03-09-2014, 03:55 AM
Wicked Yankee Girl
Clearly, the DWTS gig was not finalized until after they won the gold medal. Because training for that program has already begun (according to recent interviews), it doesn't look as though it would be possible to be on it and still go to Worlds properly trained.
03-09-2014, 08:39 AM
I am surprised no one si commenting that V and T have withdrawn due to Max's injury or am I mistaken? This really opens things up if true. Sadly after the olympics a lot of teams and skaers don't go - it isn't the same. So many medalists missing:(
03-09-2014, 09:13 AM
Oh - I missed that. Didn't realize Max was injured. I'm really hoping Denney and Coughlin can have a great skate and medal. Their LP at Nationals was awesome but their scores in the SP did them in. I find them ever so much more exciting and interesting that Castelli and Schnapir.
03-09-2014, 12:50 PM
Wicked Yankee Girl
Well, I've got to say I find Castelli & Shnapir a lot more interesting, and I particularly like their SP to Santana, choreographed by Julie Marcotte. I hope they land the clean quad Salchow throw at Worlds! They have such great transitions, unlike Denney & Coughlin, who have a rather empty program. I have no idea why Denney and Coughlin have had such trouble with their SP lately. I hope they skate well at Worlds, though. Wouldn't it be amazing if the U.S. ended up with 3 slots in pairs?
The pairs at Nationals, as a group were so much better than in previous years-there were at least three teams worthy of a spot at Worlds.
03-09-2014, 04:33 PM
Yep, in this exhibition: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5lsS478JTao when they do the death spiral you can see him grab his shoulder. Which is curious, if he's injured - especially the shoulder - shouldn't they stop doing exhibitions to let it heal?
Originally Posted by noskates
03-09-2014, 06:58 PM
If they skate clean again with the quad and the Canadians mess up not only thee spots but maybe a medal could be their's?
Originally Posted by dorispulaski
03-09-2014, 07:19 PM
Wicked Yankee Girl
They did their very, very best at Olympics in 4 programs-not to mention winning a very tough US Nationals. I fear they might be worn out...but I have hopes.
03-09-2014, 07:23 PM
I'm probably a little bit prejudiced because Caydee and John sat behind us at US Nats in 2012 and we got to know them - so I'm partial. John is a sweetheart, very nice guy. And Caydee is very nice. Both are pretty unassuming! I find them exciting and wish they hadn't had an injury last year and lost a year of competition. I think it really hurt them. If I'm not mistaken, they WON the LP at Nats but their scores were just too low from the short to move up.
At Worlds, I'm FOR anyone from the US. It would be wonderful if one of our pairs teams medaled. More than that would be awesome.
And yes, you'd think if Max's shoulder was injured he wouldn't do anything to aggravate it.
03-09-2014, 10:02 PM
Love popcorn, hate horrendous costumes.
Meh, Mishin's students always end up with injuries .Even Yagudin, to some extent. For the record, just look at Liza, and Artur. Poor those kids! Not everyone can be a superman like Plushenko. And he is superman no more, I am crying here. I hope he got a normal and healthy life after all the crazy years.
Originally Posted by Pippuripihvi
03-10-2014, 09:07 AM
D/C did win the LP with a massive overscore despite his singling three consecutive jumps in their combo and extremely out of synch spins that the judges ignored. Their SP was also high given what they put out (as was Scimeca & Knierim's) when teams like K/O and Donlan/Speroff had cleaner shorts and Leng/LeDuc were miles better in the short which wasn't reflected in the scoring. The judges were desperately trying IMO to put them on the Olympic team until Felicia and Nate skated lights out and most importantly last in the group. I firmly believe that if Denney and Coughlin had skated last, they would have been on the Olympic team.
Originally Posted by noskates
I am a huge, huge Castelli & Shnapir fan and would love them medaling but I don't see either US team on the podium. I do hope she can get the quad landed cleanly after coming so close in Sochi. Despite the fact that I loathe D/C's skating, I had really hoped they would be able to clinch three spots in a depleted field but the field is not that depleted and I just don't see it happeneing. Yes V/T won't be there but there are two strong Chinese pairs, S/S's swan song, S/K whose stock has risen massively, both Canadian teams, Italy's B/H and the often overscored B/L. 6th and 7th will be very very tough. But I would love if D/C to help the US clinch that spot and retire on a good note. I don't see a reason for them to stay around- Marissa & Simon are now the definitive US #1 and there are too many young teams that will soon pass them including Caydee's sister who is a much more complete skater.
03-10-2014, 01:01 PM
Yulia forver! I'm on team dumped Ice Dance.
An Olympic gold medalist not going to Worlds is hardly strange. Yu Na after 2010 said it was very hard to come back for Worlds after winning Oly gold. She is not retiring, I expect to see her skate next year.
Originally Posted by tana
She has nothing to prove in the Worlds. Yuna is not going to be there and in any case it's another competition. You might have a bad night and still be a fantastic skater or viceversa.
So I think people will never be satisfied because it's impossible to prove something which belongs to one event, in one particular night only.
It's just ridiculous and it's usuful only to the press&fanatics, who loves gossip, trash talk, and demonizing skaters or this sport.
In anycase she's doomed, no matter how she skates. So the only chance she has it's to let this year's world pass and hope that cool heads prevail and attacks are called off next year. Come back stronger and better and have a lasting career if she can, which I doubt because the era of the many-years medalists ended with the new judging system.
03-10-2014, 02:56 PM
My guess is Sotnikova will skate only at GPs where the judging panel and/or tech team will be favorable to her. I'm not sure how the Russian fed will manage that, as she won't be a seeded skater, only a returning Olympic medalist (1-2 seeded skaters get first choice). I guess the Russian fed will know the judge/tech assignments and make sure she's 'invited' to the right venues, probably CoR and maybe TEB or CoC.
She did go to 'favorable' events this past season (Mme Piseev was on the judging panel of both) but she didn't win either one.
03-11-2014, 12:05 AM
I imagine Adelina will be assigned Cup of China and Cup of Russia. Traditionally weak field at the first and obvious inflation at the second. Hello Grand Prix Final! I'm being a bit shady here. She could definitely make the GPF regardless of her GPs this season- after all, she made it this year with reasonable marks. Winning a a world title to go with that outrageous OGM is a different issue entirely.
03-11-2014, 05:01 AM
The Russian Fed don't choose which events she gets, other than COR.
Originally Posted by amc987
03-12-2014, 12:24 AM
I know the Russian Fed doesn't choose exactly- don't skaters get invitations to GPs based on the organizers' wishes/ the ISU's requirements for entrants (e.g. the skaters with top 6 placements at the previous worlds are seeded, a certain # of skaters with season's best scores, etc.)? Anyway, if that's the case, wouldn't Adelina probably get her pick of events given her marketability as the reigning Olympic gold medalist? I think she'd prob choose China and CoR if so.
Originally Posted by karne