Julia is too new to just be gifted marks the way Chan is. Judges take more than a couple months to instantaneously fall in love with someone to the "I will give them huge marks no matter what" degree. Granted the Russian fed. of old could do the trick, but the Russians politically have no power anymore, even the Canadians have tons more political power and strength than Russian now as the often inflated scores of Chan, sometimes Virtue & Moir, Dube & Davison at times, and even Osmond's highly controversial Skate Canada scores and win proves. Plus she isnt even the Russian fed. favorite I dont think, Sotnikova is, but if Julia L continues producing better scores, performances, results, they will have no choice but to support her as their #1 next season.
No, really - if this thread is just about the ladies, it should say so in the title.
I'm not sure who the best Russian lady is, but I think that if the ladies event in Sochi will be anywhere close to the Vancouver standard, all of them are most likely to medal via the team event. Post-Olympics, things might get more interesting...
For now, Tuktamy, Sotni, and Lipni. But 14 months (until their Oly season nationals) is a long enough time for anything to happen, so I wouldn’t count out Leonova, Makarova or Polina K. They are all young.
I think Liza is the most talented girl. She has good jumping technique, musicality, and mentality.
There is so much talk about Julia Lipnitskaya here. Some say she's amazing, others say she's just getting favoured, some say she will lose her jumps as she grows, others say she has already been growing, which hasn't affected her ability to jump at all, sill others say her fast rotations and abdominal muscles will keep her jumps. I am a little confused as to where she really stands, but here is what I think. She will surely experience growth spurt, not only in height, but also in weight, muscle strength, and in mentality. She will eventually grow into a woman. i don't know if that will be before or after Sochi, and i don't know if that will affect her ability to jump and rotations. It might, and it might not. Growing is so much more complicated than just getting taller, change in the centre of gravity, or rotation speed. Also, figure skating is more than just jumps and spins and steps. It includes artistry, speed on the ice, ice coverage, edge qualities, music etc.
Having said that, I don't think Julia is neither simply a wunderkind bubble that will disappear after nor a fully grown accomplished skater (not yet anyways though she might later eventually). Here are her good qualities that I see: she nails her jumps well with amazing consistency and carries out each element well without missing anything, which has made her the judge's favourite, because the judges have to give points to the skaters who actually do the elements. Her amazing hyper-flexibility and the speed of her spins and other rotations give her extra points, too, and she has her movements. She has good speed on the ice and strong basics, such as skating skills.
But she also has some weak points that she needs to polish before becoming a truly accomplished skater. Her jump qualities may not be so great. Somehow, I noticed that her jumps don't look as solid and strong as some other stronger skaters, and the scale is not very big. These might improve as she gains more muscle strength as she grows older, or they might not, if she becomes heavier. I will need to wait and see. Also, I am not really sure, but I heard some people saying that she takes off on her blades when she does her toe jumps and she also has a slight flutz that has managed to avoid edge calls, although these are not my observation. Lastly, she often skates through music, not all the time, but much of her program. There were moments that I could not feel the music in her skating, and I think it is more than just her young age, because I have seen younger skaters with little artistry yet feel the music more than her. I think it is because of her concentration on athletic part of her skating. This might improve as well as she gains maturity and begins to open her eyes and ears to the music, or she might continue to simply focus on carrying out the elements.
In short, I see a lot of good qualities already in her and lots of potentials as well, but also she needs to work on some of her weaknesses. She is only 14, so anything can happen before the Olympics. I feel that we will need to wait and see before crowning her as the next #1 of Russia or dismissing her as nothing more than a bubble.
Last edited by bluesky85; 10-31-2012 at 01:34 PM. Reason: mistake