Interview with Coach Mishin | Golden Skate

Interview with Coach Mishin

dorispulaski

Wicked Yankee Girl
Joined
Jul 26, 2003
Country
United-States
The original interview
http://www.nvspb.ru/tops/strana-ne-tolko-vstala-s-kolen-no-i-podnyalas-na-cypochki-55946

Google Translation of the Interview
http://www.nvspb.ru/tops/strana-ne-tolko-vstala-s-kolen-no-i-podnyalas-na-cypochki-55946

Mishin discusses many things. As always, he is insightful and interesting.

Here us a representative quote of this year's version of the Zayak rule and the shortened preparation time for skaters:

In the offseason, the ISU has once again changed the rules. In particular, limiting the number of repetitions of double jumps, halve the time of preparation of the athlete to enter the ice.

- This is not the kind of changes that lead to the progress of figure skating. I understand that the "rule of 30 seconds' interests due to TV, not the sporting aspect. So I can not welcome it. A minute before the start can give athletes a greater degree to show their skills. Restricting repeat double jump is also not in favor of the athlete. There is a risk disrupting the triple jump, do a double and get zero points. As a result, the outstanding figure skater might lose because of trifling errors. It happened, for example, in Sochi with Javier Fernandez Spaniard lost the medal, because he made ​​the "extra" stage. I think that these things do not decorate our set of rules. And these moments more, unfortunately enough
 

Sandpiper

Record Breaker
Joined
Apr 16, 2014
I agree with him on both points. The 30-seconds thing is just one more part of the ISU's "We shall increase penalties for everything except falls" motto. :disapp: And... pretty much the same thing, on the doubles rule. Neither will lead to better performances.

The other part I found interesting about the interview. He speaks about why he went with a heavy competition schedule for Liza. While he lists several reasons, this one I didn't hear mentioned before:
Given the conditions that we had in St. Petersburg, the amount of ice and the people who are on the ice, concludes: training during the competition are much more fruitful and productive.
If I'm reading this correctly, there's not a lot of ice in St. Petersburg and the conditions are not good... to the extent that competition practices offer a better environment? Perhaps I'm making a bigger deal out of it than I should--how do competition practices stack up compared to other rinks and training centres?
 

KKonas

Medalist
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
I've been to St. Petersburg 3 times and the 3 different rinks I saw were quite old and one could almost call them "rickety". Don't know if Russia has built any new rinks in the area. Moscow seems to have received all the $$$$ when it comes to building skating facilities if Mishin makes such a statement.
 

adelia

Record Breaker
Joined
Oct 18, 2014
I've been to St. Petersburg 3 times and the 3 different rinks I saw were quite old and one could almost call them "rickety". Don't know if Russia has built any new rinks in the area. Moscow seems to have received all the $$$$ when it comes to building skating facilities if Mishin makes such a statement.
Plushenko echoed this statement in an interview not too long ago.
 

Alba

Record Breaker
Joined
Feb 26, 2014
If I'm reading this correctly, there's not a lot of ice in St. Petersburg and the conditions are not good... to the extent that competition practices offer a better environment? Perhaps I'm making a bigger deal out of it than I should--how do competition practices stack up compared to other rinks and training centres?

Yes, many have spoken about this problem in St.Petersburg. Moskvina and Vasilieva also.
Olega Vasiliev in the end had to leave. Artur Dmitriev also, if I'm not mistaken, and Sakhanovich.

Moskvina gave a great interview in September:
http://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/ind...irnov-project-is-the-centre-of-my-life.93078/

Among other things she spoke about this problem they're facing now in St.P

EV: Everytime when thinking about pairs skating I can't help wondering why a pairs centre such as one created by Nina Mozer in Moscow didn't exist already in St. Petersburg under you. I know you were trying to create one, why didn't it happen?

TM: Because Moscow is much more attractive for both skaters and coaches. First of all things are closer: the sports ministry is there, the federation. Second there are lots of ice rinks and schools in Moscow. And, last but not least, it's easier to find sponsors in Moscow.

EV: Yet there were times when saying `pairs skating' we meant St. Petersburg.


TM: Right. But things change. Just like in the nature: the river bank collapses, the river changes direction and where once was a field is now a lake. There were times when Stanislav Zhuk was the only pairs coach in Moscow and was very successful. But then things changed and he was not working as much as before, the pairs skating glided to St .Petersburg. Now it's back to Moscow.
The problem is that remaining on the high level and preparing the new generation at the same time is really hard, though it's the right way to develop figure skating as a business. It turned out to be impossible in St. Petersburg. Our skating federation is small compared to the one in Moscow. There isn't enough funding, not that many specialists, not enough ice. Actually there are just 2 ice rinks - Jubileiny' and the academy.


I love when she says: But things change. Just like in the nature: the river bank collapses, the river changes direction and where once was a field is now a lake. :laugh:

This woman is a legend.
 
Last edited:

BlackPack

Medalist
Joined
Mar 20, 2013
Do rivers really change directions? I didn't know that:eek:

BTW... I was hoping to read some trademark odd, funny comments by Mishin. He was so serious here :cry:
 

KKonas

Medalist
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
The Chicago River flow direction was changed but it was man-made (civil engineering) - not a natural situation. Moskvina is famous for her folktales.
 

Alba

Record Breaker
Joined
Feb 26, 2014
Do rivers really change directions? I didn't know that:eek:

I think earthquakes may do that. I also read on wikipedia that The Tonlé Sap ("Great Lake" in Cambodia): is unusual for two reasons: its flow changes direction twice a year, and the portion that forms the lake expands and shrinks dramatically with the seasons.
 

anyanka

Record Breaker
Joined
Jul 8, 2011
Where, when? I would love to read that too. :yes:

She stated somewhere that she was working on one, I think it was in her Wikipedia? But I hadn't heard much since, and no updates. I hope it is translated into English too, I presume it'll be written in Russian (although we all know Tamara speaks perfect English too).
 
Top