Page 11 of 11 FirstFirst ... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Results 151 to 152 of 152

Thread: Ashley Wagner's chance of an Olympics Medal after Nationals

  1. #151
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Posts
    311
    Quote Originally Posted by Sasha'sSpins View Post
    I call BS on the race card people are trying to pull. Imo, Mirai vs. Ashley per the USFSA's criteria Wagner was always going to win. We've all gone over this ad nauseum in other threads, but imo the real controversy was sending an untried Polina Edmunds who only had a junior record to Mirai's results in the senior ranks. Would Polina have skated as well as she did this past season if she had to face the likes of Asada, the Russians, Kostner, or Kim? We'll never know. But I will always say that it is unfair to compare the results from junior events to those of a skater who had to skate against the top guns most of the last two years. Mirai , as well as Ashley and Gracie certainly faced them at one time or another. Polina's first test against them will be at the crown jewel of figure skating - the Olympics. I think that is grossly unfair to a skater who had to duke it out in the senior ranks for four years. Jmo.
    I can see the debate there, there are skaters who go to the Olympics before even going to Worlds, there always will be. For Polina, and any skater like her, it seems to go one way: Either they're a deer in the headlights, or they skate with nothing to lose. I would be cautious about proclaiming the Russian girls, especially Lipnitskaia, shoo-ins for medals. Never predict at the Olympics. Keep in mind, Julia has never been to Worlds, this is her biggest test yet and the Olympics are in home ice. She'll be under a lot of pressure, as will Sotnikova, though Sotnikova has a bit more experience. Que sera, sera. How about we give Ashley a clean slate. It seems everyone is ready to declare Gracie the new big star over Ashley based solely on US nationals. Again, don't count the medals before they won.

    I don't understand why the whole race thing is being played. Really? Then why send the Shibs to Sochi, or as someone else said, Zhang/Bartholomay. Why make what is already a difficult decision even uglier?


    And I think it is reprehensible that cyberbullies are leaving hateful messages against Ashley on her FB site as well as Twitter. Shame on those cowards hiding behind a computer screen
    "You hide behind computer screens so that you don't have to be seen. How can a person be so mean?" to quote Fergie. It's disgusting. Ashley. did not. make. the choice. Don't hate on her. Mirai isn't hating on her Ashley, why are these bullies? I'll never understand why some fans feel the need to be so ugly. You don't do the skaters any favours.

  2. #152
    Custom Title
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    291
    Wagner's chances of a medal at the Olympics are virtually non-existent. She is a good skater, but not Olympic or world-podium level.

    Her best quality was her consistency, but that has seemingly vanished this season. She has been making many mistakes and getting lots of underrotation calls this season, particularly in her free program. She introduced the 3F-3T (which is only borderline rotated and could easily be downgraded by a strict technical specialist) to her repertoire, but she has not gotten the scores that she expected.

    In short, she doesn't have the spins, edge quality or jump difficulty to compete with the best skaters in the world, and she must skate 100% clean to give herself a chance against more talented competitors.

    Moreover, the PCS she was getting from international judges was (I believe) based on being the #1 American. Now that Gold is the national champion, the judges may consider her the #1 American and she may start receiving the PCS advantage.

Page 11 of 11 FirstFirst ... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •