03-31-2012, 09:16 PM
Just want to add this is my dream podium
Except I'd probably have Hanyu and Patrick reversed. Sorry I live for my art more than my sport (that's why i have no business being a judge but a fan) and I am sooooo very chuffed for Hanyu and his Romeo and Juliet program with the highest TES score complete with the 3S at the end. I have always express Hanyu has brought a fresh raw edge with utter abandonment to his performance only reckless youth of a sunny and courageous disposition are capable of. Hanyu took this program to a whole other level of authenticity that has whiff of melancholy through out that simply lingers in the silent moments of music that I thought he realized very well. His age being so similar to Romeo in the story surely also helps. Maybe having been through a lot over these past 12 months brought a whole other level to his emotional maturity. I was totally choked up for him in the end to see how utterly spent he was after given out his all, came back fighting through the freak fall during the foot sequence. It is just nice to see his talent and hard work properly rewarded and recogised by the judges finally, and to make it sweeter, totally appreciated by the knowledgeable audience who knows plenty about their 'amour' even before the score got read out. It is undoubtedly the 2012 world championship moment for me to remember fondly.
I thought Patrick was the rightful winner of the competition, but the judges are certainly making it very difficult for fans of his to consistently have to stand up for him in the face of questionable judging. Hanyu and Dai had higher base scores in their program than patrick which they performed with better interpretation, musicality in their choreography, good skating skills as well Dai actually goes out clean. Patrick won purely by PCS this time round with Time violation, and deduction for the falls and even as much I have always appreciate Patrick and his skills, I though Dai and Hanyu deserve better today. Nick and Chris of UK Eurosport complained since the short program and continued to at FS scores and I'd have to agree with them in this case. What would Dai have to do to win over Patrick Chan?
Maybe they should add an extra criteria to award others who are able to perform their program clean as oppose to penalize the mistakes by approximation.
Well done Brian Joubert!! I have no words...except Kuodos. 4th is pretty good but others were just better on the day.
Last edited by os168; 03-31-2012 at 09:31 PM.
03-31-2012, 09:27 PM
Peter Carruthers was the higher voice, lower was Mr. Sunderland who is a dunderhead when it comes to figure skating... Peter spent more time during the pairs portion of the competition correcting Sunderland's incorrect info...
Originally Posted by Becki
Sunderland even said Russia had a skater on every ladies worlds podium since 2005 *facepalm* Terry Gannon is commentating for Golf this weekend which is why he wasn't doing Worlds coverage
03-31-2012, 09:31 PM
Wow this guy does not know his information! Man, he ruined the whole entire performance for me with his lame comments.....
Originally Posted by Tonichelle
Heck, I can even do a better job. That's how sad he is...
03-31-2012, 09:34 PM
Yeah I was really disappointed with Sunderland... I thought Tanith, Peter, and Tara all did well inspite of him.
03-31-2012, 09:49 PM
Skating is art, if you let it be.
I predicted the podium perfectly, yay me.
I'm extremely happy for Hanyu, his medal was deserved.
Takahashi should have won Gold. The way that Patrick Chan is so held up in this sport is gross. His famed skating skills and transitions are only slightly better than Takahashi's and in terms of actually performing and understanding music and moving to it he is well behind. Should have had lower PCS than Takahashi in both phases of this competition and blowing that last jump in his program should have knocked him down to Silver overall and 3rd in the LP.
03-31-2012, 09:57 PM
Figure Skating Fan
True. This is all learning for him, I mean Yuna didn't become a champion without having her set of troubles. I think he has gained tons of experience and this will only help him to get better and better.
Originally Posted by Mrs. P
03-31-2012, 10:55 PM
Figure Skating Fan
Interesting concept! who would play Steve, J-Lo and Randy?
Originally Posted by Medusa
03-31-2012, 11:29 PM
03-31-2012, 11:34 PM
I've watched all the top bunch of LPs again, and no matter how many times I re-watch the programs, I really, really don't understand the PCS difference between Daisuke and Patrick. Can anyone more knowledgeable than I in the ways of CoP please explain the 4+ point difference in PCS between the two? I thought the difference in Performance/Execution was the most egregious. Patrick received a 9.00 while Daisuke had a 8.61. I know you can't compare scoring across different events, but to put this into perspective, Patrick received a 9.04 in PE at 4CC with an infinitely better performance (and 90.16 in total PCS, a mere 0.02 more than the 90.14 at Worlds). Looking at the criteria for PE (clarity of movement, projection, physical, emotional and intellectual involvement, etc), I don't see how ANYONE can justify how Patrick received almost a full half-point more than Daisuke in this category given how they both skated the LP.
I just don't understand.
03-31-2012, 11:59 PM
FYI - Patrick is not the bruno, the nine judges and three tech specialists, all professionally trained, are. The mass doesn't always know the truth, simple as that. I am in a good mood today since Patrick won, so I will let you win this argument. No more words from me. Good night.
Originally Posted by let`s talk
Last edited by Boeing787; 04-01-2012 at 12:01 AM.
04-01-2012, 12:00 AM
I don't understand either, and I don't think I ever will. PCs are a joke....
Originally Posted by evangeline
Patrick didn't skate lights out, he skated SMART (he said this himself). I think a true World Champion is suppose to deliver a compelling performance, much like the one he did last year.
Last edited by Becki; 04-01-2012 at 12:11 AM.
04-01-2012, 12:10 AM
Well, it's not like the judges are always 100% correct either. Remember that professionally-trained judges used to give high 7s and 8s in Transitions to Plushenko despite the fact that he admitted he hardly had any?
Originally Posted by Boeing787
04-01-2012, 12:11 AM
Patrick's performance in 4CC was not that great due to the altitude. If you compare his 4CC performance with his national and GPF performance, you will notice his speed in 4CC was a bit slower. He was visibly tired after the program. Aslo, different judges will have score differently. Let's take this factor into account.
Originally Posted by evangeline
04-01-2012, 12:16 AM
His speed at Worlds wasn't that great - he was rushing by the end because he was considerably behind the music.
I think evangeline is taking it into account. She's just trying to reconcile what the judges scored with what she saw. I am as well.
04-01-2012, 12:20 AM
You can't be certain. Considerably behind the music doesn't necessarily mean lower speed. Just saying.
Originally Posted by ImaginaryPogue