- Joined
- Dec 25, 2012
Amazing!!
Apparently, I had a bit of time today to make the submitting form for the final group of 4CC Men FS event :agree:
So now you can pretend like a real judge and score performances while watching live. (You can score/edit after the event as well.)
Here you go:
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/18STHeuwHm05lmVs5vr4OOfPcDZt3y2srU6bS-X7FWfU/viewform
NOTE: The elements currently shown are planned contents (For Grant and Takahito, I couldn't fine their planned content sheets so they are based on their protocols from the Nats and GPS.). They may be different from what the skaters actually do. In that case, just score the elements in the performed order.
Also, for this one, I chose to have a deadline - you must submit your scores by Tuesday 1st March 23:59 GMT (tell me if that's too early tho). Then we'll see the final answer of we judges
I'll set up the result page and the protocol in few days time!
Ah ! I think you forgot to give -GOE scale on quad to -4 , now it is -3
if it's doable
Absolutely fantastic idea, I enjoyed it. One suggestion- in the result box, instead of showing the weighted PC score, can you show the average score that we actually gave them? I was looking at all of the PC scores on the results page and thought initially we had all given them 6's.
Please do more of these, that was lots of fun and it is interesting to see how we compare to ISU judges.
- You need to log in via google account (to prevent multiple responses) but neither your google account nor e-mail address will appear to the others.
Very cool! :thumbsup:
I'm doing something very similar to this on my blog soon:yay:. I posted a request for judges over at FSU last week and I've got a number of people interested in participating. I plan on just having 9 judges per event and doing past events (ladies only) but I love the way you've made it so that people can judge live events. You basically get an idea of the way the entire forum would vote.
I can only judge with a Google account? Sorry, but <-- 100 years old, so not experienced with this type of stuff sorry.
Nvm, I just saw
Am I the only person without google account at this forum? I just don't like giving away my phone number :noshake:
Google accounts require phone number? I have at least 6, the last one created soely for Craigslisting purposes, don't recall inputing a phone number, real or fake. But I sign up for Gmail (which is linked automatically to all things google, I believe).Am I the only person without google account at this forum? I just don't like giving away my phone number :noshake:
I can't wait to see the results. If this is what judging is like, then it would be difficult to skew the results to favor any particular skater. -the judges might be as surprised as the skaters to see the scores come out.
Here you go!
Protocol:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...j9Lft0PyiHc/pubhtml?gid=306045089&single=true
(There's a little bug again in Google spreadsheet that the borderline is not displayed properly...) (Compare with the actual protocol)
Result Page:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...9Lft0PyiHc/pubhtml?gid=1311536893&single=true
(Compare with the actual result)
I know you all know but it's for fun, it's nothing like we are right and the judges are wrong!
And again, you can vote/edit until 1st March 23:59 GMT from here (Oh I still haven't changed the planned contents to the elements that were actually performed. I'll also add videos later.). Have fun!