Ashley would have won COR, based on her scores at SA and TEB.
Should Ashley skip the GPF
- Thread starter flying camel
- Start date
Ashley would have won COR, based on her scores at SA and TEB.
No.
They held down caro pcs and goe. They wouldnt have any problem pulling ahsley pcs and goe lower
Hello, look at what happened
Woulda, coulda. The numbers don't lie. Ashley wins this event if she skates like she did before.
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2010
No they didn't. Caro does not have a good LP this season. I'm glad to see the judges evaluating her performance and not her reputation.
Ashley would have won hands down. She's an incredibly talented skater.
- Joined
- May 31, 2010
No.
Judges did not hesitate to put Lipni ahead(overall) of Caro who has multiple Worlds medals and great SS.
Wagner is not a Worlds medalist and IMO Wagner is slower than Lipni.
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2011
Caro also skated worse than Wagner, who didn't make any mistakes as costly as Caro's at her two events.
- Joined
- May 31, 2010
After SP scoring at COR(if Wagner had competed here), Wagner's LP performance might have been different from SA & TEB's.
And Wagner's total scores were 193(SA) & 194(TEB). Both somewhat overscored.
These are scores on which judges at COR can make to 190.5 (vs Lipni's 190.8) without difficulty.
- Joined
- Jun 16, 2010
Wagner slower than Julia!?! I don't think so.
Wagner was not overscored in those two events. In Skate America many felt she was underscored compared to Mao. Given that she is now doing a triple-triple and only made minor errors her scores should be atleast as high as they were.
Wagner was not overscored in those two events. In Skate America many felt she was underscored compared to Mao. Given that she is now doing a triple-triple and only made minor errors her scores should be atleast as high as they were.
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2010
To the extent an opinion can be wrong, this is wrong. Ashley is notably faster, but Julia is 15 and she will get faster too. Michelle was slow when she was 15.
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2011
- Country
-
Ashley looks really strong this season! I think Julia can compete with her only if clean. And the PCS cushion will evaporate as soon as she loses her consistency - I think that's what the judges love about her now. Otherwise, I want to have a good competition in the GPF so I wish all the skaters the best in their preparations to it.
Similar threads
