Nice pics Bob. I think she is a fairly sheltered and charmingly innocent girl. So is Kim. It is part of their appeal. I like the purity that both girls have in their skating. 19 is a baby and I don't feel "innocent angel" is some act. Certainly TAT tried to give her a powerful vehicle with "Bells." I am a Mao fan but I must say I prefer Mao 'lite.' so to speak.
Originally Posted by PolymerBob
I agree we need to see changes from pretty iceprincess biut then, that appears to be who she is. She does not look or skate like Ito or Harding. She is fairy like and ethereal as some have said. Perhaps in 4 years she will skate programs like Salome or Samson and Delilah. Yet her stature and style seem more suited to "Butterfly Lovers program." Versatility in skating or dance seems to come with the years, experience and opportunities. Usually when someone stops competing and has programs choreographed for audience appeal rather than ISI judges.
You have a point there prettykeys.
Originally Posted by prettykeys
I like pie.
If there is ever a question about the guidelines - review them. They're for all to view and follow.
I want to add something I have recently learned from these two articles of Tokyo Newspaper. (Originally I thought I could post this in the Frankel thread but changed my mind.)
An editorial about olys : http://www.tokyo-np.co.jp/article/co...702000082.html
Asada interview after the olys : http://www.tokyo-np.co.jp/hold/2010/...202000203.html
The editorial mentions that Asada could overcome the fearsome thoughts that she might not jump anymore, succeeding in three 3As under so much pressure so her silver itself was worth. It also commend Miki and Suzuki because they overcame their own predicaments too, while it praises Yuna's performance and preparation and Team Korea's stratege. I think this editorial represents many sensible and reasonable Japanese.
In the interview, there is a question about Mao's biggest hardship in the past four years. She said, "After the Russian Cup, of course. I was surprised that my jumps broke down. Knowing that, I returned to practice but they still didn't work. The most painful moment. I even wondered if I could go to the olys."
As far as I know, she still struggled when she had lost her weight and participated in 4CC in Jan and she lost to Suzuki in SP but she succeeded 3As in the LP though. I admit her performance at 4CC and olys and Worlds took a lot of determination and hard work as other posters already mentioned.
Another question was what her mom said about olys.
"Mom said, 'it was good. Most of all, I am content because you could pull it off without mishap.'"
I think her mom said vey wise thing here.
I understand many fans from other countries don't like to hear and see such heated disputes between Korean fans and Japanese fans. I sometimes frown too but I want to say there are a lot of respectable and thoughtful people in both countries even though sometimes they may disagree over anything. Well, please look up more civil and reasonable media than lower level media or some bitter 'comments' of the internet.
This is another example from a Korean article.
He criticizes the inflated, humongous figures that was estimated about how much Yuna would supposedly boost up Korean economy and says that if Koreans hope the best for Yuna and Korea,
they should remove heavy burden of nationalism from her slender sholders. I agree.
Sunny, thanks for the post. What I mostly commented on in one post was what happens here in GS. Some of the posts which was to talk about what we like about Mao's skating, were removed as they were posts insulting her. Which of course shows poor form. I did not know of those articles regarding Mao and am enlightened. I guess I will say that I find her most enchanting in her gala skates when she skates with joy. I find in here some of the good qualities of Sasha Cohen without the bad ones.
I find it interesting that the Frankel thread which was about the balletic ability of Mao kind of evolved into a classical music/art discussion without any discussion of ballet or the great ballerinas off today. While Mao may have very good extension, she is not a ballerina but a skater. And an interesting side topic would have been how dancers are incredible athletes when they are well trained, especially ballet trained. Well, perhaps that will be another thread. Mao Asada is a rare combo. Her triple axels are so rare. Many have done the tough 3x3's in competition but maybe 5 women(?) the triple axel. And she did 3. I can see Mao as an athlete or as a dancer or as both. I wonder how she can maintain her graceful flow while doing those jumps and transitions. It seems too difficult. Well, her Worlds performance was very satisfying. It just shows how even the top two athlete/artists in FS have periods where nothing works. My best to her and all my other favorites.
I wonder how Mirai Nagasu will compare or fare this season. I see some similarities in their skating. I think if/when Kim leaves, Mirai will be Mao's main competition.
This is very enlightening. Thanks for the summaries of these articles. It's a relief to know that there were many supportive articles for both skaters in Japan and Korea.
Originally Posted by sunny0760
Certainly the revealing details about Mao's frame of mind earlier in the year make her wonderful Olympic and Worlds performances even more impressive. I feel that the way she pulled herself together and did so well will give her the confidence to shake off any further worries about her jumps.
Actually, I don't really care whether a skater is innocent or not.
Originally Posted by PolymerBob
I just assume skaters are human beings just like us and they have both angels and demons coexisting in their minds.
Also, I happen to believe innocence and competitive feistiness could coexist in a person.
I was talking about selection of image Mao Asada chose to accentuate on and off the ice and how it affected her performance.
At start of the season, she looked awkward because she was performing to heavy music while trying to maintain her off ice image as an innocent girl.
Her program eventually came together, when she showed more fire and desire to win in tune with the music.
If her endorsement contracts prefer an innocent image, she could always go back, but I preferred Mao Asada and her program as a feisty competitor.
Originally Posted by miki88
Wicked Yankee Girl
If anyone is uncertain why a post disappears, they should read the guidelines. The most common reasons for deleting a post are insulting anoter poster; insulting the moderators; posting an unsourced rumor about a skater, coach, or federation; posting ethnic slurs or ethnic or racial comments likely to start a flame war; and using x rated language. If your post has significant figure skating content, it may be edited, and if so, a comment will be written explaining the edit. However, when there are many deletable posts, all quoting other previously deleted posts, I am likely to just delete them all without explanation. For this I apologize.
But be aware, if you quote a deleted post, I will either edit or delete your post too, unless its content is so interesting that I have to take the time to edit it.
I would urge you all to be kind to one another, and when you can't be kind, use the report button to report a post.
If you have a specific question for the moderators, the place to do it is not inside a thread, it's in the feedback forum. If you have a question of why a specific post was edited or deleted, that would be the place to post and ask. Although you cannot see the post, we can, so if you give the approximate post number, we will be able to find it and tell you.
Waiting for on-ice perfection.
I think other posters have already discussed my main reasons for liking Mao. To add something to the discussion: I love it when Mao's happy. The thing is, she always exudes her feelings. Her happiness is contagious. Her smile puts a smile smack on my face. When she's sad, I'm a little upset as well. It probably has to do with her childlike transparency.
ITA, I think that was why you have plenty of people rushing to her defence fervently. Her happiness, glee and perhaps most of all 'innocence' is contagious and she exude them most in her galas where she appears most at ease (at least from the last 2 years of performances I saw). When she is happy - it really translate into her skating, and take it above a notch from her SP and FS performances. In other words, it is true one usually performs best when there's joy and happiness in their heart. At least IMHO it is true for Mao.
Mao is like a talented, good and studious prodigy that people has grew fond of over the years. Fan and Critics are are aware of the potential she is capable of, and she does show us glimpse of brilliance but is frustrating because the package is not well rounded enough, and her artistic side not recognised by the COP. However, as with life, everyone have peaks and troves, and everyone make little mistakes now and then. The good thing is they usually come back much stronger and maturer.
Just look at Yuna's failure in 2007, 2008 at WC, and then her amazing streak of 2009-2010 after it. And since the Olympics, how Mao's came back in 2010 WC with her best performances in 2 years. It says it all really. That is why I think next year WC would be very interesting to see from both Ladies. It seems Mao has come out of the slump now with rules in her favour - performing on home ground - with hopefully best programs than ever, Vs Yuna who seemed lack in motivation to compete and said wanting to push the artistic side of things, which never really count much under the current COP. It would be a match of such 'high expectations', I am literally shaken in anticipation while booking a plane ticket to Tokyo as we speak
Last edited by os168; 06-03-2010 at 06:10 AM.
I don’t believe an off-ice image and an on-ice character will interfere with each other. They are totally separate. Also, I think Mao’s sponsors throw money at her because of her off-ice image. She could portray a prostitute from an opera, and they wouldn’t care. She is an excellent role model for other girls her age.
Originally Posted by RumbleFish
As for “trying to maintain her off ice image as an innocent girl”, well, is that just an image?
I would like to add this to dorispulaski's post, number 54 above.
Trolling is defined as making posts that have no other purpose than to annoy and provoke other members of the forum. Posts of this sort are not welcome and will be deleted without comment.
If you have questions, comments or complaints about the administration of this forum, put them in the Feedback folder, not in on-topic threads.
Originally Posted by prettykeys
Are you seriously serious?
Anywho... I don't need a special thread to say something nice about Mao because her skating is sick and I admire any skater who is willing to take a chance in an Olympic year. As tradition goes, skaters tend to dial it back and skate for perfection vs. innovation in an Olympic year. No major coaching changes, safe music & cheoro, conservative costuming... safe & solid is the way to play the olympic game.
Mao had no real incentive to push herself technically this season, but she did it anyway. (I'm still a bit cranky about what I saw as underscoring by the officials but what can you do?) This is not a skater content to rest on her laurels - a true fighter and I love that about her.
And for those of you who think Mao is too innocent; check out the leather dominatrix outfit.