Page 4 of 5 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 LastLast
Results 46 to 60 of 63

Thread: Worlds best guesses for podiums?

  1. #46
    she takes the audience on her journey of emotions Layfan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Mexico City
    Posts
    3,637
    For the ladies, I say the momentum is on Mao's side. I'm going to go with her. I just love her LP this year, it's exquisite and the music maybe an old warhorse but there is also no other lady skater right now who could do it justice like Mao can.

    It's looking hard for Ashley to make the podium. I'm guessing Yuna and Carolina will share the podium with Mao but there are also the Russian ladies. One thing for sure is that it's going to be a real competition. Yay!

    I really have been struggling to keep up this season so I have to watch the men. I wouldn't have predicted that Chan would be as vulnerable as he is! I'm still going with him for gold though. For now...

  2. #47
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    560
    Quote Originally Posted by Layfan View Post
    For the ladies, I say the momentum is on Mao's side. I'm going to go with her. I just love her LP this year, it's exquisite and the music maybe an old warhorse but there is also no other lady skater right now who could do it justice like Mao can.
    I think Mao has a high chance of winning if she skates clean(both SP and FS), but that's unlikely to happen. When was a last time that Mao skated a clean SP&FS with 1~2 3As and 3F+3Lo(no downgrades or URs)?
    Of course, Mao can definitely win with a SP&FS exactly like 4CC(though I'd expect her total score to be slightly lower) over Yuna with few(more than 3) major mistakes

  3. #48
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    111
    My predications:

    Ice Dance:

    1. Virtue/Moir (the superior team by far but will they be rewarded for the extreme difficulty & innovation of their modern dance Carmen program?)
    2. Davis/White (will probably win because their FS is clean & precise – but predictable & one dimensional)
    3. Pechalat/Bourzat (twighlight days for this senior team)

    Bobrova/Soloviev and Ilynikh/Katsalapov could possibly beat P/B; they have less technical difficulty altho better expression & connection)


    Men: (wide open with such depth)
    1. Chan
    2. Fernandez
    3. Hanyu

    But with a number of talented guys right there to swoop onto the podium if anyone falters.

    Ladies: (also somewhat wide open with depth)
    1. Kostner
    2. Wagner
    3. Kim

    But in the hunt are Asada, Suzuki, Korpi,Osmond, Gold and the Russians. Whoever brings it on the day.

    Pairs:

    1. Volosozhar/Trankov
    2. Savchenko/Szolkowy (or the other way around – both amazing)
    3. Duhamel/Radford

  4. #49
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    560
    Quote Originally Posted by Cherryy View Post
    My wish list:
    I know I'm crazy. I saw almost all the people consider Kim, Mao and Carolina to go head to head but it would be so boring. After taking into consideration that ice is slippery only 2 things would still never happen and that is Kim finishing behind Zijun and Kostner dropping to 11th. Also if you look at my wish list it gives Russia, Japan, and USA 3 spots for the Olypics. I doubt South Korea and Italy need those 3 spots. China (with Kexin), Italy (with Marchei) and South Korea would all get 2. I really like my wish list
    I also agree that South Korea and Italy won't really need 3 spots for the Olympic games I think Yuna said she wants 3 spots so she can compete at Sochi with other young skaters from South Korea, but still, I don't think they'll be Top.15 skaters by Sochi 2014. On the other hand, it would be really unfair to see that skaters like Mirai, Agnes and Christina who all have potential to be in Top.15 won't be at Sochi 2014 just because, for example, US only has 2 spots for Sochi 2014. Considering that, I'd put my list like this:
    1.Mao Asada
    2.Ashley Wagner
    3.Yuna Kim
    4.Akiko Suzuki
    5.Adelina Sotnikova:I just prefer Adelina over Liza because she's an all-around skater(though Liza is definitely much better at jumps, since Liza doesn't flutz)
    6.Elizaveta Tuktamysheva
    7.Gracie Gold
    8.Carolina Kostner
    9.Kaetlyn Osmond
    10.Kanako Murakami

    Which is very unlikely to happen And this isn't my wish list, as I hope Yuna wins gold medal at Worlds

    I think it's unfair that ISU doesn't give 3 spots to the country that really needs them(for example, US, Russia and Japan), but give 3 spots away to country that gold and silver medalists represent(if they're the only one from their country competing at Worlds). But rules are rules...

  5. #50
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Russia
    Posts
    731
    Can somebody tell me what places should the Russian girls get to have 3 spots for Sochi? Will 4+5 or 5+6 be enough? That is my only wish. It's not fair if there'll be just 2 our girls in Sochi, especially given that in 2018 many of our talents won't get the chance to be in the Russian Olympic team

  6. #51
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    242
    Guessing that:
    1. Mao Asada
    2. Yuna Kim
    3. Carolina Kostner
    4. Adelina Sotnikova
    5. Ashley Wagner

  7. #52
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    560
    Quote Originally Posted by koatcue View Post
    Can somebody tell me what places should the Russian girls get to have 3 spots for Sochi? Will 4+5 or 5+6 be enough? That is my only wish. It's not fair if there'll be just 2 our girls in Sochi, especially given that in 2018 many of our talents won't get the chance to be in the Russian Olympic team
    Yes, it'll be enough I don't think Liza or Adelina can place 4th, though, unless Ashley or Akiko has few mistakes and Adelina or Liza skate without major mistakes. I think 6+7 or 5+8 is possible
    Last edited by vera01; 02-15-2013 at 05:34 AM.

  8. #53
    Forever stuck on those steps Li'Kitsu's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    938
    Ladies:

    If you think about how the last two worlds looked a little pale, this year is so amazing again! So many lovely ladies that I want to do well, it's really exciting. So for the predictions...

    1.) Yuna Kim
    She's the most likely to deliver clean or at least close to clean.
    2.) Mao Asada
    I don't think it would need Yuna to do several major mistakes for 4CC-Mao to overtake her. Her planned BV is over 12points higher than Yunas planned one, and even 4CC-BV tops Yunas with about 3 points. Yes, Yuna can make that difference up with +GOE, but then there's the question again how likely Yuna is to be completly clean in both SP and FS. With Mao's insane content I'm not even trying to believe she'll go clean, but 4CC + 3S instead of 2S should already give her pretty good chances to win.
    3.) Carolina Kostner
    Last season, she kept getting better and better with every competition, but this year, she skipped the grand prix. That's why I don't think she'll be mistakes-free here. If everyone is clean, Caro should win in PCS, and she has 7 triples planned in the FS. She might aswell win it, I just feel she might be the biggest question mark of the three.
    4.) Akiko Suzuki
    Simply because she rocks
    5.) Adelina Sotnikova
    This is probably a little optimistic... anyway, Adelina looked very determined to me at Euro's. I just don't want to believe it was a fluke. If she manages to skate like that again, 5th isn't out of reach for her at all.
    6.) Elizaveta Tuktamysheva
    Same as Adelina - althogh she's more likely to skate good, her PCS are really holding her down,
    7.) Ashley Wagner
    Yes, just in 7th. The major plus Ashley had at the GP was fight + making nearly no mistakes. But without a 3-3 nor even a 2A-3T she really is dependant on that. Since nats last year she had the momentum going for her, but I think her last two showings ended that streak somehow. I'm not too sure she can show off the same kind of confidence she had at the beginning of the season, or that even clean skates will give her the same marks as before (getting 66+ is probably not as likely with Yuna, Caro and a better Mao around).
    8.) Kanako Murakami
    I might even have her higher, if not for those UR's...
    9.) Kaetlyn Osmond
    Tough call here. She did good enough at 4CC for a newcomer in my opinion, and I still think she'll be a star in the future. For now, top10 is definitly doable. But she's hard to rank for me at this point.
    10.) Zijun Li
    I'd like to see her placing higher, but with her PCS that seems unlikely. Would still be a nice debut

    Other possiblities: Gracie Gold and Elene Gedevanishvili. Both can score very well, both are prone to make mistakes. Hard to predict. (Though I really, really hope Elene comes roaring back after Euro's!)


    Men:

    Funny, despite the men being really strong this year, I'm more excited for the ladies... oh well

    1.) Javier Fernandez
    Would be fun. Has the best LP this season, had great skates at GPF and Euros and looks likely to continue like that. I think he'd be a nice world champion.
    2.) Daisuke Takahashi
    Okay, maybe a liiiiiittle bit of hope thrown in here. So what. Daisuke has his ups and downs quite often, but he more often than not delivers when it counts. And he needs to win in Sochi for my little fan-heart to be happy, so making the podium here will be a good starting point.
    3.) Yuzuru Hanyu
    He might even win, but the 4S is giving him a lot of trouble. If he delivers in the SP, he will very likely win that segment, but he's a little bit of a wild card in the LP.
    4.) Patrick Chan
    That was a very tough decision. It would be so weird to see Patrick off the podium, but maybe that way he will get a technical coach again. Though I'd like him to stay with Buttle, Nichol/Chan was getting old...
    5.) Florent Amodio
    Not too sure why myself. He did great at Euros, gets the Morozov-PCS and... because Euros was much better than 4CC this year (stupid argument, I know).
    6.) Brian Joubert
    Because you can never count him out!
    7.) Ross Miner
    I'm not a fan, but I think he'll recover from 4CC and is a way better combination between TES and PCS than most of the guys that are still to come.
    8.) Kevin Reynolds
    Probably not the most popular vote after 4CC. But all of his jumps are looking tight, and it seems like a tougher panel might slaughter his TES. I do like him and I'd be happy for him if he places better, but this field is really good and since it's his quads, and mainly those, that keep him competitive, I'm still a little cautious.
    9.) Michal Brezina
    Woah, now I've suprised myself. He can easily do so much better than that, but since he never skates even close to clean, I think a strong field like this might really leave him behind.
    10.) Takahito Mura
    Maybe I'm weird, but I think Mura is quite underscored in PCS. He's not the most artistic skater, but his SS are really good, his choreography is decent and he has a good feel for the music. But as things are, he probably doesn't have good chances to place that much better than this.

    Other possibilities: Nan Song and Maxim Kovtun. I'd want both to make the top 10, to give their countries two spots for Sochi.
    And there's Max Aaron, I know... saw him for the first time at 4CC. His jumps are nice, but I'm not that impressed. If you depend on your jumps and really just that, even small mistakes might leave you behind very far against some guys with good SS and actual choreo. And I'm not too sure how he'll handle that pressure.
    Last edited by Li'Kitsu; 02-15-2013 at 07:42 AM.

  9. #54
    Mashimaro on Ice
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    1,419
    Quote Originally Posted by vera01 View Post
    I think Mao has a high chance of winning if she skates clean(both SP and FS), but that's unlikely to happen. When was a last time that Mao skated a clean SP&FS with 1~2 3As and 3F+3Lo(no downgrades or URs)?
    Of course, Mao can definitely win with a SP&FS exactly like 4CC(though I'd expect her total score to be slightly lower) over Yuna with few(more than 3) major mistakes
    Her PCS at 4CC in the LP was only slightly higher than the one in GPF, so I don't think her score would change that much at Worlds. I even think it might be higher cause scores tend to go up at Worlds if skaters deliver. More than 3 is not considered few. I think Yuna can't afford that many mistakes at Worlds this year.

  10. #55
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    560
    Quote Originally Posted by miki88 View Post
    Her PCS at 4CC in the LP was only slightly higher than the one in GPF, so I don't think her score would change that much at Worlds. I even think it might be higher cause scores tend to go up at Worlds if skaters deliver. More than 3 is not considered few. I think Yuna can't afford that many mistakes at Worlds this year.
    Well.. I just remembered that Yuna made 3 mistakes at 2011 Worlds, and won silver there. Judges aren't going to give away gold medal to a skater who makes three mistakes.

    You're right. Skater(Carolina, Mao, or Yuna) that delivers the cleanest(or a program that looks like a clean program, which means, no falls, one or two UR but no downgrades, and 1~2 flutz or lip) program would win gold medal. Yuna is by far the most consistent skater, but Mao and Carolina can definitely deliver clean program, too. Even South Korea Nationals Yuna(even with an almost clean FS) might not be winning gold medal because of her mistakes at SP.

    Yuna should be skating in group 2 or 3 at Worlds. I'm curious to see if that'll affect her score..

  11. #56
    Long live the Queen! YunaBliss's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Posts
    444
    Quote Originally Posted by vera01 View Post

    Yuna should be skating in group 2 or 3 at Worlds. I'm curious to see if that'll affect her score..
    ooh~ why is that? If that is the case for her SP, then I think it will actually be better for Yuna to skate early. Yuna seems to feel less pressure when she goes early.

  12. #57
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    674
    Quote Originally Posted by YunaBliss View Post
    ooh~ why is that? If that is the case for her SP, then I think it will actually be better for Yuna to skate early. Yuna seems to feel less pressure when she goes early.
    I don't think skating in earlier group will not affect Kim score. Only Mao and Kim had cracked the 70+ mark so far, and you can bet if Caro goes clean, she will join them too. Question is will Caro go with harder content 3F+3T and 3Lz or easier 3T+3T and 3Lo???

    Adelina and Liza can get close to 68-69 range if they goes clean, but chances are judges will hold them down around 66-67 range. Same goes for Suzuki, thou she was still under score for her super SP at 4CC in PCS wise. Ashley can get around 65 range too, but at this point still question mark bc of her injury, which we will know in practice sessions.

  13. #58
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    674
    Regarding Yuna winning base on her GOE, I think the format had changed and it hurt her the most since she used to get crazy +2 +3 like a free pop corns in theater. Now she can only get higher GOE wise on her 3+3, the cushion she will get will be like 50% of what she used to have.

    But def ladies is more wide open field than men.

    For men, i bet only Chan, Fernandez and Hanyu will be on podium. Takahashi is big question mark after 4CC!

  14. #59
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    5,609
    At the beginning of the season, if you had asked me would I be more comfortable predicting Fernandez on the podium than I would predicting Hanyu/Chan/Takahashi (aka, the three medalists from last year's worlds), I might have thought you were nuts. But the way he's been skating is exceptional, and he's really peaking very well this year (something he didn't do so well last season).

  15. #60
    Adiós Melon's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Posts
    405
    Quote Originally Posted by wonderlen3000 View Post
    Regarding Yuna winning base on her GOE, I think the format had changed and it hurt her the most since she used to get crazy +2 +3 like a free pop corns in theater. Now she can only get higher GOE wise on her 3+3, the cushion she will get will be like 50% of what she used to have.

    But def ladies is more wide open field than men.

    For men, i bet only Chan, Fernandez and Hanyu will be on podium. Takahashi is big question mark after 4CC!
    You sound as if Yuna doesn't deserve those GOEs. As far as I'm concerned, her program earned that GOE with her ice coverage, flow, techniques, audience connections etc.
    But I do agree that GOE range has changed (except 3A, which I don't understand) and it'll be harder for her to earn those deserving GOEs.

    My guess is
    1) Mao
    2) Yuna
    3) ???

    I put Mao 1st because of her BV, if she delivers a clean program, there's noway Yuna can beat her. However, with UR and edge calls from the judges, Mao may not be able to win gold. But then again, there's that 70% rule............ very iffy to say who'll win gold.
    3rd, I honestly do not care who gets it.

Page 4 of 5 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •