Which Poem version
- Thread starter SeaniBu
- Start date
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2006
Ice skating poetry! How rare a find!
Starting to understand there is a reason. Not many like it I 'spose. ???? Too bad no feedback, I even like negative, but nothing
.... Andy W would conceder that failed art.:frown2:
- Joined
- Jun 27, 2003
I don't think there are a lot of poetry savvy people on this board. Sure everyone loves a good ryhme or a limmerick, but as far as critiquing I don't know of anyone who feels qualified...
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2006
If someone can read and has feelings from reading IMO that would qualify. Art is for the masses, not just select groups of people. JMO- even if that is "I don't like poems that don't rhyme."
- Joined
- Jun 27, 2003
my feeling, though, is if you want a critique that is truly helpful you want someone that knows what they're talking about...
I like an accolade on my photography, but the only ones I truly take to heart are the ones by other photographers, because they actually know what I did right/wrong/otherwise and can better help...
me, I'm not into poetry and so I probably wouldn't like it even if was the best poem ever written... i don't find that helpful to you because it's not fair for me to assess something I don't care to understand... that is just as helpful as me not commenting at all.
but you've made your selection so it's a moot point now.
I like an accolade on my photography, but the only ones I truly take to heart are the ones by other photographers, because they actually know what I did right/wrong/otherwise and can better help...
me, I'm not into poetry and so I probably wouldn't like it even if was the best poem ever written... i don't find that helpful to you because it's not fair for me to assess something I don't care to understand... that is just as helpful as me not commenting at all.
but you've made your selection so it's a moot point now.
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2006
Good points Toni, I was looking for more of a "like" then critique. I should be more specific in my requests in the future.:agree:
Similar threads
- Sticky
