Here's a thread for discussing grades of execution.
For singles and pairs, you can download ISU Communication 1790 from the link at the bottom of the page here:
The bullet points for positive GOEs and the suggested reductions for negative GOEs are listed at the end of the document.
I hope we could start out by reminding ourselves of what the rules/guidelines are and apply them to a few whole programs, discussing among ourselves what GOEs we think the elements deserve and why according to these rules, before comparing our thoughts to the official panels.
Anyone care to choose a performance to start with?