- Joined
- Dec 11, 2011
i understand that unlike flatt's moscow worlds skate, AC's GPF performance didn't affect any other skater's ability to enter future competitions. that is a significant difference.
IMO AC's skate wasn't embarrassing and awful. in fact it showed her pride and determination, how fiercely she fought for some of those jump landings. it showed how far she's come that she could eek out those landings even when in pain and not at her physical best.
and i honestly don't think anybody has to say *anything* to her. she's clearly a strong person who's come back from much lower points than this. this performance was affected by injury.
no disrespect to the OP, who i think means well, but i think it's a bit unfair to her for anyone outside the situation to presume that she needs comforting, like she was profoundly shaken by this one bad skate, or thinks all the progress she's made with her jump consistency has gone away because of one skating-while-injured performance. i would have thought that her fans would have more faith in her own words--that she's a new skater now-- the 12th place finisher at worlds is long gone.
i have at times questioned the holding up of her spins and spirals as the ultimate standard. i still wonder about the non-calls of her underrotated jumps, still dislike her stiffness and narrow range, but i don't question her strength as a competitor or the improvement in her jump technique. and i wonder if well-meaning folks who rush to send her comforting words are all the while re-enforcing the notion that she's somehow terribly fragile, when she's in fact incredibly resilient.
Point taken, skfan. I worried that my post implied just what you say immediately after I wrote it. To clarify, I don't mean to suggest that Alissa is more psychologically fragile than any other skater competing today. I posted this question in reference to Alissa because she happens to be my favorite skater of the past 3-4 years; I just have a greater concern for her than I do for other skaters!
I think a skate like that would rattle anyone. Lots of people (incorrectly) blame their own lack of ability even when they have legitimate "external" explanations for their lack of success (in this case, for Alissa, the injury). And I was especially concerned in this case because it was, by a notable margin, Alissa's most flawed FS since the beginning of last season. (I agree, though, that it would be an exaggeration to say it was embarrassing or awful.)