Wicked Yankee Girl
US Selections for Junior Worlds
US Figure Skating has been tweeting it's picks for Junior Worlds a frustating bit at a time:
Ladies: Agnes Zawadzki, Courtney Hicks, Christina Gao
Alternates: Lam, Siraj, Gong
Men: Will be listed after the Senior Men's Final today
Dance: Charlotte Lichtman & Dean Copley, Lauri Bonacorsi & Travis Mager, Anastasia Cannuscio & Colin McManus,
Alternates: Olson & Cowan and Yang & Baker
Men have just been added.
Men on U.S. World Junior Team are Max Aaron, Jason Brown, Keegan Messing..
.alternates are Alex Zahradnicek, Steven Evans, Philip Warren
This is so unfair to Zahradnicek who earned his way to be on the Team as a full member yet he gets pushed aside to make room for the ageless seniors. The USFS should straighten this out to rule once a skater of less than so many years can opt to be a Junior or a Senior but not Both. How many European skaters skate both Seniors and Juniors?
Originally Posted by nadster
Wicked Yankee Girl
Brown is 16. So I don't think he qualifies as a "ageless senior". The perhaps unwritten rule appears to be that if you won juniors at Nationals & are age eligible, you move up to Seniors the next year. He did. So the question is, was his performance at seniors good enough to place him over Zahradnicek? And it was.
I'm not that familiar with Juniors, but am surprised that it's not like seniors when it comes to the selection process.
Imho the most fair decision would be to send those that placed 1, 2, 3 or 1, 2 depending on how many spots were earned the previous year. Anything else reeks of politics, favoritism, et al.
And I don't care how good somebody is, if they didn't earn their spot on the team, sorry, come back again next year. Thank God seniors plays fair 99% of the time (e.g. this year's Nationals).
Joesitz, a number of European skaters have done both junior and seniors. Alena Leonova won junior worlds, came top five at senior Europeans, top ten at Worlds. Denis Ten of Kazakhstan went to both junior and senior worlds, along with 4CC n 2009. Michal Brezina went to Euros for two seasons while still competing on the junior circuit. Ira Vannut of Belgium was at Europeans this season while still competing on the junior circuit.
The distinction between junior and senior internationally is different than it is in most countries. Nationally, its about skill level (if you pass such-and-such test, you're considered a senior). Internationally, it's strictly a designation of age.
I was not bringing up the case for Brown. i was speaking of the system. USFS says Brown is eligible to skate Seniors and ISU says he is ok to skate Juniors. He didn't do both. He only skated Seniors and now he will skate Junior Worlds. It's all perfectly legal, but I believe the Senior system for Americans is to place at senior Nats, and if podiumed that is reason enough to skate Worlds. Brown didn't place at Junior Nats, and I felt it was only his age was considered plus the ok by the special committee would allow him to skate junior worlds.
Originally Posted by dorispulaski
This didn't happen for Abbott. What if he didn't skate Worlds? I just think there should be a meeting of the minds on what exactly constitutes a Junior in the USFS.
Jason Brown competed as a junior in the JGP series this season. He won a silver medal in France and was an alternate for the JGP final. It was his age eligibility and previous international accomplishments at the junior level that were taken into consideration by the selection committee. For what it's worth, the skaters understand what the process is for being selected.
Originally Posted by Joesitz
I think Richard Dornbush is a good example of how well the US system can work for a skater. Even though he also competed as a junior internationally, he skated senior at nationals. Had he been forced to skate at his international level, he would have most likely walked away with the junior title and be going to junior worlds instead of worlds.
In regards to juniors winning junior worlds, this is the link for last years results, http://www.isuresults.com/results/wjc2010/CAT001RS.HTM . If you click on the skaters name, their ISU bio shows their placement at their national event for the 09/10 season. At a quick glance, other than the pairs team, all the other gold medalists competed junior at their nationals too.
Last edited by Tammi; 02-07-2011 at 09:39 PM.