM
and by reporting the facts, you do not have any comments about disagreeing with what the judges scored. I wish we knew who the protocolers are by name.
03-28-2010, 06:36 PM
Honestly, Yu na and Mao are in different leagues, and I'm so shocked that many of you guys do not even realize that.
Mao's program was dull, wierd and depressing, and she is no "Yagudin' she is more suitable with light and pleasant programs. Her artistry lacks quite a bit to perform heavy musics like Bells of Moscow...She will do much better next season with the program that will suit her brightness and lightness on the ice. I am expecting her to do better next year!
Yu-na had a good program, a program that no other skaters in the world can perform. Her difficult entrance to her jumps and speed in and out of jumps are just flawless, Yes she fell once and singled her 2A, but figure skating is so much more than doing Jumps.
Mao is a good skater, there is no denying of that, but Yu na is one of the greatest ever, both technically and artistically, she is the 'total package' and until this season, she was underestimated by the judges ...do you guys remember 2008 worlds? how Mao won gold? and how Caro got silver over Yu na? I'm not saying Mao did anything wrong but that's how it used to be and now yu-na's finally being recognized by the judges..
03-28-2010, 06:42 PM
03-28-2010, 06:45 PM
Excellent post. Thanks for the edit.
Originally Posted by nddandy
03-28-2010, 06:45 PM
I agree. Every time Mao beats Yuna, it's because Yuna makes significant mistakes. A perfect Yuna will beat a perfect Mao every time. Also, every time Mao beats Yuna, it's by a few points, whereas Yuna has beaten Mao by over 20 points multiple times.
Originally Posted by nddandy