Regional Stereotypes? | Golden Skate

Regional Stereotypes?

cksmwc

Match Penalty
Joined
Mar 5, 2011
So I'm working on a project for school, discussing the various stylistic stereotypes from a certain region - ie, from Europe/Russia, North America/US, and Asia. It seems like it's a question of skating style; ie, the Russians are considered to be the most artistic or balletic. What do you think the stereotypes for each region are, and do you think there's any truth to them?
 
Joined
Jun 21, 2003
Here is a good place to start. Check out the 2002 Olympics pairs performances of Shen and Zhao (China), Berezhnaya and Sikharudlize (Russia -- see especially their short program), and Sale and Pelletier (Canada). (Better, use the 2003 World championships for Shen and Zhao.
 

smia

Rinkside
Joined
Oct 25, 2010
It depends on the discipline. While many Russian pairs and ice dancers have been balletic, Russian singles were not known for that at all. However, this may be changing with skaters like Adelina Sotnikova.
 
Joined
Jun 21, 2003
Actually, once you get past John Curry (British), it is hard to think of a skater who is "balletic." Maybe Oksana Baiul (Ukrainian). Or Toller Cranston, if you want a different kind of ballet. :laugh:

For an interesting comparison within a country, the artistic Belousova and Protopopov versus the athletic Rodnina and Zeitsev is a fascinating contrast.
 

blue dog

Trixie Schuba's biggest fan!
Record Breaker
Joined
Dec 16, 2006
Actually, once you get past John Curry (British), it is hard to think of a skater who is "balletic." Maybe Oksana Baiul (Ukrainian). Or Toller Cranston, if you want a different kind of ballet. :laugh:

For an interesting comparison within a country, the artistic Belousova and Protopopov versus the athletic Rodnina and Zeitsev is a fascinating contrast.

I think the "winners" have a lot to do with changing the style of a whole region. Take, for example, Dubreuil and Lauzon. For years before them, the style of Canadian, and even North American dance was athletic (Bourne/Kraatz). The athletic dancers were excellent, but the emphasis was more on athleticism, rather than the storytelling. Then, Dubreuil and Lauzon began winning, and the style shifted towards the understated storytelling. The athleticism is still there, but it's less overt.
 

dorispulaski

Wicked Yankee Girl
Joined
Jul 26, 2003
Country
United-States
I would have said that the style of Dubreuil & Lauzon was Romance Novel on Ice.
 

ivy

On the Ice
Joined
Feb 6, 2005
Of course any 'national style' has many, many exceptions to the rule. Here's my quick, shooting from the hip, take

Russian - high style, decorative, technically accomplished - like a Faberge egg or the Winter Palace - Plushy, Maria B, Irina

French - similar to Russian but slightly simplified, funkier. Baroque instead of Roccoco - Marina & Gwendal, Amodio, Candeloro

US - cool, classy, elegant - Michelle, Nancy, Evan, Todd

I have a harder time with a Japanese skating identity - maybe elegant, intricate, intellectual? It seems to me that Takahashi, Kozuka & Oda are stylistically very different. I wonder if it has to do with a western sport/art being over layed over an eastern culture producing even more variation
 

blue dog

Trixie Schuba's biggest fan!
Record Breaker
Joined
Dec 16, 2006
Ivy, I think Asian skaters are a. still trying to find an identity that is distinctly Asian that will be "accepted by the ISU" (Many people believed Chen Lu assimilated into the Western style to win) or b. are very very versatile that they can do any style. I'm more inclined to say B, but then again, I think that is true of any skater. As fans, many of us just get used to them doing one style, that when they attempt another, we may think it's not as good as what they used to do (Kwan, when she attempted the blues).

If we want to see regional stereotypes, we may want to look at packaging. Russians tend to have more dramatic costumes and arm movements, whereas North Americans tend to stick to more subdued costuming. With Asian skaters, it seems to depend on their choreographer (those of the Nichol school have more subdued costuming and packaging, whereas those of the Tarasova/Morozov/Zhulin school seem more Russian).
 
Joined
Jul 11, 2003
Of course, I don't see why a solo skater has to be balletic. There are so many forms of Dance. Why should it be the chosen one for figure skating. I think there is a musical style that skaters can manage. Michelle Kwan was/is a beautiful skater that was not at all like a ballerina. Her body flowed with the music as did her arms and were not restricted to classical ballet positions. She was a first rate figure skater. So are a few male skaters, which your term paper might include.

To be honest, I believe the topic should also include Acrobatics and Contortionism which predominates figure skating of today. Both these forms of "dance" get lots of wows in competitive skating.
 

miki88

Medalist
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
If we want to see regional stereotypes, we may want to look at packaging. Russians tend to have more dramatic costumes and arm movements, whereas North Americans tend to stick to more subdued costuming. With Asian skaters, it seems to depend on their choreographer (those of the Nichol school have more subdued costuming and packaging, whereas those of the Tarasova/Morozov/Zhulin school seem more Russian).

True. In general, I think Asian skaters are a little more reserved in terms of performance. They express through their body movements or gestures instead of their faces. Although there are certainly exceptions such as Daisuke and Akiko who are both quite facially expressive.
 

gio

Medalist
Joined
Jan 23, 2006
For this topic one can even write a book. I mean, it is really interesting about the various styles and influences on FS. After all it is an art. One can analyze many factors (cultural for exemple) that lead to a style. Or the elements (costumes, performance, choreography, music choices etc.) that characterise a style.

There are regional patterns which are somehow visible even for the more inexperienced eye (Russian style, French, American). But there are many exceptions and nuances. Every skater/team could be analyzed from program to program.
There are temporal patterns (a similiar topic I've opened some years ago about the different music choices in the various decades, which in a way sometimes reflected the fashion of the time and sometimes not).
And obviously there are also coach and choreographer patterns.
 

dorispulaski

Wicked Yankee Girl
Joined
Jul 26, 2003
Country
United-States
One thing that influences the style of the skaters is the group of pieces they choose their music from. Very few American or Canadian skaters are the first to pick a particular Russian movie theme (despite so many of US coaches being Russian), whereas Russian skaters pick them more frequently. However, after a Russian skater or team has introduced a particularly skatable piece of Russian music, a Western team will often pick it up.
 

blue dog

Trixie Schuba's biggest fan!
Record Breaker
Joined
Dec 16, 2006
One thing that influences the style of the skaters is the group of pieces they choose their music from. Very few American or Canadian skaters are the first to pick a particular Russian movie theme (despite so many of US coaches being Russian), whereas Russian skaters pick them more frequently. However, after a Russian skater or team has introduced a particularly skatable piece of Russian music, a Western team will often pick it up.

This is true, Doris, but it might have to do with the accessibility of the piece. I've tried to get Maria B's Seventeen Moments In Spring to use for my silver test, because it's slooowww. I can't get it.

You're right; when Russian skaters debut a Russian film and are successful with it, it becomes a piece that western skaters want to skate to, like My Sweet and Tender Beast.

The reverse is also true, but NA soundtracks are more available, than Russian ones, or in my case, even German ones (I paid 30 bucks to get Katarina Witt's Where Have All The Flowers Gone!).
 

gkelly

Record Breaker
Joined
Jul 26, 2003
You're right; when Russian skaters debut a Russian film and are successful with it, it becomes a piece that western skaters want to skate to, like My Sweet and Tender Beast.

So who popularized that one? The first time I heard the music (as far as I know) was Chait and Sakhnovsky's free dance in 1997. But it wasn't brand new music at the time, so possibly some other mid-ranked teams or singles skaters had used it before then and I just hadn't seen/heard enough programs at that level.

Then in 1998-99 Silverstein and Pekarek were using it for their original dance, probably supplied by their Russian coach.

And later that season Anissina and Peizerat changed their OD music to use that piece, which is probably what got the attention of the rest of the skating world.

Some of the skaters named above were originally from Russia, but none of them was competing for Russia at the time. :)
 
Joined
Jul 11, 2003
I think Russian influence on music had to pass the prevailing censorship from the early days of Communism up to its fall. I think they considered Western Pop Music to be anti-music. That would eliminate some wonderful background movie scores. How many Russian composers had to flee their country to be more expressive?

The leading ballerina during that period had to beg to dance Giselle because the last scene in the ballet takes place in a religious cementery. It was changed accordingly. Giselle got a non sectarian burial.

Nowadays, times have changed and there is constant exchange of creative artists and performing artists throughout the world. How wonderful that is.

What does it all have to do with Figure Skating? I think one would have to look at Ice Dance for the answer.
 

blue dog

Trixie Schuba's biggest fan!
Record Breaker
Joined
Dec 16, 2006
Whole Thread

Or, it may just be taste. Russians tend to like folk songs a lot more. When they use Russian soundtracks, depending on the composer, the music has a distinct feel and tempo. Isaak Shvarts, the composer of Tune of White Nights had very soft, lyrical music. Schnittke is far from lyrical (he seemed to thrive on dissonance), and Doga (who isn't Russian), had a very dreamy quality.

When using classical music, Russians also tend to stick to their own. Big, booming Tchaikovsky, and passionate Rachmaninoff.
 

siberia82

Addicted to Canadian men's singles skating
Record Breaker
Joined
Jun 18, 2008
Country
Canada
Canadian men singles' skaters are renowned for either their artistry (especially footwork) or their athleticism (a lot of "firsts" were accomplished by Canadian guys), but rarely both. In other words, they tend to be categorized as inconsistent performers or boring jumpers.

Swedish men's singles' skaters (more specifically Berntsson and Schultheiss, though I think Stiller can be included as well) are often praised for their innovative choreography, and are frequently described as "voidy" by FSUers. Majorov doesn't quite fit this mold, though, so I'm not sure how his recent success might affect this perception.
 

gkelly

Record Breaker
Joined
Jul 26, 2003
Canadian men singles' skaters are renowned for either their artistry (especially footwork) or their athleticism (a lot of "firsts" were accomplished by Canadian guys), but rarely both. In other words, they tend to be categorized as inconsistent performers or boring jumpers.

I'd argue that Brian Orser and Kurt Browning fit both those categories. But we could consider them exceptions.
 

siberia82

Addicted to Canadian men's singles skating
Record Breaker
Joined
Jun 18, 2008
Country
Canada
I'd argue that Brian Orser and Kurt Browning fit both those categories. But we could consider them exceptions.

I did take them into account when I wrote "rarely both". ;)
 
Top