Many Canadian skaters cross the border to compete in Skate Detroit and Liberty, where there are very competitive final rounds. Hopefully, these skaters will continue to push themselves by seeking out challenging competitive environments. It is certainly to their benefit!
I noticed that it pretty much just junior and senior skaters who compete at Liberty. Given the different rules ( and the travel costs ) for skaters at novice and below, you don't see any novice and below Canadian skaters at Liberty.
More Canadian skaters from all levels do compete at Detroit. Detroit however is minimal cost travelwise to Western Ontario based skaters. Detroit is right beside Windsor, Ontario.
That is a very valid point, just wondering. Skaters should seek the competition instead of hoping for competition at a certain event. Regardless of final rounds or not, competitive skaters compete against the entire group, whether or not they are divided into 10 groups. There is alot of score matching at these events. They may not be on the same warmup ice, but competitive kids want to have the highest scores regardless of 1 group or 20.
Skaters have to branch out to competitions other than just regional, ie Quebec, Wildrose, BC. These competitions usually attract the same skaters every year. Some skaters may branch off to the neighboring province, but that is it until Sectionals. For the majority of skaters, Challenge is the first "travelling" competition of the year. Exposure to other competitions, adapting to travel, adapting to meals changing, etc are all part of development and succeeding.
One issue is that for novice levels and below, the Canadian rules are different from the American rules ( different requirements , program lengths etc ). That will keep many of the lower level skaters from doing that travel.
I know that skaters look at the scores of all flights not just the one they competed in. However , a fair comparison can't happen between the top scores when they were subjected to different callers and judges.
As well, in separate groups, the top skaters don't experience the direct pressure of having other skaters on the competition ice that can push them. Comparing scores to other top skaters in other groups is not the same thing.
So event finals are needed here in Canada at all levels. This is the only way that our ladies can get used to the pressure of international competition.