I like these moments. They're so simple but so cool and the second one is so poignant.
Stéphane Lambiel http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a9snEtUHJZ0 3:11 and 5:02-5:25
in the middle of the difficult season with his injury and uncertainty about Olympic selection, Daisuke fought hard. This segment of Friends and Lovers at Japanese Nationals 2013 gives me chills no matter how many times I watch it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODVHs3KVZ20#t=02m47s
Daisuke's 2011/12 season SP, i get the biggest goosebumps when he pauses in the step sequence. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsUplazBWp0
Like so many of you mentioned, Mao's Sochi LP. Especially from the moment she nails her 8th triple, the loop till the end when she bursts into tears... Gets me every single time.
1996 Worlds Michelle's SP - the part she strokes so graciously into Ina Bauer at 1.24, and where she taps her hands so captured in the feel of the music at 3.20.
2004 Worlds Shizuka's LP - you can see that the usually reserved Shizuka really feels the music at 7.23 during the magnificent Spread Eagle, then to nailing the second 3lutz, then to Ina Bauer till the end.
Shizuka's Torino LP - the part she moves to the gorgeous Y spiral with only a couple of strokes at
Watching Patrick's steps. Especially Take Five.
Davis & White's Free Dance 2013/14. The part they just keep going and going from 3:35 is insane.
Gordeeva's Mahler--like watching the earth move. This piece was nearly unskateable, but no other music could have been better to convey the profound loss and grief Katia had experienced. Confession: When Virtue and Moir skated to this music, I was never able to enter completely into the spell they cast, because the Adagietto has just one meaning to me, and that meaning transcends competitive skating. Tessa and Scott looked beautiful, to be sure, and they well deserved the OGM that this earned them, but I wish that Zoueva had used some other part of a Mahler symphony for them in 2010.
I don't mean to criticize Zoueva at all, but I've always been curious: has anyone ever asked her why she used this music again? She choreographed the original version for Katia out of her own grief for Sergei, so clearly the piece meant a great deal to her. I'd love to know how it came to her to recast it into something more serene and graceful rather than a statement of unimaginable rupture and anguish.
I just want to say kudos to the OP, TMC, for starting this thread as I am so enjoying following the video links of skating performances posted here as well as reading the explanations why they are deemed to give chills.
D/W's Strauss free dance - I noticed a couple of moments in this version (gpf) which I thought were hilarious/awesome: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZSzLIs9S24
I can just see what Charlie is "saying":
At 2:19: "Look, I twirled her!"
At 3:24: "Wait...where did she go? Oh there, wait for me!"
Also agree w/ the poster who mentioned Rudy Galindo @ 1996 US Nats & Midori Ito @ 1988 Olys. Rudy's performance had me in tears. I wasn't aware of the anti-gay angle (grrr....); only knew that many people had pretty much written him off and that he had been very discouraged after Kristi Yamaguchi opted to quit their pairs partnership to concentrate on singles. Even without the backstory, though, it was a wonderful skate -- he was simply inspired. No way anyone could have denied him the gold that day.
As for Midori...watching that performance, I found myself wondering if she had springs in her skates or something. Yikes, that was amazing! Also wonder if she would have been on the podium (or at least closer to it) if not for the school figures.
I Casi un Bolero SO MUCH. The perfect example of telling a story in a program, and oh, what a story. A young widow lost and alone and grieving...the young man who falls in love with her...her uncertainty...and finally, their joy.
What I don't love is some of the comments under the videos...yeesh, some of these people would have only been happy if Katia had worn black and cried all her life over Sergei.
Generally, skates that make me feel emotional are the one that make me forget I'm watching a competition.
Daisuke's performances. Almost all of them give me goosebumps and teary eyed
2011 NHK SP Garden of souls The whole performance. I don't care if he just did a 3/3 instead of a quad, I know he did it clean whith a quad at Nats and WTT but it didn't have the same emotional impact. For me this one performance remains as his best SP ever, it gives me chills from start to finish.
2012 Nat FP Pagliacci Despite being one of my least favourite program of him, this particular performance especially the end when he soars on the edge and his "possessed" like look in the ending position really gave me goosebumps.
2010 World SP Eye The circular steps. Shame on the camera work but I liked it better than Oly because he seemed more relaxed.
2010 Worlds FP La Strada Like watching a movie. I especially loved the mid section when he's having fun with the choreography.
2013 Worlds SP Moonlight Sonata Minus jumps, the last spin, footwork and transitions are pure chills.
And I'll stop there because the list could go on. I think there is not a single performance good or bad from Dai that won't draw me in.
Same for Akiko.
2012 NHK FP O The choreographic steps at the end never fail to amaze me even when the jumps aren't there.
2013 WTT SP Kill Bill Her kick, hydroblade and killer steps.
2013 Dream On Ice Ex Love dance The overall performance. It's like she becomes the instruments one by one (the flute (?), the cello, the voice)
2010 CoR FP Fiddler on the Roof
Savchenko/Szolkowy 2007 Euros FP The Mission The overall performance
2003 Worlds FP Turandot Like most of you in this thread, I find it difficult to not shed a single tear.
2007 World FP Meditation from Thaïs
2011 The Ice Ex Jupiter
2006 SA SP Nocturne
2014 World SP Nocturne II
Of course her 2014 OG performance which brings me to tears every time I watch it.
2011 Nat SP Scheherazade Because it was her first time skating after her mother's death just a few weeks before this routine. And she stayed so strong despite being surely overwhelmed by the emotion. Also I may be in the minority but I love this program.
2008 Worlds SP Fantasia for violin
2007 Worlds SP Tango de Roxanne
2008 SA SP Danse macabre Yes it's not her best but this is the one who always give me chills especially the end. Idk why her season late performances always leave me cold.
2012 Worlds SP Violin muse
2013 CoR FP Papa can you hear me?
All of Shizuka's pro programs especially The voice and Yugao
Also her 2004 Worlds FP
2007 Worlds SP Variations
2014 Worlds SP Ave Maria
2007 4cc OD Assassination Tango
2008 Worlds FD Umbrellas of Cherbourg
2013 Nat FD Carmen
2010 OG FP Carmen I couldn't find the OG version so I linked the one from nats which was also great, but Oly's was special.
2010 World SP Pirates of the Caribbean
2010 TEB SP The Witches of Eastwick
2010 Worlds SP Bold as love
2012 SA SP Exodus
2012 SA Ex Sound of silence
Julia 2013 SC FP Schindler's List I wasn't a fan of her at all and she managed to make me care for her with that performance. This is my favourite out of all the clean ones she did.
Also all of Michelle Kwan's performances. I can't even pick one, just all of them makes me feel emotional.
There are still a lot of performances and skaters that give me chills but judging by the super long list above, I think it's more than enough for now.
Oh and your description about Casi un Bolero is so spot on.
I was watching this video Yesterday and I just Love Yagudin here. I still miss him today.
"Moon Over Bourbon Street" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJZTiji8DPw
Here with Racing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gqcsgm2VLB8&list=WL
Those edges are just to die for.