Best and worst warhorse performances | Page 5 | Golden Skate

Best and worst warhorse performances

My favourite is still this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FfcVJLcknrk (Robin Causins, 1991)
The assignment didn't specify it couldn't be a dated pro program. :)
the thing with Rach 2 is that each movement has been used to create really nice programs... I like that Cousins is using the 2nd movement here which should be done more often. What is annoying me the most is those who use all 3 movements (so 30 minutes of music) in a LP of 4 minutes... This shouldn't happen. Same with those who repeat musical phrases in ways that it just doesn't make sense or omit main themes.

This music editing for the Cousins's program was very well done. It made sense. The skating was beautiful. Thank you, I hadn't seen this performance before.
 
Hmm. Well, it was barely noticeable for me. I thought the program did justice to the music and captured the feel and emotion.
Sure, I agree, the program was well skated, Mao gave her all, and most people would not notice. OTOH, this is such a well known piece of music, it probably deserves to be called a masterpiece?... And then such an amateur cut. Why? Give the piece justice, cut it properly and try to make choreography match it in such a way that they match. This would be good choreography, right? Anyway, it's these little things in Mao's programs that make some of them not my favs, even when from purely sports point of view they are great. Nitpicking... :shrug:
 
I don't know if it's the absolute best performance of Carmen, but for me it might be: Samantha Cesario. Here is one example of it.
^ Oh, that was marvelous. Thank you for posting it. Unusual music cuts and the choreography followed the music perfectly, especially the placement of jumps.

Here is another non-traditional take (Michelle Kwan, 1999 SP). The music is not Bizet but rather the Carmen Fantasie by movie composer Franz Waxman. (Dick Button and Peggy Fleming find some points to criticize, but oh well. ;) )

 
Last edited:
I don't know if "Send in the Clowns" is a warhorse, but here are my two favorites.


 
I don't know if "Send in the Clowns" is a warhorse, but here are my two favorites.

Lol. I remember getting my eyes wet a bit with Yuna's. It was strange. My brain couldn't help but pick apart her choreography, yet to the heart it simply didn't matter.
 
Here is Sasha Cohen's finest performance ever, Swan Lake at 2004 Marshalls cheesiest. The first time she ever beat Michelle Kwan and maybe the first time she ever got through a whole program and hit every jump. :)

I had never seen that performance. And her charlotte spiral-- exquisite! Sasha was her own worst enemy; it's such a shame that she got in her way so much.

But lordy, how I miss those spirals from both her and Michelle...
 
My example will be Rhapsody on a theme of Paganini:
Good one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jk4PGcUHEFA (Mark Mitchell, 1994, AP)
Not as good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6dIVuAegpg (Yuzuru Hanyu, 2010, junior FP)
Found another one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQlC6HXZ1dg (Totmianina/Marinin, 2004 SP)
It's not a bad program, but the climax asks for a spiral sequence, not a dismount from a lift and connecting steps into a death spiral.
Of course, it's not fair to compare a 6.0 artistic program with IJS short and long programs, esp. junior ones, but I think it was not necessary that they should all be from the same scoring system, and a fair comparison?
I will not mention a recent show program that I think is very bad, let's be positive.

Lambiel was not the first to skate to Winter for sure, here are some other examples:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8bosaG3fJ8 (Carolina Kostner, from the same Olympic event)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4deFLKcHK4A (Usova/Zhulin, 1992)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVnRAWkyP5M (Surya Bonaly, 1998)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MOMDOu3xMpo (Petrova/Tikhonov, 2001)
The Mark Mitchell performance was beautifully done. I had forgotten all about him; these blasts from the past are such fun!

IMO the "Paganini" theme has to be one of the loveliest melodies ever written.
 
(One of) the best Swan Lakes.


The worst = someone dressed in half black, half white feathers and flapping their arms.

Here is one of the best-choreographed (Lori Nichol) ladies' Short Programs ever, IMHO. It's Rachmaninov piano concerto #3, not #2, but anyway... By the way there is also some music taken from a Rachmaninov piano trio -- wWkipedia says #3, by I always thought it was #4 (Dumky). Maybe @4everchan can clear that up for me?

I still remember watching that performance. It had me in tears and I wondered what Michelle could ever do to top it. Then came "Lyra Angelica."
Here is one of the best-choreographed (Lori Nichol) ladies' Short Programs ever, IMHO. It's Rachmaninov piano concerto #3, not #2, but anyway... By the way there is also some music taken from a Rachmaninov piano trio -- wWkipedia says #3, by I always thought it was #4 (Dumky). Maybe @4everchan can clear that up for me?

 
Choose a piece of music that has been overused in figure skating over the decades.

Give at least one example of an excellent interpretation of that music, and at least one example of a skater who lets the music do the artistic work for them with minimal effort toward choreography and interpretation.

There may or may not be a direct connection to the success of the elements or the quality of the skating skills. But try not to use a disastrous performance or a skater with weak skating skills as the example of poor interpretation. What I'm interested in is skaters whose interpretation of music that is supposedly easy to interpret leaves much to be desired. (Maybe they did better on other occasions or with other programs . . . or on other aspects of what's covered under IJS program components, but this one didn't really showcase interpretive skills.)

My choices:
This was an all-time great performance to music that (IMO) is structured to do a lot of the heavy lifting for the skater

I'm almost sorry that performance was so great, because it led to many other performances to the same music that were not so great.

Here are some good ones:

And some lazier attempts at interpretation

Shen/Zhou's Turandot at Worlds 2003 - Best
 
Back
Top