Still, Kim Clijsters, for instance, won a grand slam (US Open), which probably was an equivalent of, or similar to, an Oly gold medal for pro tennsi player, at the time she retired. Kim then married and had a child. She then came back as an even more successful career (three more gland slam titles) woman!
As far as I know, Kim is the only come back player with even more successful career the second time around. And she did it as a working mother. I don't know about you, but Kim's feat to me is just as remarkable.
Also, Michael Jordan did a brief stint into minor baseball to honor his murderd father's wishes. His second and third come back (just like Plusy attempts to do) as an NBA player is more substantial.
I wouldnt call Lambiel's comeback as coming back from retirement comeback, even if he announced retirement in between, cause he missed a season due to the injury, something Daisuke did also that same season. Nevertheless however you call it, it doesnt take away both comebacks and the oustanding results they had in 2009-2010 season.
There is no reason to compare athletes, each one has their own story to inspire. And how much inspiring was the comeback of Elena Berezhnaya after brain surgery..
There are less famous comeback stories than MJordan. Kyle Shewfelt in Gymnastics broke both his legs one year before 2008 Olympics but he came back. Mila Marinova had a break of 8-9 years before coing back to rythmic gymnastics again. My fav comeback of other sports is Dara Torres.
Wasnt there an american swimmer who said in Bejing that as he was competing and watched the bottom of the pool he realised that that was all he was doing in his life, lost concentration and lost the competition?
Do you think all these athletes are having meaningless lives outside their sport or nothing better to do? Thats like mere mortals thinking. I dont think I can enter and explain those people's mindset but I can admire them.
It doesn't matter the sport, competition is about winning, being the best you can be, and beating the other guy or girl that is your rival. Your glorious Olympic moment on the podium, or wherever. Plushenko's team may be setting us up a bit. "Evgeni the bionic skater will now have spinal surgery. Expect him to recover, as afterall, he expects to be on the podium in Sochi." People lie all the time in skating about their injuries to avoid a competiton, or not to let their real problems be known to competitors. Or to look heroic. Good PR. Look at Flatt re last years Worlds. Surprising for me that Flatt and her team did it that way.
Remember how people reverently spoke of Irina when she came back after such illness? Fluff peices really helped her with national audiences and maybe with judges. But someone with spinal injury for real in much pain would not risk living in hell (and it is hell I can assure you) for a bronze medal. Bronze medal. Why would he care about a bronze medal at this point? If Plush has significant injury and risks, we may well have his Euros as his last great skate. I personally was very disappointed to see Yags unable to compete after SLC and see him doing programs with SOI on with Kings with no great jumping. It was part of what made him the champion he was. Like watching Elvis without the jumps. Just no fun.
I pray for your Dad, Toni and wish him well.
One great skating comeback not mentioned Hong Bo Zhao after blowing his achilles tendon. It is amazing what he did. I would retire. Seriously, Patrick at this rate is already unbeatable. So a perfect Plush could get bronze. I don't expect Patrick to melt down in his second Olympics. I guess we will see how much longer and if Evgeni skates, and if he goes to Sochi for the glory. At his age and stage, it has to be one day at a time. Hanyu if healthy is the the spolier, I truly believe that. I just expect amazing skating from him, and he has killer instinct. Dai is already eclipsed, I feel.
As for thinking that this Olympics may have a judging scandal, I think it more likely than 2006, the Oly Torino, or the 2010 Oly in Canada, figureskating was under much scrutiny after Salt lake when evrryone knew about skategate. I think the placements were perfect in skating last two Olympics. Judges behaved well. The only result some might have debated in ladies were that Mirai skated lights out and deserved the bronze. But Joannie skated well enough to earn it, and how could they have placed her fourth? I never looked at the protocols, but one never yells wazrobbed when North America sat there sobbing. And a sophisticated home girl could make a couple errors and still easily place over a perfect newcomer in this system. If Mirai were our national Champion for a couple years and hd rep points, she might have placed third. Only a perfect Michelle Kwan with a CoP program could have taken the bronze from Joannie. So I think the skating judges have been perfect at the last two Olympics. I only expected Mao to score closer to Yuna, but I wasn't counting points or reading about CoP then.
It seems even ice dance has become so much better/more fairly judged by far. It was fixed for so long. I don't want to be cheeky but I expect some sort of problem with the judged sports and something controversial in skating, perhaps in 2014. I expected it in Bejing, and i wasn't "disappointed." Just call it a hunch. I hope I'm wrong, but I expect drama. Evgeni may be the source, or a female russian skater. I feel team Russia feels they can have two to three gold medals in figure skating alone. They sure are doing all they can to make it happen after their huge Vancouver disappointments.
Last edited by skateluvr; 02-23-2012 at 10:59 PM.
One more tennis player I'd like to mention is Evonne Goolagong. I don't remember exactly how much time she spent off the court, but she won Wimbledon for the first time at the age of 19 and then didn't win Wimbledon again until she was thirty, after having a child. I think she was the only mother to win Wimbledon in the modern era--is she still? Quite a comeback, in any case. She was always one of my favorite players.
Like the other posters, I don't bring this up to detract from Plushy's reputation but because it's so interesting to think about all of these athletes who have beaten the odds. Seniorita, I agree that Dara Torres may have set the record for reviving a career. I think she's trying for this upcoming Olympics, too. What is she, 46 years old? You go, girl!
Toni, I also wanted to say good luck for your dad's surgery, I forgot to say that getting caught up in this back surgery talk. Hopefully this is a case of Plushy's team bluffing and trying to build up a great comeback narrative for Sochi. I think with the home field advantage that Chan will have to out-jump Plushenko to beat him; the judges are not going to take Evgeny out on PCS, not in Russia.
I know sports psychlogy and the mind games, but I wouldnt wish for anyone to have Irina's disease so that she cant get pitty marks from judges in her comeback. I m sure she didnt plan for it either.
And Plushenko's health issues were not sth new, especially his back and knee date since 2005. I dont know what they did to him at free Euros skate but a look at his Q round, his skate was a mess.
Anyway I saw today a Mishin interview but it dates before the surgery, and contrary to press article he looks very calm and not so worrying, so I guess it is not such a big injury as it was indicated. I post here part of translation.
Zhenya's health status is very good. We just want to get rid of the effects of old injuries. This is a prolonged return. Now everything is different, than it was before the Olympics in Vancouver. The second return of Plushenko is designed for several seasons. And to be he looked worthily during these seasons on the ice, the body should be a little repair. We had time for that, because Zhenya not participate this year on world championship. He has whole three months to recover. Next year, due to the team world championship, such a pause in his schedule will not be. Here we have used free time, to be - once again I emphasize - preventively eliminate his weak points, accumulated over many years. And how could it be otherwise, if a man for twenty years, jumping complex multi-turns jumps? It would be strange, if anything would not hurt him.- Alexei Nikolaevich, however, coming two operations ...
- I'm not sure, that there will be two. For now, we are talking only about arthroscopy: Zhenya's meniscus is splited, and we will work carefully with the German surgeons. With hernia, we will be dealing after meniscal repair. It is possible that there will be no surgery, but we will treat him with conservative treatment. So I beg you not to escalate the situation: Plushenko's the spine will not be cut up, and the leg will not be cut off. I would be very grateful, if you could write just that.- But you will agree that 5 painkillers injections, which "raised" Zhenya' in the free program at the European Championships in Sheffield, is not associated with the image of a healthy person.
- And how could it be otherwise, if the person, I repeat again, twenty years jumping complex multi-turns jumps? It does not add to his health. In Sheffield, Plushenko looked like a cucumber (), and everybody saw it. Five painkillers injections - it just seems scary. In fact, his performance did not fall under the bar "at the risk of life." We knew exactly, that his meniscus will not be blocked. So I particularly and do not worried.
If I started worrying about what can happen, think about the bad things, it will be passed to Zhenya. If he have the same thoughts, he would inform me. And what would be gained from it? Nothing good. And so - I was calm. And Zhenya was calm.
LOL Seniorita. Your translation had me in stitches. I don't mean to be rude but I find these very very funny. " In Sheffield, Plushenko looked like a cucumber " Can you explain why cucumber? I have heard of 'cool as cucumber' but sick as cucumber? or maybe they mean green as cucumber? I did try to imagine Plushy looking like cucumber.
"Plushenko's the spine will not be cut up, and the leg will not be cut off". Honestly Seniorita, did they say really mean that? That's butchering.
You make my day.
^ I m not offended, but google translation might be offended.
I dont know if the original text says something different. My russian are limited to My name is Seniorita, Where is the metro, I want to eat blinis, etc..
Yes cucumber was funny, I dont know what he meant, Mishin is always speaking metaphorically.
Toni, I hope everything goes well with your dad. It's interesting to realize that two activities have led to great advantages in medicine: war and sports. These days, doctors can do things that look almost like magic. Microsurgery and better diagnostic tools have led to such things as being able to operate on newborns with hearts the size of a walnut, and tissue repair in virtually every part of the body. There are still no guarantees, but some procedures have a better chance of success these days.