I am trying to figure out what the judges are looking for so I understand the sport better, so I ask this question:
What, besides the jumps, varies from competition to competition?
Does a skater exhibit better edges at Skate Canada than at Skate America? Or, assuming the music is the same, will he or she interpret it better at NHK than at Cup of China?
I know jumps are made or missed, and occasionally a spin or footwork is messed up, but what about those other skating skills?
It seems to me that a skater who is considered to have deep edges, a good line, and great speed and other "skating skills" now has such an advantage that there is little competition any more, or at least they are practically guaranteed a win over certain people, regardless of jumps landed or falls. If these skills don't vary that much, then, for example, Caroline Z will never beat Carolina K. Even if CZ skates clean (I know--out of my mouth and into God's ears) and CK makes a few major mistakes. Because CK is always faster, with better lines, etc. (I'm not sugesting that CZ should have beaten CK in any particular competition, I'm just u sing them as extreme examples on the slow/fast continuum).
Am I correct? Or do these skills vary more than I think from time to time?
What, besides the jumps, varies from competition to competition?
Does a skater exhibit better edges at Skate Canada than at Skate America? Or, assuming the music is the same, will he or she interpret it better at NHK than at Cup of China?
I know jumps are made or missed, and occasionally a spin or footwork is messed up, but what about those other skating skills?
It seems to me that a skater who is considered to have deep edges, a good line, and great speed and other "skating skills" now has such an advantage that there is little competition any more, or at least they are practically guaranteed a win over certain people, regardless of jumps landed or falls. If these skills don't vary that much, then, for example, Caroline Z will never beat Carolina K. Even if CZ skates clean (I know--out of my mouth and into God's ears) and CK makes a few major mistakes. Because CK is always faster, with better lines, etc. (I'm not sugesting that CZ should have beaten CK in any particular competition, I'm just u sing them as extreme examples on the slow/fast continuum).
Am I correct? Or do these skills vary more than I think from time to time?