Throughout this season it has been brought up ithat some of the contestants were too young or lacked the life experience needed to make the songs believable. Last night after Diana sang "I Believe" Simon said something to the effect that at age 16 she could not possibly be credible in singing the lyrics.
Why did the show choose contestants who they admit are too young to be in the competition?
Why did they choose Tamyra's song if they felt one of the contestants would not be credible in singing it?
I voted for Fantasia but I feel that a diservice was done to Diana by the show.