Men's 2003 Grand Prix Final

Kasey · Dec 22, 2003

Okay, since it's such a huge source of "conversation" in the Grand Prix forum, why not vote for it here? Who do YOU think should have won this year's Grand Prix final for the men? Plushenko, Sandhu, or "other" (Other being a euphamism for "all those other dudes who were unable to keep their tushies off the ice!")

Kasey

Spark · Dec 22, 2003

I didn't actually see Plushenko's skate because of the interruption, but judging by the reports I read the results seem fair. The rules state that a skater is only allowed two combinations. Perhaps after this season they should alter that rule so that in a situation like this, the first jump of an illegal third combination would be counted as a solo jump. But since the rules have been firmly in place all season, what were the judges supposed to do, give Plushenko credit for the third combo anyway?

Going by what I've seen of both men's programs, Sandhu with a quad and two triple axels should place ahead of Plushy with two quads and no credited triple axel.

mike79 · Dec 22, 2003

Sandhu deserved it. Sorry about Plushenko, but it's his and Mishin's fault for not knowing the rules.

mpal2 · Dec 22, 2003

Sandhu won.

Even though Evgeni did an illegal combo and didn't get credit, he still would have won if he bothered to put in the salchow at the end. He got complacent, forgot about the rules, left stuff out and lost fair and square.

Doggygirl · Dec 22, 2003

BIG Ditto with Mpal2...

Knowing and adhering to the rules seems like a really basic requirement for any competitor in a sport, much less at the elite level. No tears for Plushy over this one from my eyeballs.

DG

amazonprincess · Dec 22, 2003

Regardless of the rules, Emanuel was far more interesting to watch skate at the GPF. I think he deserves his gold.

CassidyL · Dec 23, 2003

Same feelings as Doggygirl here.

I can't imagine how anyone would think Plushy should have won since that would have involved some shady judging, and we all know how everyone feels about that.

Mathman · Dec 23, 2003

mpal2 said:
Sandhu won.

Even though Evgeni did an illegal combo and didn't get credit, he still would have won if he bothered to put in the salchow at the end. He got complacent, forgot about the rules, left stuff out and lost fair and square.

I wonder if he got complacent or if he was just too tired to do that Salchow at the end. I didn't get to see Evgeny's performance, thanks to the orange alert -- like Joe said, what are we supposed to do, rush out and buy duck tape? -- but all of the men that I did see looked like they were about to pass out at the end of their programs, because of the altitude. Maybe it got to Engeny, too.

Mathman

mpal2 · Dec 24, 2003

Either too tired or in too much pain from delaying knee surgery. I wasn't thinking about that when I typed the above statement. I'll let those who actually got to see the program let us know, but I still think he was surprised by the loss. Based on the interviews, I think he expected to still win after making mistakes or leaving jumps out.

falula · Dec 28, 2003

amazonprincess, I could not agree more!
i was there and watched the whole event and Eman won fair and square. Emanual should have won even if Plushy hadn't added a combo. Eman just has such a amazing quality. and Plushy just sorta stands and poses IMO

RealtorGal · Dec 29, 2003

falula said:
...and Plushy just sorta stands and poses IMO

Although Plushy is not my favorite skater, that is HARDLY an appropriate description of his skating. He's incredibly energetic and hardly maintains any single "pose" for more than a moment!

Ice Princess · Dec 29, 2003

Evgeni & Mike looked disappointed on the podium, but Sandhu deserved it! They were probably surprised that a substitute won, but he was good-otherwise he wouldn't have been there! I thought good for him! That's a big break for him!

mpal2 · Dec 29, 2003

RealtorGal said:
Although Plushy is not my favorite skater, that is HARDLY an appropriate description of his skating. He's incredibly energetic and hardly maintains any single "pose" for more than a moment!

After trying to take some pictures of him during 2003 Worlds, I would have to agree that he hardly maintains a pose for more than a moment. IMO, he is one of the most difficult skaters if you're trying to get a decent picture. Plus, if you are facing the judges the only view you'll get of him is his backside. All of the skaters are somewhat judge centric, but he really took that to a new level. :laugh:

shine · Dec 30, 2003

Plushenko had one more quad. So what? Even if he didn't do the axel combo Sandhu would still have deserved the gold. The judges totally robbed Emanuel in the TCS marks. No way he should be more than a point lower in almost ever TCS mark than Plushenko.

icedancingnut31 · Jan 9, 2004

Plushenko

Ptichka · Jan 9, 2004

Under the old 6.0 system, Plushy would have probably won. I think most judges would not have placed Sandhu 1st. However, under CoP, the results where fair and square; considering the event was judged by CoP, I'd have to say Sandhu should have won.

246579 · Jan 26, 2004

totally agree! GO E-MAN!

curious · Jan 27, 2004

a thread to justify eman's technicality win. Plushenko had the best skate but noone here is going to recognize that because he is not your fave skater,that's okay the guy is going to win his third world title

SusanBeth · Feb 2, 2004

If you don't follow the rules, you deserve to lose.

Kasey · Feb 5, 2004

Curious, I only started this thread because *I* was curious as to what the majority of people who saw the competition thought. It appears that the majority feels that Eman deserved the win, whether it is a "technicality" or not.

Sure, Plush may well win World's for a third time this year. Then again, Eman could win there also....or Klimkin....or Joubert....or some other unexpected person. Joubert's win today at Euro's certainly wasn't on a "technicality"....Plush IS beatable. Maybe it's due to the injury. Maybe he's been unchallenged at the top for too long. Maybe something totally different. But he ain't the same Plush of last year, or two years ago.

Kasey

Men's 2003 Grand Prix Final

Who should have won the 2003 Grand Prix Men's final?

Evgeny Plushenko

Emmanuel Sandhu

Other (Please, PLEASE explain a response to THIS one!! Hee hee)

Kasey

Spark

mike79

mpal2

Doggygirl

amazonprincess

CassidyL

Mathman

mpal2

falula

RealtorGal

Ice Princess

mpal2

shine

icedancingnut31

Ptichka

Forum translator

246579

curious

SusanBeth

Kasey

Similar threads

Connect with us