02-02-2014, 01:35 PM
Bottom line: that kiddo will be waiting in the wings if Kim or Asada aren't clean. That LP of hers is an Olympic winning number and I'm not sure YuNa's is. That said, I adore YuNa, and still think she has the extra musicality and grace that the others do not, and is the class of the field. I see Lipnitskaia on the podium & the Russian darling of the Olympics.
02-02-2014, 02:08 PM
02-02-2014, 02:55 PM
Size 7 Knife Boots
What's amazing is where Julia's chances are now in relation to just a few months ago when she was still not guaranteed to even make the team. It made her stronger and pushed her to develop further. Now if she wins silver no one would be surprised.
Originally Posted by Sk8n Mama
02-02-2014, 04:46 PM
She is a strong competitor for the bronze and the silver or gold if Yu Na, Mao or Carolina make a mistake.
I'm afraid she will be overscored because she is skating in her home country- I have a feeling it has the makings of a big controversy if the results are close and she is overscored and ends up winning a medal she did not deserve (a la Cup Of Russia 2013 at the cost of Carolina).
Truth is, she has great jumps and spins although her jumps are small and don't get any height or distance- I think it should be reflected in her first mark on the GOE. What truly worries me is her second mark. She started the season in the low 60's and is now in the high 60's for the long program which is unprecedented and shocking. The fact that she almost tied Carolina in the long program should be a red flag to the unfair judging that may take place in Sochi- it needs to be addressed immediately. Even judge's are speaking out about it:
02-02-2014, 07:27 PM
And that could very well be the difference. However YuNa does have an eye-catching SP that, if skated well, could make whatever Julia does with her FP moot. We've seen it before where YuNa has won competitions by racking up so many points in the SP that it makes everyone else skate outside their comfort zones come the FS. Could Julia just ignore that and just skate her program knowing it might not be enough to win gold (especially if YuNa skates after her)? Will she have the maturity to just be the best she can be ? It's a double-edged sword sometimes performing in your home country when the expectations are so high.
Originally Posted by Sk8n Mama
02-02-2014, 09:02 PM
Figure skating referee and former ISU official Sonia Bianchetti says Carolina Kostner was undermarked in Budapest
Originally Posted by WalkingJackson
You said 'judges' plural, were speaking out about it rather than 'a' judge is speaking out about it which is what the article is about. I am sure there are judges with her point of view but frankly Bianchetti is an Italian like Kostner. I would prefer to hear from unbiased judges on the matter. I'm guessing Russian judges would probably have their own spin on their compatriots and Kostner as well.
And for the record I disagree with Bianchetti. I think Julia and Adelina did great and their final placements are correct. Kostner has been under par all year and I think of the three 2013 Worlds medallists, she, Yuna, and Mao, Kostner is the most vulnerable. She's been beaten at every GP and now Euros, likely with different judging panels each time. I just don't believe that there's this worldwide conspiracy that includes non-Russian judges determined to place Julia and/or Adelina at the top of the Olympic podium anymore than there was when Brian Boitano won in Calgary, Sarah Hughes won at Salt Lake City or Evan in Vancouver, all on North American soil. Sometimes homegrown skaters just rise to the occasion (kind of like the 1980 U.S. Men's Hockey team) and they simply bring it in from of the home crowd or near neighbors (in the case of Americans winning at the Canadian-hosted Olympic Games). I get the feeling that that is exactly what is going to happen with Julia and/or Adelina. I think that like Hughes and her back to back triple-triples in Salt Lake City, jumps are going to win the day - and Kostner has been looking very vulnerable on that end. She also simply doesn't have the same firepower technically that Sotnikova and Lipnitskaya have.
02-02-2014, 11:45 PM
I disagree. If Julia is not skating like junior, none, including Li, or Polina, in the senior circle is juniorish. Julia's skating is mature in terms of presentation and expressiveness, not her skating. You may not like it, but there is no reason why Polina or the Japanese skater who took silver in 4cc, when they are clean, so to speak, can't rank better than Julia while Julia's skating is ratified as adequate as senior.
Originally Posted by Sasha'sSpins
02-03-2014, 01:45 AM
Sorry. Completely disagree on Polina. She still looks awkward and coltish out there as does Elena. Julia looks much more polished, much more refined and it is clear that one international panel of judges after another agrees with me. We'll just have to disagree on Lipnitskaya - but you'd better get ready, because she's more than likely going to be on the podium at Sochi.
Originally Posted by HalfTriple
I never once mentioned Zijun Li in my previous post, and I certainly don't consider her as a skater who looks junior out there as Polina Edmunds and Elena Radionova do. Quite the the contrary. Like Julia, she presents a much more mature, much more refined style.
02-03-2014, 02:55 PM
02-03-2014, 04:11 PM
I don't see ppl having that strong of an emotion against her. Personally, I admire her determination but not her skating style.
Originally Posted by Sam-Skwantch
02-03-2014, 04:14 PM
the answer to this thread is NO!
02-03-2014, 04:38 PM
Hey I know that Lipnitskaia is good but I was just implying that she is not super consistent remember this?http://youtu.be/r99vlgdi3l8
Originally Posted by Isabel_O'Reilly
02-03-2014, 04:49 PM
Size 7 Knife Boots
What if I hyperlinked Mao's Japan nationals skate? Would that prove anything?
02-03-2014, 04:52 PM
Why are you so mad about Julia? It's not like she's the only skater who has ever had inconsistencies.
Originally Posted by nagoya
02-03-2014, 04:54 PM
If both Lipnitskaia and Asada is not perfect this will be the result
LIPNITSKAIA- cup of russia 2013 http://youtu.be/r99vlgdi3l8 Free skate = 118.56
ASADA - Skate America 2013 http://youtu.be/VS90gggO56Q FREE SKATE = 131.37
These are FACTS! with proven Videos , even if Lipnitskaia will not much do error than this video she will still not get close to 131.37 most probably on the mid 120's
Yes Lipnitskaia is very good for her age but she is still human and in need of more polishing to level with yuna and mao .
what is wrong with this thread? do you guys forget how many world championship medals that yuna and mao have won? with yuna having the world record and mao having the record of most grand prix titles?
Lipnitskaia is still young, give her some time eventually she will be on top, not just now. Her best result will probably bronze if she beat costner and suzuki, well, she beat them before so I can see no reason why she cant beat them now in her own turf