2015 Cup of China Ladies Short Program

David21 · Nov 7, 2015

Mathman said:
Accually, the rules are pretty clear on this. The judges are required to compute the positive GOE features first. Let's say they give her bullet points for good height and distance, good flow throughout, element matched to the musical structure, preceding steps -- whatever. So she starts with +2 GOE before errors. Now she gets -2 for "e" and -1 for <. Total GOE = -1. Lots of ways this can turn out.

This doesn't contradict with that I've said.

Blades of Passion said:
Not wrong, a jump "looking good" in real time inherently means it is showing qualities of good flow, amplitude, air position, etc.

That's not necessarily what that means, no.

Blades of Passion said:
Nah, that's incorrect usage of GOE. Which the scoring system itself does have in the rules right now, yes. But no jump that is otherwise clean should ever receive -3 GOE just because of edge and rotation problems. If it was underrotated so much, then it is already inherently receiving a base value deduction. Same for the edge if it was an "e".

Either you don't know the rules or you think that the rukes are wrong as they are should not be applied. That's what I get from your post.

begin · Nov 7, 2015

lol this forum never disappoints. For how many more years will people nitpick Mao's jumps? And for how long will 'Yuna fans' be resurrected as the root of all haters? Stay tuned to find out!

koatcue · Nov 7, 2015

begin said:
lol this forum never disappoints. For how many more years will people nitpick Mao's jumps? And for how long will 'Yuna fans' be resurrected as the root of all haters? Stay tuned to find out!

But she does UR

2015 Cup of China Ladies Short Program

David21

begin

koatcue

Similar threads

Connect with us