I know most people didn't pay much attention to Popova/Massot, but anyone who has can't be surprised that Savchenko/Massot would have a big twist - maybe surprised that they got it so quickly, but he's trained with Ingo so it's very likely that their technique is compatible....No way that's a real photo, right? It's way bigger than even V/T's!
Although I am not signing the petition myself (I don't like putting my name to things like this), I do think it is time to draw a line over the whole affair. Especially since it is starting to affect other people, as well as Germany's future chances in Pairs skating.
CaroLiza_fan
Correct me if I'm wrong but the people it affects mostly are Ingo and his students, the 2 highest profile Aliona & Bruno neither of which are German.
But Aliona does have German citizenship. Or is it not German enough? Do you consider only people born in Germany to be truly German?
For the purpose athletes I say yes, the second S/M decide to skate for France she's gonna drop her German citizenship in a flash and go get French citizenship to continue skating; it's not for some love of country, but to skate.
This is not very logical, because even though she was actually born in the Ukraine, she gave up that citizeship to skate for Germany. So she is not Ukrainian enough either? As for dropping German citizeship "in a flash", this is simply not fair to her, she seems to have been trying to remain in Germany even if she has to sit out two years because France wouldn't release Massot.
Do you know for sure that she gave up Ukrainian citizenship? People can have dual citizenship you know...
And getting French one does not automatically mean that she will drop the German one. She may end up with three citizenships. I had a Friend who had three citizenships and three passports.
I don't believe Aliona Savchenko could have represented Germany in three Olympics were she not a German citizen. She has lived in Germany for more than a decade and speaks the language. Her life is in Germany. She's German.Correct me if I'm wrong but the people it affects mostly are Ingo and his students, the 2 highest profile Aliona & Bruno neither of which are German. I would be more in favor of them putting money towards German skaters. I would like to see if they do (doubt they do give him a pension) is to put 'strings' to it; the money he gets is for/to train young and up-coming German skaters. IMO - the best thing for Germany's future in pairs skating (as in any country) is to see German skaters at the top level; I don't think it does a lot for the growth of the sport for kids (future skaters) or general audience (fans) in the country to see the top team(s) to be other nationalities. Hard-core FS fans like us who watch the sport all the time and follow it, generally have our favorites and it generally isn't limited to the skaters from our own country vs. (at least from what I get in the U.S.) casual fans who are going to watch during the Olympics, most of those people tend to stick with the skaters from their country or the special 'skater' of the Games that the media latches onto.
You're wrong about Germany - acquiring citizenship in another EU country does not require that one renounce German citizenship. Germany also allows dual citizenship in many other cases (mine included, BTW).Nope neither Germany nor Ukrain allow multiple citizenships.
The Ukrain never does as far as I know and in Germany that works only if you have plausible reasons for that. Sport probably is none of them...
You're wrong about Germany - acquiring citizenship in another EU country does not require that one renounce German citizenship. Germany also allows dual citizenship in many other cases (mine included, BTW).
Also, it's Ukraine, not The Ukraine.
Could that be due to requirements in your friend's country of origin?Okay seems to depend on the case then 'cause a friend of mine was not allowed to gain German citizenship and keep her original one at the same time.
But thanks for infoming me. So who knows it might work in her case.
And I agree with you that she is German due to her life there.
I find it wrong to say she's not German 'cause she just wasn't born there.
Could that be due to requirements in your friend's country of origin?
It's definitely wrong to consider someone to be a second-rate citizen (or not a citizen at all) because they weren't born or didn't grow up in the country where they end up living and holding citizenship.