I agree, I don't get the comment he doesn't capture the audience either. Todd should know better from first hand experience. He's often skated at the same venues, large and small, where Evan has brought the house down. Not only does Evan sell the footwork, he sells the entire package, making the most of what he's been given to work with to completely engage the crowd. He does!
ITA with you! I'm not sure why Evan gets so much "hate" on the boards. It's ridiculous. As for Jeremy Abbot and Brandon Mroz- well I think jumping on that gun is very premature. Evan has proved time and time again that while he may not be the best skater out there and makes his share of mistakes, he never gives up on a competition or a program. I am not a fan of Evan but he has earned my respect. I also think that Evan has the best mind set for pro skating because he works on relating to the audience.