No, this is terrible. Who would want to be a judge under such a system?
Let's say you are judge #2. All we want from you is to count Transitions and then to give an opinion on Performance and on Choreography. If you have something to say about the skater's blade to ice skills (SS) or about the way they interpreted the music, or about the quality of the skater's triple Lutz -- shut up, we're not interested. Who do you think you are, judge #8?
The ISU is fiddling while Rome is burning. This monkey business will not produce better programs. It will not produce better skating. It will not win back disaffected fans. It will not improve their product at the elite level and it cannot be implemented in lower level contests with fewer judges. It will not eliminate cronyism and disruptive politicking within the organization.