- Joined
- Jul 11, 2003
Sometimes, the Tech Panel sees more correctly than the arm chair TV judge.
Ladies SP
- Thread starter bibi
- Start date
- Joined
- Jun 5, 2007
Sometimes, the Tech Panel sees more correctly than the arm chair TV judge.
Technical panel sees tv slowmotion~~~~Too~~~
You must see slowmotion --Ashley and Yuna..
Ashley---2.25 rotation
Yuna--2.75 rotation
http://gall.dcinside.com/list.php?id=figureskating&no=420678&page=1
Last edited:
- Joined
- Mar 24, 2008
Ok, let's talk with video clips. Would you show me anything that other skaters did 3F in the same way as Yuna but their jump is called consistently as a lip?
Unless you show me the proof, I will have to think of you as who just blindly trashes her.
Last edited:
At first people said it was downgraded (in the PBP thread), but when I cheched the scores (http://www.isufs.org/results/wc2008/WC08_Ladies_SP_Scores.pdf) I noticed that it only received -GoE for the fall. It was sort of weird, considering it was very clearly underrotated (and it was underrotation that caused the fall), but as I said, I don't really mind the final result (though I would prefer Mao-YuNa-Yukari podium).
Yeah, peaking later in the season would be smart. Fixing the 3F ASAP might be a wise idea, though - it might be too difficult later. I suspect that YuNa works on her 3F already - I think the reason she fell a few times in the practices was because she tried to do a correct take-off.
NO. It was NOT. If her triple was downgraded at worlds, she wouldn't have advanced to the final group. I was sooooo pissed since the UR was so transparent.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PRTVsAg9Nzw
- Joined
- Mar 24, 2008
Fiercemao, I am waiting for your reply here.....
If you need time, please tell me.
If you need time, please tell me.
Fiercemao, I am waiting for your reply here.....
If you need time, please tell me.
I don't have time to do research on edge since I generally believe edge calls are extremely silly. Just one example, Miki got called on wrong edge last season. If she's a lipper, Yu Na is as well.
Oh dear, the Korean Yu-Na bots are foaming at the mouth even though she's first after the SP and will probably go on to win the competition outright. It's so hard to satisfy people sometimes.
Since she was finally marked as a lipper in this SP, I do have to wonder if she was always prone to lipping in the past and whether those people who claimed she did weren't quite so misinformed after all. Maybe the judges are finally wising up. I don't think she'd produce a lip out of nowhere tonight if she wasn't prone or apt to doing so in the first place.
Since she was finally marked as a lipper in this SP, I do have to wonder if she was always prone to lipping in the past and whether those people who claimed she did weren't quite so misinformed after all. Maybe the judges are finally wising up. I don't think she'd produce a lip out of nowhere tonight if she wasn't prone or apt to doing so in the first place.
I’m very unhappy with today’s COC judging that obviously held down Kim by punishing her with scandalous “e” and “<”. Or will they also punish Asada for her not only pre-rotated but under-rotated 3A, for her flutz, and for her foul use of toe picks entering into jumps?
Yu-Na said right after 2008 Worlds that she felt like she was just doomed to be a Worlds bronze medalist. And I think she's totally wrong. She's not doomed. It's fixed.
Yu-Na said right after 2008 Worlds that she felt like she was just doomed to be a Worlds bronze medalist. And I think she's totally wrong. She's not doomed. It's fixed.
- Joined
- Oct 29, 2008
I don't why you had to put a race to Yu-Na's fans. They aren't all Korean.
- Joined
- Jan 6, 2007
Or maybe the ISU thought "Oh, now it's 2300 youtube vids showing Kim lipping - I guess we have to call her on it now."
But the lip-calls are strange anyway. Anyone remember Weir and Lysacek? They didn't get edge-called for the entire 07/08 season - except for their last competitions. At Worlds Weir suddenly had two wrong flips and Lysacek got suddenly called on his Flip at the Japan Open. And yes, fans pointed out that Weir lipped before that - but he was never called on it.
The ISU needs to fix this mercurial edge-calling - pronto please.
The rabid Yu-Na bots are Korean. The obnoxious ones sure are. Just as the virulent Mao fans are Japanese. Makes some kind of strange sense, doesn't it?
Wow! And everyone though I was a Yu-na Kim fan who couldn't see reason.
(not just you caleb)I think the scores are fair Caleb. She's still in freakin first place, and there are things she needs to work on.
It's going to be a long road to Vancover.
- Joined
- Mar 24, 2008
Ok, now you don't have time?
Since you didn't give me the clip, I'll show you the clip that exactly compare Yuna's flip with Miki's lip.
http://kr.youtube.com/watch?v=Iel9kjBAq2s
What do you think? If you are busy, please post your reply anytime you are available.
Last edited:
As beautifully as Ashley skated today, I'm surprised that she didn't get an "<" call on her lutz considering it didn't seem to get all the way around. I just wish the "over the top" and "anti" Yuna fans would quit it with all of the bickering (I know I played a role in that last time and I apologize).
Last edited:
Fiercemao, you are over the line.
What is your bases of the constantly perverse arguing against Yuna. So you are the only one who saw the her lip long time ago, even hundred judges and billions audiences haven't seen any wrong with her jumps until this doubtable 'e'
Last edited:
She should get an UR call as well, absolutely!
I think the entire UR/edge call is a scandalous scheme. It's absolutely ridiculous.Uh huh. You might beg to differ, but I don't think ISU members are busy poring over YouTube videos posted by Mao bots (bots, remember, not fans) and giving a toss about what they purport to show.
We'll gain further insight when we see how the judges score Yu-Na in the LP.
Yes, that 'e' was completely weird. The funny thing was that she got even +1 on her 3F-3T even the technical specialist marked 'e' on it.
