Skating is NOT just about jumps, there is a technical and ARTISTIC side, You do not have to have the full repertoire of technique in order to succeed under the COP if your PCS are very good, Lepisto, Korpi and Kostner are very good in this area and should be REWARDED as such.
I do not like seeing someone go from one jump to the next without choreographic content, good use of the music and artistry.
And you make it sound like there is only "either - or". Also, I frankly don't think your last sentence describes Liza at all.
And, also frankly, I have yet to see a single person - ever - and I mean EVER - say that it was ALL about the jumps. One day I would like to meet - even if only virtually - this mythical person people keep replying to...