- Joined
- Oct 20, 2010
Another fail. Kristi beat Michelle in artistic scores when they met at the Ultimate Four in 97 when Kwan was already in her prime and had some of her best programs (people might say they were even better than 98 had she actually skated them cleanly more), an even which Michelle won only after Kristi imploded on her jumps in the 2nd round after leading. Kristi was given a perfect 6.0 and almost all 5.9s for presentation in the short program by ISU judges who were probably biased to the amateurs before Michelle even skated. If Tara managed to tie Kwan in presentation by half the judges in the long program, it is silly to just say with certainty Kwan would easily get higher 2nd marks than Kristi.
Kristi improved her artistry immensely over her time as a pro. I loved her as both an eligible and a pro skater, she is probably my second favorite lady of all time, but the difference between competitive Kristi and pro Kristi is night and day. I don't even really like Lyra Angelica (I'm sure I'll be tarred and feathered for saying that, but it's probably my least favorite Michelle program, or at least my least favorite of her "major opus works"), but there is absolutely no comparison. Kristi's program was technically brilliant, but the music was just a huge mismatch for her personality and her performance skills at that time. Lyra kicks it's butt up one side and down the other. So does Tara's. Frankly, so does Midori's free skate from Calgary.