Page 6 of 9 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 LastLast
Results 76 to 90 of 124

Thread: Can patrick chan close the gap on yuzuru hanyu?

  1. #76
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Posts
    187
    And for comparison, the referee at the men's event in Skate Canada was Canadian. The technical controller of the men's event, Worlds 2013 in London, was Canadian. Should I take those results with a grain of salt as well?
    Or maybe we should ask Shin Amano why he keeps overlooking Mao's underrotations.

  2. #77
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    1,818
    Quote Originally Posted by Kalina View Post
    And for comparison, the referee at the men's event in Skate Canada was Canadian. The technical controller of the men's event, Worlds 2013 in London, was Canadian. Should I take those results with a grain of salt as well?
    Or maybe we should ask Shin Amano why he keeps overlooking Mao's underrotations.
    If you can show that Chan or another Canadian Champion has suddenly got a boost of 30+ points vs. a similar skate less than 3 weeks earlier or to make it easier for you, just show a sudden jump of 10+ points in PCS for a single skate, then I'll take back what I said. Since you obviously can't find such example, maybe you should reconsider whether the GPF result is indicative or even likely to repeat.

  3. #78
    Custom Title Mathman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Detroit, Michigan
    Posts
    27,108
    I think Hanyu has a chance. Why not? If he lands all his big tricks he could conceivably out-point Chan by 5 to 10 points in TES and try to hold the PCS margin to that much, countering Patrick's mature mastery with youthful enthusiasm.

  4. #79
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    4,140
    Quote Originally Posted by wallylutz View Post
    In any event, Hanyu had the highest TES at the 2013 Worlds Free Skate and still ended up off the podium. In fact, he couldn't even beat Chan in the Free Skate who fell 3 times despite having the highest TES.
    Chan fell twice. Hanyu URed and had an edge call. Their TES/PCS scores were essentially the reverse of each other, although I would have had Hanyu slightly ahead of Chan in the FS.

  5. #80
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Posts
    187
    Quote Originally Posted by wallylutz View Post
    If you can show that Chan or another Canadian Champion has suddenly got a boost of 30+ points vs. a similar skate less than 3 weeks earlier or to make it easier for you, just show a sudden jump of 10+ points in PCS for a single skate, then I'll take back what I said. Since you obviously can't find such example, maybe you should reconsider whether the GPF result is indicative or even likely to repeat.
    No, I can't show you. Can you show me the tapes of the japanese referee bribing the other judges so that they overscore Hanyu? Probably not. Can you lend us a time machine, so that we might travel to the future and assure ourselves that what you said will definitely happen? Nope.
    I've already explained what I think is the reason for such a big increase in PCS. That explanation makes sense to me, as I've seen the judging system work during these past years. If it doesn't make sense to you, it's your business. It's not like any of us can bring proof of what we're saying, here. Threads like these only exist for the sake of arguing.

  6. #81
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    4,887
    Hanyu`s technical base value is 8 points higher than Chan, unless Chan is planning to make some changes. Despite that he gets huge GOE compared to almost all the rest of the field, a clean Chan would not best a clean Hanyu on GOE, in fact Hanyu might even gain a couple more points there. So unless Chan wins the PCS by close to 10 points or more (and I dont think he would, Japan ice or not) a clean Hanyu would win the LP I believe.

    Could Chan get a few points lead in the short program if both are clean. That might be his only chance to triumph in that scenario, either that or adding more base value to his LP.

  7. #82
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    4,887
    Quote Originally Posted by qwertyskates View Post
    Actually, your comment about JL is is the truly laughable one here.
    You are an idiot. JL and YH are not comparable as first and foremost their biggest strengths arent even similar. Hanyu is the best jumper in the World today. Julia is a consistent jumper with small jumps, and whose LP doesnt have as high of base value as several of her competitors.

    Julia is not considered a threat for gold in Sochi unless atleast 2 skaters bomb. If Hanyu skates well nobody but Chan even has a chance of beating him at this point, and even he isnt certain to. Thus the two are not comparable in their current situations just like I said.

  8. #83
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    4,887
    Quote Originally Posted by Kalina View Post
    Should I take those results with a grain of salt as well?
    Oh you definitely should. Everyone else (except a few radically pro Canadians) do.

  9. #84
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    840
    Quote Originally Posted by Kalina View Post
    No, I can't show you. Can you show me the tapes of the japanese referee bribing the other judges so that they overscore Hanyu? Probably not. Can you lend us a time machine, so that we might travel to the future and assure ourselves that what you said will definitely happen? Nope.
    I've already explained what I think is the reason for such a big increase in PCS. That explanation makes sense to me, as I've seen the judging system work during these past years. If it doesn't make sense to you, it's your business. It's not like any of us can bring proof of what we're saying, here. Threads like these only exist for the sake of arguing.

  10. #85
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    404
    Quote Originally Posted by pangtongfan View Post
    You are an idiot. JL and YH are not comparable as first and foremost their biggest strengths arent even similar. Hanyu is the best jumper in the World today. Julia is a consistent jumper with small jumps, and whose LP doesnt have as high of base value as several of her competitors.

    Julia is not considered a threat for gold in Sochi unless atleast 2 skaters bomb. If Hanyu skates well nobody but Chan even has a chance of beating him at this point, and even he isnt certain to. Thus the two are not comparable in their current situations just like I said.

    Can you stop throwing insults ("idiot", "laughable") all the time at others when they disagree with you? Keep it classy, will you?

    First of all, I was comparing YH vs PC and JL vs Mao at GPF, *not* JL vs Yuna & Mao.

    It is about the odds of a younger newcomer to the Senior circuit vs an established OGM favorite Senior, as the thread implies.

    Like I said, your personal and impolitely expressed opinion doesn't hold water against the *REALITY* of JL getting 3 Golds at international event this season and GPF Silver right behind Mao, awarded by judges. JL is chasing Mao, just as YH is chasing Chan.

    The double standards you applied - one for YH vs PC and another for JL vs MA - do not help your stance.

    Just a couple of months ago at TEB, in Europe (neutral territory), judges obviously felt that PC is the better skater. In Russia, another neutral territory, it is most likely that the criteria of judgment will be the same.

    The debate is whether this GPF win by YH over PC is definitively showing that PC is now behind YH (neutral, unbiased judgment) or if there is home advantage at work and PC is still OGM frontrunner.

    Every Fed will fight for their skater, Japan is no exception at GPF. To accuse PC of enjoying home advantage but making an exception for YH when he is skating in Japan is not rational. YH even expressed surprise at his own GPF record breaking scores - there were clearly a number of flaws.

    My own judgment is that YH is better at jumps and is more flexible, however, PC has strong jumps and many other stronger skating qualities, SS, carriage, maturity, musicality, better edges, etc. that makes for a whole package. It's jumps vs whole skating delivery. YH is like JL, better technically but behind in many other aspects vs veteran champions.

    To me, this GPF result, like others where the home favorite won, do not indicate the larger picture for Sochi.

  11. #86
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    4,887
    Yes, Yu Na Kim's WD from the grand prix series in no way impacted Julia's success this year, and makes her grand prix showings with Yu Na absent (and Kostner doing her usual sleepwalking early season routine) an accurate indicator of her Olympic chances. Hanyu also wasnt unlucky at all to have to meet Chan in both his grand prix outings. Your theories hold about as much water as little paper napkin trying to hold down a flood.

    I like Julia alot more than Hanyu who as I already mentioned I am not a fan, but if you think how Julia currently compares to Kim and Asada (or should I say doesnt remotedly compare at this point) is comparable to how Hanyu is a strong factor at the very top of the mens field, then you are beyond delusional. One will be going to the Olympics with serious hopes of a gold medal, and shouldnt do worse than silver unless he implodes, and the other will be trying to hold off a bunch of women to win a bronze medal, with absolutely no hope of doing better unless 1 of 2 skaters has a complete and utter catastrophe.

    Anyway I wasnt just comparing who is better or who has a stronger standing right now, but breaking down their skill sets which arent even to each other. And that Hanyu actually is better in some ways than Chan, he has a much higher base value in the long program, and his GOEs can match and even surpass Chan's; unlike Julia who is better than say Asada at practically nothing (even spins Asada can pretty much match her in). Hanyu skates like a man, while Julia skates like a little girl still at this point (granted an extremely precocious and excellent one), with small jumps, and lack of speed and power and top notch basics that the great champions like Kim, Asada, and Kostner on a good day have.

  12. #87
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    404
    Quote Originally Posted by pangtongfan View Post
    Yes, Yu Na Kim's WD from the grand prix series in no way impacted Julia's success this year, and makes her grand prix showings with Yu Na absent (and Kostner doing her usual sleepwalking early season routine) an accurate indicator of her Olympic chances. Hanyu also wasnt unlucky at all to have to meet Chan in both his grand prix outings. Your theories hold about as much water as little paper napkin trying to hold down a flood.

    I like Julia alot more than Hanyu who as I already mentioned I am not a fan, but if you think how Julia currently compares to Kim and Asada (or should I say doesnt remotedly compare at this point) is comparable to how Hanyu is a strong factor at the very top of the mens field, then you are beyond delusional. One will be going to the Olympics with serious hopes of a gold medal, and shouldnt do worse than silver unless he implodes, and the other will be trying to hold off a bunch of women to win a bronze medal, with absolutely no hope of doing better unless 1 of 2 skaters has a complete and utter catastrophe.

    Anyway I wasnt just comparing who is better or who has a stronger standing right now, but breaking down their skill sets which arent even to each other. And that Hanyu actually is better in some ways than Chan, he has a much higher base value in the long program, and his GOEs can match and even surpass Chan's; unlike Julia who is better than say Asada at practically nothing (even spins Asada can pretty much match her in).

    "Laughable", "idiot", "delusional"...look, I'm done debating if the tone cannot be kept civil. This is an interesting debate but not when insults are thrown. Kovtun, if he is skating his 4-5quad program, will come close to or beat YH's BV. If Sochi is Russia pushing for new blood, then yes, all the frontrunners will be threatened. If that is the case, YH might win OGM, but you can't expect then Mao to win with her GPF performance at GPF in Japan vs JL, as JL's PCS and GOE will rise significantly, especially for battle of LP.

    If the old rules hold and stature is valued, veterans have an edge over newcomers, then PC, Mao/Yuna, will all keep their frontrunner status.

    I didn't want to believe there are PC haters, but it appears different standards are vehemently applied here to PC that they do not say, for Mao, who has often won despite falling and not bringing her A game. To me, PC and Mao are of equal stature and quality of skating, and both enjoy judges' favoritism, and deservedly so.

  13. #88
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    2,514
    Quote Originally Posted by pangtongfan View Post
    Hanyu`s technical base value is 8 points higher than Chan, unless Chan is planning to make some changes. Despite that he gets huge GOE compared to almost all the rest of the field, a clean Chan would not best a clean Hanyu on GOE, in fact Hanyu might even gain a couple more points there. So unless Chan wins the PCS by close to 10 points or more (and I dont think he would, Japan ice or not) a clean Hanyu would win the LP I believe.

    Could Chan get a few points lead in the short program if both are clean. That might be his only chance to triumph in that scenario, either that or adding more base value to his LP.
    I agree about the comments on tes but Chan is undermarked for pcs overall; he deserves a bigger cushion over at least Hanyu but the tide has changed. Chan has to up his tes at least skate clean and hit all level 4's on his spins and footwork to have a chance.

  14. #89
    Tripping on the Podium
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    55
    Quote Originally Posted by Skater Boy View Post
    I agree about the comments on tes but Chan is undermarked for pcs overall; he deserves a bigger cushion over at least Hanyu but the tide has changed.
    Overmarking is continuing in ridiculous manners. I actually like all marks going down, but if not and if Hanyu get 92 PCS than we can put Chan at 99 constantly.

  15. #90
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    4,140
    Quote Originally Posted by Skater Boy View Post
    I agree about the comments on tes but Chan is undermarked for pcs overall; he deserves a bigger cushion over at least Hanyu but the tide has changed. Chan has to up his tes at least skate clean and hit all level 4's on his spins and footwork to have a chance.
    Chan is not under marked for PCS and it has actually been suitably marked this season. It's Hanyu's outlying marks at the GPF that are wackier. The difference should be at least 2.5 marks in the SP if both go clean and it should be at least 5 points if both skate a clean free. I'm a fan of both but it's obvious that Chan is a better artistic skater (though Hanyu has improved he should not be getting 92 points with a fall).

Page 6 of 9 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •