attyfan said:Was Irina first or second after the SP at the GPF?
Irina was in 2nd-she doubled her flip, I think. Mao was 1st after the SP.
attyfan said:Was Irina first or second after the SP at the GPF?
Kwanford Wife said:Now you know its pointless to argue who deserves what with skating fans... only our favorites deserve to win because we love them sooo much... what they put out on the ice during a specific competiton is irrelevant...
Red Dog said:No, but she sure skated in SLC...(which is what I was referring to, BTW)
Joesitz said:If one throws in the 'what ifs', how would Irina compare to Kimmie in the Worlds had she participated?
It's extremely difficult to compare skating from one competition to another competition. It's all about what happens at THAT competition and the other competition just doesn't count.
Joe
Joesitz said:Can't argue with your rationale, Antmanb:agree: but I stand by my point of comparing skaters from two separate competitions.
I didn't say you did. I was just reiterating my position of comparing scores from 2 different venues. It' a slippery sport in many cases.antmanb said:I don't think i made any argument against the point you made about comparing skaters from two separate competitions :scratch:
Ant
jesslily said:Angela N., Fumie S., Victoria V., Julia S.... They are really great skaters with good jumping technique. But they are never lucky enough to get the titles they deserve.