Gymanstics are more current. Skating is getting a bit boring, without the competitions. Who is your favorite woman gymnast (past or present)?
Mary Lou Retton
Carly Patterson
Elena Shushunova
Shanon Miller
Daniela Silivas
Ecaterina Szabo
Svetlana Boginskaya
Svetlana Khorkina
Tatiana Gutsu
Other
Gymanstics are more current. Skating is getting a bit boring, without the competitions. Who is your favorite woman gymnast (past or present)?
I've got to go with local gal MARY LOU. She has represented the sport well and has gone on to excell at the most important job in the world.........being a MOM.
My 2 favs aren't on there. (Dominique Moceanu and Lilia Podkovayeva)
I always loved Shannon Miller. She seemed so down to earth and I was proud that an American girl finally stepped up and became a viable (and reliable) World contender (no boycotts, etc). She also was brilliant on the beam...which is probably my favorite apparatus! Others I loved from the past: Nadia Comaneci, Mary Lou, Dominique Dawes, Amy Chow
Present favorites: The entire U.S. team (particularly Humphrey & Hatch...way to go!), Carolina Ponor, Svetlana Khorkina (pre-2004 Olympic appearance)...and probably the entire Chinese team.
Silvia Mitova and Henrietta Onodi....but of those listed, it probably would have been Boguinskaya.
Kasey
I don't like that bratty Russian girl that whined for not winning. Is that behavior really acceptable in Russia? What is wrong with them? I remember Irina doing the same thing at SLC when Sarah won FAIR AND SQUARE. Their anti-Americanism probably cost them many fans.
Nadia - I don't think there will ever be another like her.
I have only heard of Nadia and Olga (Korbut), but never watched them. That is why I left them off the list.
My favorites are tied between Vera Caslavska and Ludmilla Turischeva. I also like Nellie Kim a lot, but she was more of a specialist. Of the more recent gymnasts listed, it's a tie between Shannon Miller and Svetlana Khorkina.
Last edited by hockeyfan228; 08-28-2004 at 01:41 AM.
If you never saw Nadia's 7 perfect 10's you really have missed something. She was abosolutely amazing. Her performances looked effortless, as second nature as walking. While the tricks they do today are I'm sure more difficult, I have never seen anything that approaches the "perfection" she displayed during those Olympic's. She was only 14, 86 lbs, and had an innocence that was so refreshing, she seemed to have no idea how amazingly she performed - all in a days work. The whole world fell in love with her that day. I have compared every gymnast to her that I have seen since, and while many are great, I have never seen anyone that performed like she did. I kept thinking that there would be the "next" Nadia, but I've come to believe there never will be. She was one of a kind.
Last edited by Kathy; 08-28-2004 at 02:51 AM.
Forever Olga Korbut. She popularized the sport like no one else has ever done. (Then Nadia advanced the sport like no one had done beforehand.)
I missed Nadia Comanice on the list. She is to Gymnastics as Sonia Henie is to figure skating, imo.
And Vash, I agree with you on skating being boring without competitions.
Joe
I voted for Shannon Miller. Constitant & elegant.
Also like Boginskaya, she always had really interesting floor exercises.
Favorite not mentioned - Comanechi
Favoriite from these Olympics - Ponor from Romania - My two favorite women's routines from Athens were her beam & floor.
Eliza
I watched the Nadia movie once when it was on HBO. It was an older movie, and they showed an actress doing her routine. I wish it was the real Nadia and her competition. Anyone know how we could get a copy of this? I know she was amazing and everyone just fell in love with her.
Hers is a great story.
I saw her with Katie Couric and Today, and she is beautiful.
I too really wish I had a tape of Nadia's Olympic performances, and would be interested if anyone knows how to get one. I remember watching her in awe during those Olympics, as if it was yesterday. She was so incredible that the image of her performing on bars, the floor and the beam is still etched in my brain. It would be such a treat for those of you who never saw her to be able to see what she did.
Bookmarks