- Joined
- Jul 30, 2009
I saw a video of Miki doing it in practice before the Olympics. Now I can't find it on YouTube.
Who among the Ladies has a 3-3 this year?
- Thread starter Mrs. P
- Start date
I saw a video of Miki doing it in practice before the Olympics. Now I can't find it on YouTube.
It was amazing! So much distance. Also is it me or is Gao look totally different? I want to say she's grown a few inches, but I think she's about the same height as last year. Maybe she has more muscle?
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2009
Icenetwork now has her listed as 5'2", last year she was listed as 5'1", so she's grown a little, but not much, I think more her body is changing into a more mature one and so her torso looks more in proportion to her legs than before.
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2008
- Country
-
It was underrotated. So, nope, nobody has done a 2Axel-3Loop combination in the history of the sport yet (AFAIK).
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2009
It was underrotated. So, nope, nobody has done a 2Axel-3Loop combination in the history of the sport yet (AFAIK).
Well, maybe Anna will be the first
. And if she does do that combination and it gets ratified all the people who complain about how bad her jumps are will be eating lots of crow. GOOO ANNA :yay:! I love that girl so much - so musical, so charismatic, so happy 
- Joined
- Jan 15, 2010
Oh my. Russians really aren't kidding about Sochi aren't they?
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2008
- Country
-
After Russia's disastrous outing in Vancouver, where I personally feel they should have been completely shut out of the medals, I would certainly hope not.
Miyabi Oba went for a 2A-3Lo combo at one local competition in March. It was a step-out but fully rotated. There was a video on YT covering the competition (not sure still available).
http://www.skatingjapan.jp/local/2009-2010/fs/24/02_ijs/data0305.pdf
http://www.skatingjapan.jp/local/2009-2010/fs/24/02_ijs/data0305.pdf
I'm your friend, Anna is my favourite Russian skater.
I hope, Mirai and Mr. Carrol will include 3L-3T in her FS.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2009
I'm your friend, Anna is my favourite Russian skater.
I hope, Mirai and Mr. Carrol will include 3L-3T in her FS.
Me too. Anna is very good friends with Elena Ilynihk who thinks that Anna is actually the best of all the young Russian female singles skaters right now
.And I hope Mirai goes for 3lz-3t in SP and FS, I think she is totally capable. Wishing her a speedy recovery from her injury!
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2007
Many of the top American ladies haven't yet skated this summer, so we don't yet know about Ashley, Caroline, Mirai or Rachael. I don't recall Alissa ever having a triple / triple.
Yes, and she is in the North America Team for Japan Open, so I hope that means her injury is not very serious.
Polymer,
Alissa did a 3z-3t at SA 2005.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QC4Fm1uy5hI
I don't know if she ever landed one again. Any historians remember if that 3-3 was DGed?
Alissa did a 3z-3t at SA 2005.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QC4Fm1uy5hI
I don't know if she ever landed one again. Any historians remember if that 3-3 was DGed?
- Joined
- Jan 15, 2010
http://www.isufs.org/results/gpusa05/GPUSA05_Ladies_FS_Scores.pdf
Assuming that they didn't have symbols for UR/DG back then, it was counted as a 3Lz+2T with negative GOE.
Liza Tuktamysheva has definitely grown up a bit, but here 3lz-3t is still there.
Mishin's camp gala a couple of weeks ago.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S3q4wARd_hU
Mishin's camp gala a couple of weeks ago.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S3q4wARd_hU
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2005
It was underrotated. So, nope, nobody has done a 2Axel-3Loop combination in the history of the sport yet (AFAIK).
It doesn't matter if you think it was under rotated. The protocols are what counts and according to the them it was rotated. So Joey Russell has completed the jump. Another Canadian skater, Jayson Denommee did triple axel triple loop combinations in the early 2000s.
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2008
- Country
-
LOL, the protocols are absolutely not what counts. Using your own eyes and brain is what counts. It's a National competition; they went easy on him and clearly didn't look closely (or care to look closely) at the jump.
Regardless, nobody has done the move in international competition yet.
Regardless, nobody has done the move in international competition yet.
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2005
to the bolded part - I am pretty sure that protocols are what counts and matter to everyone. They are what counts to skaters, commentators, coaches, choreographers, and us fans. The ISU and National federations also use them to evaluate the judges and other officials. If they didn't matter, why would we pore over them after every competition?? The jump was close to being under rotated but it is hard to tell because of the camera angle - you can't say definitely that it was UR. The judges called it clean so it is clean. We have seen this many times with other jumps in the past that have been questionable yet were called/not called.
It is hard to say if the jump has been done in international competition - it could have been completed years ago but there is no available video for it or protocols to study.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2008
- Country
-
:disapp:
Protocols are nothing but the marks of a few people who mostly don't know what they are doing, filtered through whatever the current rules of the scoring system are. They are absolutely not "what matters".
Obviously they are important to competitors and coaches for knowing what levels their elements got scored at and what kind of GOE and PCS grades they are receiving. That doesn't mean every downgrade call or every level call was correct just because the protocol says so, much less that the judges scored a skater correctly after evaluating the performance for yourself.
If protocols are what matters most to all choreographers, good GOD, the sport would be dead. Obviously choreographers need to make sure the programs are going to allow the skaters to get points under whatever the judging system is, though. And of course many choreographers will continually recycle what has worked in the past.
As for FANS, how ridiculous to say protocols are what matters to fans most. If you wanted to win a "most inane statement of the year" award, you surely succeeded. Many skating officials don't understand the protocols, much less fans. Some fans don't even know protocols exist. They just see the numbers that come up at competitions. Whenever I am in the stands at competitions, I pretty much always have to explain everything to people around me. Even family members of other skaters usually have no idea what the numbers mean.
Um, yes I can. He leaves the ice facing the camera and lands 1/8 of a turn past that point. His foot is clearly at a slanted angle and not parallel to the camera, which would the minimum point he'd have to land at before the jump would get downgraded by a tech caller who was paying proper attention.
It's noticeable in real time that the jump was short, most likely caused by the way he went off axis in the air. Don't make me have to go through the trouble of creating a screen cap for this.
Similar threads
