Results 1 to 15 of 15

Thread: 2013 Junior World Figure Skating Championships: Ladies Short Reports

  1. #1
    ISU, stop promoting 2-foot skating!
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Axis of Evil
    Posts
    2,516

    2013 Junior World Figure Skating Championships: Ladies Short Reports

    2013 Junior World Figure Skating Championships
    Ladies – Short Program

    Detailed Classification
    Judges Scores


    Disclaimer: The GOE values listed next to the elements are the ones, I'd award if I was a judge, to give you a general impression of how well it was executed. I try to describe each of the elements but there's not always time to be as detailed as I would like and those numbers can sometimes say a thousand words. So if you see positive GOE, it means an element was executed to a high standard (and yes, I am generally being very nitpicky ).

    Any questions, comments, criticisms and discussion are very welcome.

    A general rant: An annoying judging trend that I've noticed is that biellmanns seem to result in very high GOE regardless of how they are actually executed. Which encourages ugly, slow and unextended biellmanns. Thanks, judges!

    26. Nicole RAJICOVA /SVK/
    Malaguena by Ernesto Lecuona

    2lutz/2toe [0]
    3flip – break after steps [-1]
    scratch butterflies to flying camel sideways twist coe(weak position, off-centred) to upward catch [-1]
    sideways to layback catch – off-centred at the start, lacking extension [-1]
    straight line step sequence [0]
    popped axel – landed forward after one revolution [no value]
    camel/sit var/change up butt out/sit broken leg/up – quite good positions, good rotation speed [1]

    Quite smooth edges and decent basic skating in general but her posture and lines could be stronger. The program lacked Latin character. You could have played any music over that performance, really.

    27. HONGO Rika /JPN/
    Samson and Delilah by Camille Saint-Saens

    3toe/3toe(cheated over a quarter, not a lot of flow out) [-1]
    3flip – solid but a very short break after steps [0]
    flying camel coe to upward twist to donut to upward twist – could use a little more speed [0]
    sideways to layback to catch to biellmann – extension a little weak [0]
    straight line step sequence [0]
    2axel – solid [1]
    camel to illusion/change sit cannonball to pancake/up – good rotation speed [1]

    A good job on the elements but whilst everything was clean, her elements weren't of an a very high quality (hence I would go with mostly base GOE values).

    The choreography was quite generic and her movements lacked conviction. She didn't project strong enough to the judges and the audience.

    'This concludes your warm-up, would you please clear the ice NOW' said the announcer after the following warm-up group came to a close. :D

    28. Yasmin SIRAJ /USA/
    Daphnis and Chloe by Maurice Ravel

    3toe/3toe – not a lot of height, slightly tilted in the air, not a lot of flow out of the second jump which was cheated over a quarter [-2] (a nice spiral coming out of it though)
    3lip – underrotated over a quarter, fall [-3]
    ina bauer towards layback to sideways to catch to biellmann [1] – quite good rotation speed
    circular step sequence – could use more flow [0]
    flying camel upward twist to catch coe to donut [1]
    steps to 2axel – solid [1]
    scratch butterflies to camel to illusion/change sit cannonball to pancake/up – good flow and rotation speed [1]

    The program was packed with transitions throughout. Her upper body was very stiff however and there was a jarring contrast between her quite soft arm movements, which reflect the Swan theme quite well, and her head and back which hardly moved at all (whilst the music was Daphnis and Chloe, the concept of this program is her being a swan). Her basic skating isn't very strong either.

    29. Alaine CHARTRAND /CAN/
    First Dance by Edvin Marton

    3lutz/3toe(weak landing, cheated just over a quarter, turnout, foot down quick) [-2]
    3lip – high with secure landing but a slight outside edge on the take-off [0]
    transition to camel/sit/up Y/change sit broken leg to forward tuck – quite good rotation speed [1]
    2axel [-3] – fall, was a little tentative going in and you could predict this was going to happen
    scratch butterfly to flying camel to donut to upward catch(extension a little weak) [0]
    circular step sequence [0] – could use more flow, the upper body movement was very over the top and didn't seem to fit the music well
    to sideways to layback to catch – could use more extension but very good rotation speed [1]

    The program lacked character. Generic GFB choreography with her arms moving up and down, independently of the rest of her body, without much of a purpose and not really fitting the gentle, longato character of the music very well.

    30. Reyna HAMUI /MEX/
    Carol Ann by Michael W. Smith

    3loop – underrotated just over a quarter, fall [-3]
    2flip with arms above – straight off footwork with no preparation [2]
    flying camel coe to upward catch to donut – quite slow, extensions a little weak [-1]
    Y spiral towards 2axel [0]
    camel/up Y/change sit broken leg to forward bend/up [0]
    straight line step sequence [0]
    sideways to layback catch to biellmann – quite good flow and rotation speed [1]

    This was well skated for her ability. Her basics aren't very strong - posture is a little weak and she didn't have a lot of speed - but she presented the program quite well throughout, making effort on all of her movements.

    31. Laurine LECAVALIER /FRA/
    Sing, Sing, Sing by Benny Goodman

    3lutz/2toe [0] – not a lot of speed or flow out but decent height and secure landings
    3lip – solid, short break after steps though and outside edge on take-off [-1]
    flying camel to coe to donut to upward catch(good extension) [1]
    2axel [-1] – slightly shaky landing, a little over the toe, set-up was quite long
    camel to upward twist/up/change sit broken leg to side twist [0]
    straight line step sequence – good expression [1]
    sideways to layback catch to biellmann(a little slow) [1] - very good rotation speed until the biellmann

    She was a little cautious at the start but once she has landed both of the triples, she really relaxed and showed some very good expression and attack. Good posture and lines, she extended her arm movements beautifully. She needs to learn to point her toes, though.

    The program didn't have a lot of transitions.

    32. Gabrielle DALEMAN /CAN/
    Avatar (soundtrack) by James Horner

    3toe(really off-axis in the air)/turn/3toe(underrotated over a quarter, step out, hand down) [-3]
    3lip [0] – high and solid and straight off steps but outside edge on take-off
    scratch butterflies to flying camel coe to donut to upward catch [0]
    biellmann spiral towards 2axel [0]
    circular step sequence [0]
    sideways to layback catch to biellmann [1] – decent positions and rotation speed
    ina bauer towards camel/cannonball/change sit broken leg/up butt out [1] – quite good positions and flow

    Decent choreography featuring various MITF throughout. She maintained quite good speed and her movements were sharp and confident.

    She was in tears in the Kiss & Cry with Berezintsev maintaining his usual high spirits and telling her to smile. He always has a good, positive attitude which is very important in situations like this.

    33. Anna POGORILAYA /RUS/
    Songs from the Victorious City by Anne Dudley

    3lutz/3toe [0] – both jumps a tiny bit shaky and not a lot of speed or flow out
    3lip [-2] – break after steps, outside edge on take-off, landing could have been a little stronger
    2axel [0] – landing a little awkward
    scratch butterflies to flying camel(needed a hop to maintained balance and travelled slightly) to donut to upward catch(good extension) [-1]
    layback to catch(very fast!) to biellmann – good extension [2]
    straight line step sequence [0]
    camel to illusion/change up butt out/sit holding foot/up – good rotation speed [1]

    She looked tense throughout, her movement was a little catious and she didn't project very well. Generic choreography consisting of “Walk Like An Egyptian” arms.

    She had Lv3 bitchface after seeing her scores. The coach didn't seem very impressed either.

    34. Gerli LIINAMฤE /EST/
    Palladio by Carl Jenkins performed by Escala

    steps towards 3loop/2toe – not a lot of flow out [0]
    2flip [1] – straight off steps, good height and a solid landing
    flying camel to donut coe to upward catch [0]
    back catch spiral towards 1axel [-3]
    camel to illusion/change sit cannonball to pancake/up – decent positions and rotation speed [1]
    layback to sideways(a little off-centred) to catch to biellmann(barely held one revolution) [-1]
    straight line step sequence [0] – could use more speed and attack

    A fair amount of connecting elements in the program. The choreography could have been quite effective if she sold it well (the music had a strong rhythm and a lot of accents) but her movements lacked attack and confidence.

    35. Patricia GLESCIC /SLO/
    Crystallized

    3loop(cheated over a quarter)/2toe [0] – solid landings (would be +1 if not for the cheat)
    3flip [-3] – cheated over a quarter, poor speed out, foot down quick
    flying camel to upward catch coe to donut – slow [-1]
    layback to sideways to layback catch to biellmann [-1] – slow, extensions not very good
    2axel [0]
    circular step sequence [1] – quite fast footwork, a lot of freedom in her movement
    camel to illusion/up/jump to change sit broken leg(slow)/up [-1]

    Slow. Sluggish upper body movement and hardly any connection to the music. Weak spins. Great job landing everything but the quality just wasn't there, I'm afraid.

    She was very happy after her performance and looked really shocked when the scores came up.

    When I saw her ISU bio for the first time, I thought she was going to skate to The xx's “Crystallised” but she didn't. :(

    36. Elena RADIONOVA /RUS/
    The Fifth Element (soundtrack) by Eric Serra

    3lutz(cheated over a quarter)/3toe(very strong) [0]
    2lip [-3] – opened up after a little over two revolutions and fell
    back spiral to 2axel [0]
    layback to catch to hyper-extended biellmann – fantastic positions, very good rotation speed [2]
    camel/up Y/change up butt out/sit forward tuck – good positions and rotation speed [1]
    straight line step sequence – sharp footwork, a lot of upper body movement [1]
    to scratch butterfly to flying camel upward catch coe to donut – good positions [1]

    Strong basics. Beautiful posture and lines, great flexibility. Smooth edges. She reflected the music quite well, both in the slower and the upbeat part.

    There's star quality here and I pray she will be given good programs in the seasons to come because bad music choices and generic choreography managed to very successfully drained life from Lipnitskaia, who was also a great performer before she entered the international scene.

    Jesus Christ, Inna Goncharenko's haircut is as bad as it gets.

    37. Nathalie WEINZIERL /GER/
    Exodus performed by Maksim Mrvica

    3lip [-3] – gap after steps, take-off off an outside edge, turnout on the landing
    3lutz/2toe [0] – clean but a long set-up and not a lot of speed out
    layback to sideways to catch to biellmann [1] – extension quite weak, good rotation speed though
    scratch butterfly to flying camel to coe to donut to upward catch [0] – rotation speed and positions not bad but it took her quite a while to change some of the positions
    2axel [-1] – tentative, deliberate set-up, landing a little scratchy
    circular step sequence [0]
    camel/sit cannonball/change sit broken leg/up var to up – quite good flow and rotation speed [1]

    Decent speed but her upper body was quite stiff and she didn't interpret the music very well.

    38. Julia LIPNITSKAIA /RUS/
    Sabre Dance (modern arrangement) by Aram Khatchaturian

    3lutz(landing not perfect)/1toe [-3]
    full split spiral to steps to 3lip [-1] – slight outside edge on take-off
    2axel [0]
    scratch butterflies to flying camel to donut to coe to upward catch – good positions and rotation speed [1]
    straight line step sequence – busy upper body movement but footwork a little scratchy [0]
    layback to sideways to catch to hyper-extended biellmann – very good extension, quite good rotation speed [2]
    camel/up cannonball/sit var/change sit var/up Y(full split) – well extended positions, good rotation speed [2]

    Decent basic skating but she didn't present the program very well. She needs to look up to the judges and the audience and show more attack and conviction in her movements.

    She's extremely, uniquely flexible and there are a lot of kicks, spirals and splits in her program but what is their purpose? They aren't done to highlights in the music, they don't really reflect its character either and they don't really fit within the program as a whole. It's showing off for the sake of it.

    It makes me sad because I remember her Kung Fu Panda program from back when she was 12. It was fun, playful and there was a joy and an exuberance to her skating. But in the last two seasons it looked like her team tried to make her look 'mature' by giving her dreary, overused sad music which she doesn't seem to feel at all and her choroegraphy couldn't be any more generic. She has incredible talent but I don't think that she is being packaged well.

    She had a look of utter horror upon seeing the scores. She looked possessed by the devil.

    39. Courtney HICKS /USA/
    Korobushka by Bond

    3lutz/3toe(cheated over 1/2) [-2]
    layback to sideways to catch to biellmann [1] – decent positions (although could use some more flexibility in her back) and rotation speed
    flying camel(poor free leg extension, it was slightly bent in the knee) to coe to donut to upward catch [1] – good rotation speed
    3flip [-1] – overrotated but good height and a good entry right off preceding footwork, with no obvious preparation
    to footwork to 2axel [1]
    straight line step sequence – quite fast footwork, good energy [1]
    camel to catch/sit var/change sit var to pancake/up – good rotation speed [1]

    Heavy, lumbering, movement. Her arms weren't extended and she didn't point her toes. Is she doing ballet classes? Because she really should.

    Having said that, she has shown quite good energy throughout and her perky movement reflected the upbeat, playful character of the music quite well.

    It was impressive how well the flip and the axel were integrated into the program with connecting footwork.

    40. Brooklee HAN /AUS/
    Freedom by Michael Smith
    Titanic Symphony by Richard Clayderman

    3toe/2toe [0]
    2lip [-1] – decent height and secure landing but take-off off an outside edge
    flying camel to donut(very good extension) to upward catch coe – quite good positions and rotation speed [1]
    owen spiral to 2axel [0] – could use more flow out
    sideways to layback to speed increase catch to biellmann [2] – good extension and rotation speed
    circular step sequence – quite good flow and busy upper body movement [1]
    camel/sit pancake/change sit var/up butt out/sit forward tuck – good positions and rotation speed [1]

    A polished, confident performance, where everything looked neat and secure, despite the mistake on the flip. She knows how to use her arms but her back is stiff. Her basics are not as strong as those of the top skaters but she did give it her best this afternoon.

    41. MIYAHARA Satoko /JPN/
    The Swan by Camille Saint-Saens

    3flutz/3toe [-2] – poor height and both jumps were cheated over a quarter, but the landings were soft and solid
    3flip [0] – again: lacking height and cheated over a quarter but soft and secure landing
    flying camel upward twist to donut to upward catch [0] – could use a little more speed
    straight line step sequence – quite good flow [1]
    2axel [0]
    camel/jump to sit side twist/change sit var/up Y [1] – rotated in both directions! decent positions and rotation speed
    layback to sideways to catch to biellmann [1] – decent positions and rotation speed

    Soft kneebend, gentle and elegant upper body movement which reflected the languid character of the music very well. She definitely moved like a swan. The whole package was there and everything was executed to a high standard.

    42. ZHAO Ziquan /CHN/
    Moonlight Sonata performed by Henry Mancini

    3toe/3toe(underroatted over 1/2, step out) [-3]
    3lip [-3] – outside edge on take-off, cheated over a quarter, heavy step-out
    camel/up Y/change sit cannonball/up var [0]
    2axel – solid, nice extension on the landing [1]
    scratch butterflies to flying camel coe to upward catch to donut [0] – decent positions but could use more speed
    straight line step sequence [0] – very busy upper body movement but could use more speed and flow
    layback to sideways to catch to biellmann [1] – very good extension, could use a little more speed though

    Poor posture and lines, quite stiff back, generic choreography. The were a lot of arm movements throughout but they weren't extended well.

    The Spanish arrangement of the Moonlight Sonata that she used for the second half of the program was probably the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard.

    43. Samantha CESARIO /USA/
    Carmen Fantasie by David Garrett

    3flip [1] - solid, good flow out, a very short break after steps though
    2axel [1] – secure landing with a nice extension of the free leg, set-up quite short
    layback to sideways to layback catch to biellmann [1] – quite good positions and flow throughout, lovely arms on the layback at the start
    flying camel coe to upward twist to upward catch [0] – extensions a little weak
    3loop(cheated over a quarter)/2toe [-1]
    straight line step sequence [2] - great expression, skated to the music well, quite good flow
    camel to illusion/sit broken leg/change sit cannonball/up Y [0]

    Sophisticated, mature presentation. She used her whole body to interpret the music throughout, even the facial expressions were appropriate and added to the effect. The upper body movement was quite busy and it was all in character of the music. The program flowed over the ice well too. She had the whole package and deserved the highest PCS so far.

    Samantha, honey, I love you but that new hair colour is way too dark and doesn't suit your complexion.

    44. PARK So Youn /KOR/
    Pantoum for Piano by Maurice Ravel

    3salchow/2toe [1] – light and secure, good flow out of both jumps
    3flip [-1] – cheated over a quarter
    flying camel upward twist to upward catch coe [0]
    2axel – solid [1]
    sideways to layback to catch(didn't manage to hold it) – off-centred [-1]
    straight line step sequence [0]
    camel/up var to Y/change sit cannonball to pancake [0] – could use some more speed

    Nice posture and lines. She was elegant and skated to the music quite well.

    As she was about to start her program, the music failed and she had to leave the ice while it was being sorted. It took so long that Park and Kim needed another warm-up. After the ice fail of the previous day, this is another example for why major events of any kind should not be held in Italy where nothing ever works.

    45. KIM Hae Jin /KOR/
    La Boheme

    3flutz(cheated over a quarter)/2toe [-2] – not a lot of flow out
    steps to flying camel to upward catch coe to donut [1] – quite good positions and rotation speed
    sideways to layback to catch to biellmann [1]
    3flip [-2] – solid but a long break after steps
    2axel [0]
    straight line step sequence [1] – good use of upper body, decent speed and flow
    camel to upward twist/up var/change sit broken leg to forward tuck [0]

    A well chorographed program, featuring a lot of upper body movement and a fair amount of transitions as well. Good use of her whole body throughout. Nice use of arms.
    Last edited by Ziggy; 03-01-2013 at 07:29 PM.

  2. #2
    Wicked Yankee Girl dorispulaski's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Staring at the ocean and smiling.
    Posts
    15,252
    Ziggy, I had to laugh at this bit that you wrote about Yasmin Siraj:



    The program was packed with transitions throughout. Her upper body was very stiff however and there was a jarring contrast between her quite soft arm movements, which reflect the Swan theme quite well, and her head and back which hardly moved at all. Her basic skating isn't very strong either.
    because Siraj is skating to Ravel's Daphnis & Chloe, but I swore while watching it that she must have had a Swan SP at some point and kept the choreography but ditched the music.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daphnis_and_Chloe

    Daphnis & Chloe is a 2nd century BC telenovela about two young lovers who have many adventures before getting married and living Happily.Ever.After.

  3. #3
    Outdated Old Dinosaur
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    907
    "She had Lv3 bitchface after seeing her scores."

    LOL! You really should replace Scott Hamilton as a television commentator.

    "She NAILS it!" --> Scott's commentary whenever anyone manages not to fall during a jump. Regardless of quality.

    Your analysis was much more honest and refreshing.

  4. #4
    ISU, stop promoting 2-foot skating!
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Axis of Evil
    Posts
    2,516
    Quote Originally Posted by dorispulaski View Post
    Siraj is skating to Ravel's Daphnis & Chloe, but I swore while watching it that she must have had a Swan SP at some point and kept the choreography but ditched the music.
    She is skating to Daphnis&Chloe, yes. But she has said in an interview (it was an Ice Network article IIRC) that the concept of this program is her being a swan. I edited that info in now.

    Quote Originally Posted by TontoK View Post
    "She NAILS it!" --> Scott's commentary whenever anyone manages not to fall during a jump. Regardless of quality.

    Your analysis was much more honest and refreshing.
    Most commentators seem to do that and it's really annoying. It's not that I actually like to dish out put downs to skaters who work really hard, but if mistakes happen they should be called. And correspondingly if skaters show real quality, that should be praised because it doesn't happen often.

    And thank you. I was worried I was being a little too bitchy at times.

  5. #5
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    423
    Ziggy,

    Thank you for taking the time to do this. I don't mind the music so much, but I do with the Russian women in particular would do away with the Garish unitards.

  6. #6
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Posts
    1,754
    Going into Ladies Free skate Saturday night, my wish is that all girls skate lights out. And my tiny wish (of ill-natured part inside of me) is either 1) somehow all 5 top finishers from SP are to score MAGICALLY tied all both in TES and PCS, so that none of us can't get bitchy/too harsh and just appreciate these skaters and its performances, or, 2) Rika and Gabrielle, who have to skate in the 3rd group btw, steal the show with their explosive jumps, take the gold and silver and let everyone at the end of the day!

    PS: My apology for OT, but after seeing such fast-forwarding Ladies SP thread , I would rather want to leave my tiny wish to the skating god in this fabulous Ziggy's review. Ziggy rocks!

  7. #7
    ISU, stop promoting 2-foot skating!
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Axis of Evil
    Posts
    2,516
    Thank you!

    And yes, I also hope that there's less bombing and botched jumps in the FS.

  8. #8
    Medalist
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    90
    From Ziggy:

    "She had Lv3 bitchface after seeing her scores." (not at Pogorilaya but at your description) Great reviews!

  9. #9
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Posts
    1,922
    The only remark you made which could, perhaps, be labelled "bitchy" was the remark about the skater's hair color. Trouble with Scott is, often when he says a skater "nailed it", it turns out they really didn't. I wish whomever he has a contract with would not renew it when it lapses. It's not like he needs the money.

  10. #10
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    157
    Loved the reviews, thanks!

  11. #11
    Medalist
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    82
    I quite like Chartrand. She has wonderful spring to her jumps and solid, fast spins. There is an elegance to her skating but she needs programs with more character. She is a huge contender for the second spot for Sochi if Osmond can earn it at Worlds.

    I am interested to see how the Korean girls are doing. If Yuna Kim could earn 3 spots at Worlds by placing in the top 2, 2 more girls will accompany her to Sochi. It's important for Kim and Park to skate well here not only for world ranking and seasons best scores, they need to make sure they can make the minimum scores for Sochi. Naturally, with a 3toe3toe, solid lutz and flip, great spins and a win at a JGP this season, the young Kim is a huge contender for a Korean spot for Sochi. (Was Park's short program broadcasted at all?)

    It's a shame Siraj was sent at all. She didn't earn her spot with her performances at Nationals. This is a classic example of lenient caller at Nationals vs strict caller at international event. I doubt Wang would have placed much higher after the short given her history, but at least she would usually skate a very solid free to catch up. As much as I dislike Miller's jumps, she would probably have made the top 6 after the short, especially given this weak field.

    Hicks has wonderful spins but everything else is quite hideous. How did Nicks ever let her get by with those clunky feet?

    Miyahara has so much to work on if she wants to be a top Japanese lady post-Sochi. It's like she could grow one inch and she would lose all her jumps. She is barely rotating them as is.

    I have no doubt the Russian girls will come back in the free, I just hope Cesario can hang onto the podium.

  12. #12
    ISU, stop promoting 2-foot skating!
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Axis of Evil
    Posts
    2,516
    I also think that sending Siraj here was a big mistake. USFS system is just one total, utter mess. Qualification is a mess (based on regions not points). Junior and Senior Nationals are at the same time so skaters aren't skating directly against each other. And then the decisions of who gets sent were are often very questionable as well, not taking into account anything other than Nationals.

    Park's short program was broadcasted, yes.

  13. #13
    Medalist
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    82
    Yes I just saw it and she was wonderful! She doesn't seem to have the harder jumps but the quality of everything bar the layback was wonderful.

  14. #14
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    854
    Quote Originally Posted by marcolee925 View Post
    Yes I just saw it and she was wonderful! She doesn't seem to have the harder jumps but the quality of everything bar the layback was wonderful.
    Park has all the triples (not very consistent though). Her planned combo is supposed to be 3S-3T. (I believe at Korean Nationals she landed almost all of her triples)

  15. #15
    ISU, stop promoting 2-foot skating!
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Axis of Evil
    Posts
    2,516
    Quote Originally Posted by burntBREAD View Post
    Park has all the triples (not very consistent though). Her planned combo is supposed to be 3S-3T. (I believe at Korean Nationals she landed almost all of her triples)
    It was a real shame she didn't go for the 3salchow/3toe in the SP because the salchow landed perfectly.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •