Ladies - Short Program

[dribbler]

Hi everyone! Can anybody please give the link to the detailed marks of the lady's short program. I really need to know what were the marks for the elements of Arina Martynova's program. Did the judges counted 3F or just 2F...
Thank you very much!

 

[enlight78]

:yes: Precisely, maybe still a little young to be pushing something like that. I don't really think she was, it was just the opening I would think. But is the network looking for something like that? I expected to hear a comment of " Moa practicing her 3x3 right in front of her older teammate Miki.... blaa blaa. Something along those lines because it seems they like to hype the Johnny / Evan thing. Thought they might take a shot at that one too.

Maybe with some of this new news about contract, I wonder if they just don't care.

One thing comes to mind about Dick, I think he is to critical of the leg wrap and some positions. I also hear "truth" but a number of negative comments during the programmes. That is Ugly" or "that is not good" could be replaced with "not her best" or "not one of the top... I have seen." It sounds petty, but ... I think I am making my point. They do say the more "gentle comments" but I believe it would be nicer to listen to if it was less negative and JUST critical....make sense???

Actually I don't think the commentators are negative enough. I find them way too gentle. If it wasn't for Dick. I wouldn't know what to expect from a good skater vs. a average skater. I think they can take a note from football or tennis commentators. They are not afraid to point out the errors in a players game.

 

[SeaniBu]

Actually I don't think the commentators are negative enough. I find them way too gentle. If it wasn't for Dick. I wouldn't know what to expect from a good skater vs. a average skater. I think they can take a note from football or tennis commentators. They are not afraid to point out the errors in a players game.

I see that point, and on some level I agree. But due to the difference of FS being a sport of beauty and expression vs. Football being aggressive and really not emphasizing elegance etc... it seems out of place to hear.


Back to the performances, one of the guys I was with shouted out "all 10s" at the end of Carolina's programme and it really took the wind from his sails when I tried explaining the scores just briefly, but when Alissa was skating, as she finished with the combo spin he was edge of his seat shouting "plus 3s, PLUS 3s!!!!! Over look the fall!!! I really like that girl." Nice sentiment:agree: Was a great finish to the programme for sure. Have to say she does look GREAT in hats.

That made me remember Sarah's pro, ah bummer. I think I intentionally forgot. Another that hurt in parts. I can only hope the best for them today (well ... technically yesterday).

 

[R.D.]

By the way, am I the only one who thinks Yu-na is a better jumper than Mao? I'm sure I'm in the minority here, because many people seems to rave about Yu-na's lyrical style while Mao is being talked about somewhat of a jumping bean with all kinds of difficult moves. However I really think Mao has the upperhand when it comes to overall presentation and style. Whereas Yuna is more fundamentally sound with consistent jumping techniques as well as the best 3-3 in the business. I love them both and hope this great rivalry continues

Yuna's 3-3 in the SP was quite amazing...it actually LOOKED like a 3-3...unlike Kimmie's where you need a double-take and instant replay.

 

[iloveaxel]

Yuna's 3-3 in the SP was quite amazing...it actually LOOKED like a 3-3...unlike Kimmie's where you need a double-take and instant replay.

Kimmie's 3+3 got dinged in long program, and rightly so. It does not look a real 3+3.

 

[blue dog]

Wait...Tugba didn't make the final cut

 

[Mathman]

Hi everyone! Can anybody please give the link to the detailed marks of the lady's short program. I really need to know what were the marks for the elements of Arina Martynova's program. Did the judges counted 3F or just 2F...

3F.

http://www.isufs.org/results/wc2007/wc07_Ladies_SP_scores.pdf