3.5/6 for me...I would also add:
You watched all of "Tessa & Scott" or "Ice Diaries" and care about what happens to those people long after.
You attend your local symphony's performances based on whether the music was used in a memorable free skate.
You dismiss bad fashion on gossip websites by saying "that's so figure skater!" in design, and can match the bad outfit to a costume.
You still think the best piece of gossip in sports in the last twenty years (besides Nancy vs. Tonya) was the Maia/Sasha/Pasha love triangle that ended with Maia bashing Pasha's head against the bar at, of all places, Spago.
You still debate the following Olympic results: ladies 1994 / 1998 / 2002 (and in 10 years' time, 2014), men's 1988 / 1992 / 1994 / 2010, pairs 1994 and 2002, ice dance 1994.
Your YouTube subscriptions include at least three dedicated to only figure skating competition and exhibition clips.