Mathman - I pondered over Eldridge in boh threads. he clearly, imo, woudl fit either category. i was hoping someone would mention in his name in either category and explain, because I can not.
I'm not a big fan of Todd. But neither do I dislike him. He is, imo, a good competitor but not the best. I prefer Galindo and believed he deserved his wins, and more, if he stayed eligible.
Bauman was probably the best for USA Mens in recent times, but he was clearly off the wall in private life which hurt his competitive edge. For me it appears Russian boys had more solid goals.
I, too, would say Paul Wylie. He is always fantastic. And I never really cared how many times he fell down. He was still a cut above the rest artistically.
Doris et al - It seems like Wylie and others who are Pro that are lyrical. No problem. Bth, My use of the term 'Best' is just to draw in posters responses.
Windspirit - I gotta agree with you on Stephan, but not exclusively. I also go strongly for Ilia Klimkin.
All those mentioned in the posts are good examples of lyrical skating. What gives me the nod to Klimkin and Lambiel is that they rise above the sterotype and skate it their way. I actually get anxious when they take the ice.
(Jeff and Johnny, need to learn to be strong as well as lyrical. A storybook Prince can also play a suave swashbuckler.)
I've just recently watched Stephane's exhibition number from Euros this year. Man, have a found a new favorite. He's my masculine version of Emanuel Sandhu. What a beautiful dancer! I thought he had great potential when I watched Euros 2002, but I've now completely fallen in love with him. Very, very few skaters can move like that, with such musicality.